Theories of deviance
Why do people break rules? Sociological theories explain deviance through social structure, learning, labelling, and power rather than individual wickedness alone.
Merton's strain theory
Robert Merton (1938) argued that deviance arises when society emphasises goals, such as financial success, but blocks access to legitimate means of achieving them. People adapt in five ways: conformity (accept goals and means), innovation (accept goals, use illegitimate means, as in theft), ritualism (abandon goals but follow rules), retreatism (reject both, as in some drug use), and rebellion (replace both with new ones).
Social disorganisation
The Chicago School, notably Clifford Shaw and Henry McKay in the 1940s, found that high crime rates persisted in certain city neighbourhoods even as different ethnic groups moved through them. They argued that poverty, population turnover, and weak community institutions undermine informal social control. Later work by Robert Sampson emphasised collective efficacy, neighbours' willingness to intervene for the common good.
Differential association
Edwin Sutherland's differential association theory (1939) holds that deviance is learned through interaction with others, especially close groups: people learn techniques, motives, and attitudes favourable to breaking the law. A person becomes delinquent when exposed to more definitions favourable to law violation than unfavourable ones. Sutherland also coined 'white-collar crime'.
Control theory
Travis Hirschi's social control theory (1969) asked why most people do not commit crimes. His answer: social bonds. Attachment to others, commitment to conventional goals, involvement in conventional activities, and belief in society's rules all restrain deviance. When bonds weaken, people are freer to deviate.
Labelling theory
Labelling theorists, such as Howard Becker in Outsiders (1963), argued that deviance is created when people label others as deviant. Edwin Lemert distinguished primary deviance, initial acts that may not affect self-image, from secondary deviance, when a person accepts a deviant label and acts accordingly. Labels can become self-fulfilling, limiting opportunities and pushing people towards deviant identities.
Conflict and critical theories
Conflict theorists argue that laws reflect the interests of powerful groups, and that the powerful are better able to resist labels. Crimes of the poor, such as street theft, are policed heavily, while corporate crimes, such as fraud and environmental damage, often cause greater harm but receive lighter punishment. Critical criminologists examine how race, class, and gender shape who is criminalised.
The Saints and the Roughnecks
William Chambliss's 1973 study followed two groups of boys in an American high school. The middle-class 'Saints' committed frequent delinquency but were seen as good boys sowing wild oats; the working-class 'Roughnecks' were labelled troublemakers and arrested often. The labels shaped their futures: most Saints went to university, while several Roughnecks ended up in prison, illustrating labelling and class bias.
Worked example
Explain a teenager's shoplifting with each theory. Strain: she wants fashionable clothes valued by peers but lacks money. Differential association: her friends taught her techniques and justifications. Control: her bonds to school and family have weakened. Labelling: once caught and called a thief, she may accept that identity. Conflict: her offence is punished more harshly than a company's wage theft affecting thousands. Each theory highlights different causes and policy responses.
Key takeaways
Merton's strain theory (1938) explains deviance as adaptations to blocked goals: conformity, innovation, ritualism, retreatism, and rebellion. Social disorganisation theory (Shaw and McKay) links crime to weak neighbourhood institutions; Sampson stressed collective efficacy. Sutherland's differential association (1939) says deviance is learned. Hirschi's control theory (1969) emphasises attachment, commitment, involvement, and belief. Becker (1963) and Lemert's labelling theory distinguishes primary and secondary deviance. Conflict theories show how power shapes laws and enforcement, illustrated by Chambliss's Saints and Roughnecks (1973).
Flashcard
Deviance from blocked goals and means
Check your understanding
In Merton's strain theory, a person who wants wealth but steals to get it is engaged in:
