Accounting › Section Y · Balanced scorecard and performance measures › Topic Y.3
The balanced scorecard
Financial results tell managers how the business did; they say little about how it will do. The balanced scorecard sets financial measures beside three other views of performance and links them all to strategy.
Beyond the financial numbers
ROI, residual income and EVA, from Return on investment, residual income, and EVA, measure results that have already happened. They are lagging indicators: by the time profit falls, the causes, such as unhappy customers, slow processes or untrained staff, have been at work for months. Why measure performance, and what makes a good measure showed that financial measures alone can also reward short-term cuts. The balanced scorecard answers both problems. It keeps financial measures but adds measures of the activities that drive future financial results, and it organises all of them around the company's strategy.
Where the idea came from
Robert Kaplan, a professor at Harvard Business School, and David Norton, a management consultant, introduced the balanced scorecard in a 1992 Harvard Business Review article. They argued that managers should see performance from four perspectives at once, each tied to a broad question. Financial: how do we look to shareholders? Customer: how do customers see us? Internal business process: what must we excel at? The fourth, framed in that first article as innovation and learning and now usually called learning and growth: can we keep improving and creating value? The word balanced refers to the mix of financial and nonfinancial, and short- and long-term, measures.
The financial perspective
The financial perspective asks whether the strategy is improving the bottom line. Typical measures include revenue growth, operating margin, cost per unit, cash flow, return on investment, residual income and economic value added. These are mostly lagging measures, and they remain the scorecard's final test: improvements in the other three perspectives are supposed to show up here eventually. If customer, process and learning measures all improve for several years while financial results do not, the company should question whether its strategy, or its assumed links between the perspectives, is sound.
The customer perspective
The customer perspective asks how the company is doing with the customers it has chosen to serve. Common measures are customer satisfaction scores, retention or repeat-purchase rates, number of new customers, market share in target segments and on-time delivery. The key word is chosen: a company competing on low price and one competing on premium service should not measure the same things. A premium coffee roaster may track freshness complaints and café retention; a discount grocer may track price comparisons and checkout waiting times. Customer measures are often leading indicators of revenue.
The internal business process perspective
The internal business process perspective asks which processes the company must perform exceptionally well to satisfy customers and shareholders. Measures here include defect rates, rework, cycle time from order to delivery, machine downtime, cost per unit and the time needed to develop new products. Standard costs and the variances in How companies use variance analysis belong naturally in this perspective. The aim is to measure the few processes that matter most to the strategy, not every process the company runs, so that attention goes where improvement will reach customers.
The learning and growth perspective
The learning and growth perspective looks at the foundations that let the company improve: its people, systems and culture. Measures include training hours per employee, employee skills and certifications, staff turnover, employee satisfaction, the share of employees with access to the information they need, and the number of improvement suggestions adopted. These are the most forward-looking measures on the scorecard and the easiest to neglect, because cutting training or system upgrades raises this year's profit. Including them makes that trade-off visible.
Cause and effect: leading and lagging
The perspectives are meant to form a chain of cause and effect. Better-trained staff (learning and growth) make fewer mistakes and work faster (internal processes), which keeps customers satisfied and loyal (customer), which raises revenue and margins (financial). Measures early in the chain are leading indicators, because they move first; measures at the end are lagging indicators. Kaplan and Norton later developed strategy maps, diagrams that draw these links between objectives explicitly. A scorecard whose measures are not connected this way is just a list of numbers, not a description of strategy.
Worked example: Brambleton's scorecard
Brambleton Coffee Roasters supplies freshly roasted beans to independent cafés, competing on freshness and reliable delivery. 1. Strategy: be the cafés' most reliable source of fresh coffee. 2. Learning and growth: objective, skilled roasters; measure, training hours per roaster; target, 20 a year. 3. Internal process: objective, consistent roasts delivered fast; measures, rejected batches below 2% and roast-to-door time under 48 hours. 4. Customer: objective, loyal cafés; measures, on-time deliveries of at least 96% and café retention of at least 90%. 5. Financial: objective, profitable growth; measures, revenue growth of 8% and operating margin of 12%. 6. The chain runs from training to roast quality and speed, then to loyal cafés and growth.
Worked example: reading the warning signs
A year later Brambleton missed its revenue target, growing 3% instead of 8%. The scorecard shows why. 1. Training fell from 20 to 12 hours per roaster after a cost-cutting drive. 2. Rejected batches rose from 1.5% to 3.2%, so more coffee had to be re-roasted. 3. On-time deliveries fell from 97% to 91%, because re-roasting delayed shipments. 4. Café retention fell from 92% to 86%. With 400 café accounts, that is \(400 \times (0.92 - 0.86) = 24\) more lost cafés. 5. At an average of $9,000 a year each, that is \(24 \times 9{,}000 = 216{,}000\), or $216,000 of annual revenue lost. 6. The leading indicator, training, moved first; restoring it is the place to start.
Cascading and using the scorecard
A company-wide scorecard is broad. Most users cascade it: each division, team and sometimes each employee builds a scorecard whose objectives support the level above, using measures that person can influence. Good practice keeps the number of measures manageable, sets a target and a responsible person for each, reviews results regularly in management meetings, and changes measures when strategy changes. Linking bonuses to scorecard results can sharpen attention, but brings back the risk of gaming. Not-for-profit and public organisations also use scorecards, often adapting them so that mission, rather than profit, sits at the top.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating the scorecard as a long list of measures without cause-and-effect links to strategy. Second, copying another company's measures instead of choosing ones that fit your own strategy and customers. Third, using too many measures, so none gets attention. Fourth, dropping the financial perspective or never checking whether nonfinancial gains reach the financial results. Fifth, measuring things managers cannot influence. Sixth, mixing up leading and lagging indicators: profit is a result, not an early warning.
Key takeaways
The balanced scorecard, introduced by Kaplan and Norton in 1992, measures performance from four perspectives: financial, customer, internal business process, and learning and growth. Financial measures are mainly lagging; the other perspectives supply leading indicators of future results. The perspectives should form a cause-and-effect chain from people and systems to processes, customers and financial results, all tied to strategy. Scorecards are cascaded through the organisation, kept to a manageable number of measures, and reviewed against targets.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Performance measured from four linked perspectives tied to strategy
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
In which balanced scorecard perspective does the measure 'percentage of products returned for defects' most naturally belong?
Question 2 of 5
Which of these is best described as a leading indicator of future profit?
Question 3 of 5
A distributor has 250 customer accounts averaging $12,000 of revenue a year. Retention falls from 94% to 90%. About how much annual revenue does the extra loss represent?
Question 4 of 5
What did Kaplan and Norton mean by calling the scorecard 'balanced'?
Question 5 of 5
A company's training hours, defect rates and customer satisfaction have improved for three years, but profit has not. What does the balanced scorecard approach suggest?
