What counts as deviance
Deviance is behaviour that violates social norms. What counts as deviant depends on time, place, and who has the power to define it.
Defining deviance
Deviance is any behaviour, belief, or condition that violates significant social norms in a group or society. It ranges from minor breaches, such as wearing pyjamas to a formal dinner, to serious crimes. Deviance is not a quality of an act itself but of how others respond to it: the same act can be acceptable in one setting and deviant in another.
Relativity of deviance
Deviance varies across cultures and history. Tattoos were once widely seen as deviant in many Western societies but have become mainstream; smoking moved from glamorous to stigmatised; same-sex relationships were criminalised in many countries until recent decades and remain so in some. Sociologists study how and why definitions of deviance change.
Crime
Crime is deviance that violates formally enacted laws. Not all deviance is crime, such as picking one's nose in public, and not all crime is considered deviant by everyone, such as minor speeding. Criminologists study the causes, patterns, and consequences of crime and society's responses to it.
Social control
Social control refers to the mechanisms that encourage conformity. Informal social control works through family, friends, and community: praise, gossip, and disapproval. Formal social control is exercised by institutions such as police, courts, and prisons. Most people conform mainly because they have internalised norms and care what others think, not out of fear of punishment.
Stigma
Erving Goffman's Stigma (1963) described stigma as an attribute that deeply discredits a person, reducing them 'from a whole and usual person to a tainted, discounted one'. Stigmas include physical differences, perceived character flaws such as a criminal record or addiction, and group identities. Stigmatised people manage information about themselves to avoid discrimination.
Medicalisation
Medicalisation is the process by which behaviours once seen as moral failings or crimes are redefined as medical problems, such as alcoholism, which came to be treated as a disease, and attention difficulties diagnosed as ADHD. Medicalisation can reduce blame and open access to treatment, but critics argue it can also expand professional control and individualise social problems.
Positive functions of deviance
Durkheim argued that deviance is normal and serves social functions. Responding to deviance affirms shared values, clarifies moral boundaries, unites people against wrongdoing, and can encourage social change: today's deviance, such as civil rights protests or early campaigns for women's suffrage, may become tomorrow's accepted morality.
Worked example
Consider skipping meals for days. In a hospital, it might be labelled an eating disorder (medicalisation); during Ramadan, daytime fasting is a respected religious practice; for a hunger striker, it is political protest; and for a person in poverty, it reflects lack of food. The same behaviour is judged differently depending on context and meaning, showing that deviance depends on social definitions, not the act alone.
Key takeaways
Deviance violates significant norms and depends on social reactions rather than acts themselves. It varies across cultures and history, as with tattoos, smoking, and same-sex relationships. Crime is deviance that violates law. Informal and formal social control encourage conformity, mostly through internalised norms. Goffman's Stigma (1963) describes discrediting attributes and their management. Medicalisation redefines behaviour as illness, with mixed effects. Durkheim saw deviance as normal and functional: it clarifies boundaries, unites people, and can drive change.
Flashcard
Violation of significant social norms
Check your understanding
Why do sociologists say deviance depends on social reactions rather than acts themselves?
