Accounting › Section Y · Balanced scorecard and performance measures › Topic Y.2
Return on investment, residual income, and EVA
An investment centre manager controls assets as well as profit, so the measure must charge for the money tied up. Return on investment, residual income and economic value added each do this in a different way, with different side effects.
Measuring an investment centre
Types of responsibility centers described the investment centre: a unit whose manager controls revenues, costs and the assets used, such as a division that can buy equipment or open sites. Profit alone is not a fair measure for such a unit. A division earning $480,000 on $2.4 million of assets is doing better than one earning $500,000 on $10 million, because capital has a cost: the money could have been used elsewhere. Three measures relate profit to the capital behind it. Return on investment is a percentage, residual income a dollar amount, and economic value added a refined version of residual income.
Return on investment
Return on investment (ROI) divides a division's operating income by the operating assets it uses:
Operating income is income before interest and taxes, because financing and tax decisions are usually made at head office. Operating assets are the assets used in the division's operations, such as cash, receivables, inventory and equipment, averaged over the year: beginning plus ending balance, divided by 2. Assets held for other purposes, such as land kept for future use, are left out. Because ROI is a percentage, it compares divisions of different sizes.
Margin times turnover
The DuPont approach, met for return on equity in An overview of financial ratios, splits ROI into two drivers:
Margin is operating income divided by sales: how much profit each sales dollar keeps. Turnover is sales divided by average operating assets: how many sales dollars each dollar of assets generates. Sales cancel when the two are multiplied, leaving the basic formula. The split shows how a division earns its return. A jeweller typically has a high margin and low turnover; a grocery chain a thin margin and high turnover. Both can earn the same ROI.
Worked example: Fennick's two divisions
Fennick Outdoor Group has two divisions. Trail had sales of $4,000,000, operating income of $480,000 and average operating assets of $2,400,000. Marine had sales of $6,000,000, operating income of $450,000 and average operating assets of $3,000,000. 1. Trail margin: \(480{,}000 \div 4{,}000{,}000 = 12\%\); turnover: \(4{,}000{,}000 \div 2{,}400{,}000 \approx 1.67\). 2. Trail ROI: \(480{,}000 \div 2{,}400{,}000 = 20\%\), matching \(12\% \times 1.67 \approx 20\%\). 3. Marine margin: 7.5%; turnover: \(6{,}000{,}000 \div 3{,}000{,}000 = 2.0\). 4. Marine ROI: \(7.5\% \times 2.0 = 15\%\). Marine turns its assets over faster, but its thin margin leaves it with the lower return.
Raising ROI, and the traps
A manager can raise ROI by increasing sales, cutting expenses or reducing operating assets. If Trail sold $200,000 of idle equipment, its ROI would rise to \(480{,}000 \div 2{,}200{,}000 \approx 21.8\%\); cutting $40,000 of costs would give \(520{,}000 \div 2{,}400{,}000 \approx 21.7\%\). Some routes are traps. When assets are measured at net book value, depreciation shrinks the denominator each year, so ROI rises with no real improvement, and replacing old equipment makes it fall. Some companies use gross book value, original cost, to avoid this. Cutting research or maintenance also lifts ROI in the short run while harming the future.
ROI can reject good projects
ROI's biggest weakness is that it can push managers to turn down investments the company wants. Fennick requires a minimum return of 12% on new investment. Suppose both divisions can invest $500,000 in a project earning $85,000 a year, an ROI of 17%. For the company it is worth doing, since 17% beats 12%. For Trail's manager it is not: divisional ROI would fall from 20% to \(565{,}000 \div 2{,}900{,}000 \approx 19.5\%\). Marine's manager would gladly accept, because Marine's ROI would rise to \(535{,}000 \div 3{,}500{,}000 \approx 15.3\%\). The best-performing division rejects the project. That is a failure of goal congruence.
Residual income
Residual income (RI) is operating income minus a charge for the capital used, at the minimum required rate of return:
Any project that earns more than the required rate adds to RI, so a manager judged on RI accepts every such project. For Fennick's project, \(85{,}000 - 12\% \times 500{,}000 = 25{,}000\), so Trail's RI rises by $25,000 whatever its current ROI. RI has its own weakness: as a dollar amount, it favours large divisions, so it is fairer for comparing a division with its own budget or past results than with a smaller division.
Economic value added
Economic value added (EVA) is a trademarked version of residual income, popularised by the consulting firm Stern Stewart & Co. It charges for capital at the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) and uses after-tax figures:
NOPAT is net operating profit after taxes, operating income times one minus the tax rate. Invested capital is often operating assets less current liabilities that carry no interest, such as accounts payable. WACC weights the after-tax cost of debt and the cost of equity by their shares of total capital. Practitioners often make further adjustments, which vary from firm to firm.
Worked example: Fennick's EVA
Fennick's capital is 40% debt at a 7% interest rate and 60% equity whose shareholders expect 11%. The tax rate is assumed to be 25%. 1. After-tax cost of debt: \(7\% \times (1 - 0.25) = 5.25\%\). 2. WACC: debt adds \(0.4 \times 5.25\% = 2.1\%\) and equity \(0.6 \times 11\% = 6.6\%\), so WACC is 8.7%. 3. Trail NOPAT: \(480{,}000 \times 0.75 = 360{,}000\). Its invested capital is $2,400,000 of assets less $400,000 of non-interest-bearing current liabilities, so $2,000,000. 4. Trail's capital charge is \(8.7\% \times 2{,}000{,}000 = 174{,}000\), so EVA is \(360{,}000 - 174{,}000 = 186{,}000\). 5. Marine, with $2,500,000 of capital: \(337{,}500 - 217{,}500 = 120{,}000\). Both divisions create value for shareholders.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, using net income, after interest and tax, in ROI or RI instead of operating income. Second, using ending assets when the measure calls for average operating assets. Third, assuming a project with an ROI above the required rate will be accepted by a manager judged on ROI. Fourth, comparing RI across divisions of very different sizes. Fifth, using the pre-tax interest rate as the cost of debt in WACC. Sixth, forgetting that rising ROI from depreciation alone is not better performance.
Key takeaways
ROI is operating income divided by average operating assets, and equals margin times turnover. It allows comparison across sizes but can lead high-ROI managers to reject projects that beat the company's required return. Residual income is operating income minus the required rate times average operating assets; it encourages every project above that rate but favours large units. EVA is NOPAT minus WACC times invested capital, a residual income measured after tax at the full cost of capital. Each depends on how income and assets are defined, so definitions must be consistent.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A unit whose manager controls revenues, costs and assets
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A division has sales of $2,000,000, operating income of $160,000 and average operating assets of $1,000,000. What are its margin, turnover and ROI?
Question 2 of 5
A division earns operating income of $300,000 on average operating assets of $2,000,000. The required rate of return is 11%. What is its residual income?
Question 3 of 5
A division's ROI is 22% and the company's required return is 14%. A project offers an 18% ROI. How would a manager judged only on ROI probably respond?
Question 4 of 5
Operating income is $600,000, the tax rate is 25%, invested capital is $4,000,000 and WACC is 9%. What is EVA?
Question 5 of 5
Debt is 30% of capital at a 10% interest rate, equity is 70% at a 12% cost, and the tax rate is 20%. What is the WACC?
