Accounting › Section T · Budgeting › Topic T.5
Using budgets to evaluate goals
Once the period is over, the budget becomes a yardstick. Comparing actual results with the right budget shows which goals were met, separates the effect of volume from the quality of cost control, and points managers to the few differences worth investigating.
From plan to performance report
A budget sets goals before the period; a performance report compares actual results with them afterwards. Did the company earn the profit it planned? Which revenues or costs differed, by how much, and why? Each difference between an actual and a budgeted amount is a variance. A variance does not prove that anything went wrong or right. It shows where to look, so managers can fix problems, repeat successes and set better budgets next time. The quality of the answer depends on choosing the right budget to compare with.
Favourable and unfavourable variances
A variance is favourable (F) when it makes operating income higher than budgeted: revenue above budget, or a cost below budget. It is unfavourable (U) when it makes income lower: revenue below budget, or a cost above budget. So a $500 cost overrun and a $500 revenue shortfall are both unfavourable, while a $500 cost saving is favourable. Reports often show the amount with an F or U label, because a bare plus or minus sign means opposite things for revenue and cost lines.
Quenby's March results
Quenby Ceramics, whose flexible budget appears in "Flexible budgets", planned to sell 10,000 mugs at $14 in March 2027 for operating income of $30,000. It actually sold 11,000 mugs, after giving a large retailer a discount that brought the average price to $13.80, so revenue was $151,800. Actual costs were: materials $28,600, labour $31,900, variable overhead $11,600, shipping and commissions $5,300, fixed manufacturing overhead $23,000 and fixed selling and administrative costs $17,500. Total costs were $117,900 and operating income $33,900.
The trouble with the static comparison
Against the static budget, income is \(33{,}900 - 30{,}000 = 3{,}900\) favourable, which sounds good. Costs tell the opposite story: \(117{,}900 - 110{,}000 = 7{,}900\) unfavourable, which sounds like poor cost control. Neither conclusion is safe, because Quenby made and sold 1,000 more mugs than planned. Extra mugs should cost more to make, so the static budget mixes two different things: the effect of selling more, and how well revenue and costs were managed at the volume achieved. The production manager should not be blamed for costs caused by successful selling.
Worked example: against the flexible budget
1. Flex the budget to 11,000 mugs: revenue \(14 \times 11{,}000 = 154{,}000\), variable costs at their per-mug rates, fixed costs unchanged.
2. Variances: revenue 2,200 U, materials 1,100 U, labour 1,100 F, variable overhead 600 U, shipping 200 F, fixed overhead 1,000 U, fixed selling 500 F. 3. Costs in total are only \(117{,}900 - 117{,}000 = 900\) U, not 7,900.
Splitting the static-budget variance
The difference between actual and static operating income, the static-budget variance, splits into two parts:
The sales-volume variance, flexible-budget income minus static-budget income, shows the effect of selling a different quantity at budgeted prices and costs. The flexible-budget variance, actual income minus flexible-budget income, shows how well prices and costs were managed at the volume achieved. The first is mainly a question for the sales team; the second is shared between sales, for prices, and the managers who control each cost.
Worked example: Quenby's two variances
1. Sales-volume variance: \(37{,}000 - 30{,}000 = 7{,}000\) F. Check: 1,000 extra mugs at $7 of contribution margin each give \(1{,}000 \times 7 = 7{,}000\). 2. Flexible-budget variance: \(33{,}900 - 37{,}000 = 3{,}100\) U, made up of the 2,200 U revenue variance and 900 U net cost variances. 3. Total: \(7{,}000\ \text{F} - 3{,}100\ \text{U} = 3{,}900\) F, which matches the static-budget comparison. 4. Reading it: higher volume added $7,000; the discount and the cost overruns gave back $3,100.
Interpreting the variances
Favourable is not automatically good, and unfavourable is not automatically bad. The 20-cent discount cost $2,200 of revenue, but if it won the retailer's extra order, it helped earn the $7,000 volume variance, so the sales manager's decision may have been sound. Labour came in $1,100 under, while materials ran $1,100 over: perhaps workers rushed and wasted clay, or a new glaze was quicker to apply but used more material. Only investigation tells. "Materials variances" and "Labor variances" split these amounts into price and quantity effects.
Worked example: which variances to investigate
Managers use management by exception: they investigate only significant variances. Quenby's illustrative rule is to look into any variance over $1,000 or over 5% of the flexible amount. 1. Revenue: 2,200 is over $1,000, so investigate. 2. Materials: 1,100, investigate. 3. Labour: 1,100 F; favourable variances are checked too, so investigate. 4. Variable overhead: \(600 \div 11{,}000 \approx 5.5\%\), investigate. 5. Fixed overhead: exactly $1,000, about 4.5%, so not over either limit. 6. Shipping (3.6%) and fixed selling (2.8%) are also below both limits. Four of seven lines get a follow-up.
Budgets, incentives and ethics
When bonuses depend on beating the budget, managers face pressure to game it: padding estimates with slack, pulling next month's sales into this month, delaying needed spending such as maintenance, or spending a leftover budget before year-end so it is not cut. These moves make reports look better without improving the business. Research on budget manipulation suggests that formal ethics codes, ethics training and good role models can reduce it, as can evaluating managers on items they control; the standards in "Managerial accountants: roles, skills, and ethics" require accountants to report results honestly. Nonfinancial goals, such as quality and customer satisfaction, are covered in "The balanced scorecard".
Common mistakes to avoid
First, comparing actual costs with the static budget when volume changed. Second, labelling variances by sign alone: revenue above budget is favourable, a cost above budget is unfavourable. Third, treating every favourable variance as good news and ignoring it. Fourth, forgetting that the sales-volume and flexible-budget variances must add up to the static-budget variance. Fifth, blaming a manager for a variance caused by someone else's decision, such as a sales discount.
Key takeaways
A variance is the difference between actual and budgeted amounts: favourable when it raises operating income, unfavourable when it lowers it. Static-budget comparisons mix volume with control, so performance is judged against a flexible budget at the actual activity level. The static-budget variance equals the sales-volume variance plus the flexible-budget variance; Quenby's was 7,000 F plus 3,100 U, or 3,900 F. Variances are signals to investigate, often by exception, not verdicts, and budget-based rewards must be designed so they do not tempt managers to game the numbers.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Difference between an actual amount and a budgeted amount
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Actual shipping costs were $5,300 against a flexible budget of $5,500. What is the variance?
Question 2 of 5
A static budget assumed 2,000 units; 2,300 were sold. Contribution margin is $9 per unit at budgeted prices and costs. What is the sales-volume variance?
Question 3 of 5
Static-budget operating income was $30,000, flexible-budget income at actual volume was $37,000 and actual income was $33,900. What is the flexible-budget variance?
Question 4 of 5
Why can comparing actual costs with the static budget mislead managers about cost control?
Question 5 of 5
A company investigates any variance over $1,000 or over 5% of the flexible amount. Which variance should be investigated?
