Thinking clearly: biases and good habits of mind
Good reasoning is not only about logic; it also means avoiding common fallacies and mental biases. Philosophers and psychologists have catalogued the traps that mislead us.
Informal fallacies
Informal fallacies are errors in reasoning that depend on content rather than form. They are persuasive because they often feel reasonable. Learning their names is less important than recognising the move: replacing evidence with pressure, attacking something other than the claim, or assuming what needs to be proved.
Fallacies of relevance
Ad hominem attacks the person instead of the argument: 'She's not an economist, so her tax argument is wrong.' Appeals to popularity claim something is true because many believe it. Appeals to inappropriate authority cite someone outside their expertise. Red herrings change the subject. In each case the reason given does not bear on the truth of the conclusion.
Fallacies of presumption
Begging the question assumes the conclusion in the premises. A false dilemma presents two options when more exist: 'Either we ban cars or accept pollution.' The slippery slope claims a small step will inevitably lead to disaster without showing why. Hasty generalisation draws broad conclusions from a few cases. Post hoc reasoning assumes that because B followed A, A caused B.
The straw man and charity
A straw man misrepresents an opponent's view as weaker or more extreme than it is, then refutes the distortion. The principle of charity asks us to interpret others' arguments in their strongest reasonable form before criticising them, sometimes called 'steelmanning'. Charitable interpretation makes disagreements more productive and conclusions more trustworthy.
Cognitive biases
Psychologists such as Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky documented systematic biases. Confirmation bias leads us to seek and favour evidence for what we already believe. Anchoring makes the first number we hear distort later estimates. The availability heuristic judges how common something is by how easily examples come to mind, so vivid but rare events, such as plane crashes, seem more frequent than they are.
Motivated reasoning
Motivated reasoning means reaching conclusions we want and then finding reasons for them. It affects highly educated people too, sometimes more, since they are better at constructing justifications. Group identity strengthens it: people often evaluate evidence differently depending on whether it supports their political or social group's views.
Habits of good thinking
Useful habits include stating the strongest version of opposing views, asking what evidence would change your mind, distinguishing how confident you feel from how strong the evidence is, considering base rates, separating facts from interpretations, and being willing to say 'I don't know'. Intellectual humility, recognising the limits of your knowledge, is linked in research to better judgement and more open discussion.
Worked example
A social media post says: 'Since the new mayor took office, burglaries have risen. Clearly her policies caused it, and anyone who disagrees just hates our city.' The post commits post hoc reasoning (sequence is not causation, and burglary trends may have other causes) and attacks critics' motives instead of their arguments, a form of ad hominem. A better approach would compare trends with similar cities and examine which policies changed.
Key takeaways
Informal fallacies depend on content and persuade by seeming reasonable. Fallacies of relevance include ad hominem, appeals to popularity or inappropriate authority, and red herrings. Fallacies of presumption include begging the question, false dilemmas, slippery slopes, hasty generalisations, and post hoc reasoning. Avoid straw men; apply the principle of charity. Cognitive biases include confirmation bias, anchoring, and availability. Motivated reasoning bends evidence towards desired conclusions. Good habits: steelman opponents, ask what would change your mind, consider base rates, and practise intellectual humility.
Flashcard
Reasoning error based on content
Check your understanding
'You can't trust his climate argument; he drives a big car.' Which fallacy is this?
