Accounting › Section X · Capital budgeting decisions › Topic X.1

Capital investment decisions

Buying a machine, opening a branch or launching a product ties up a large sum for years. Capital investment decisions settle which of these long-term projects a company funds, and this topic sets out the process and the cash flows every later method relies on.

What a capital investment is

Capital investment, often called capital budgeting, is spending on long-lived assets that should produce benefits for several years: new equipment, replacements for worn machinery, a new building, a new product line or entry into a new market. An operating expense keeps today's business running and is expensed in the period. A capital expenditure is recorded as an asset and, except for land, depreciated over its useful life, as described in Tangible and intangible assets, capitalized costs. Three features make these decisions hard. The sums are large, the benefits arrive over many years and are uncertain, and once the money is spent the choice is slow and costly to reverse.

Kinds of capital projects

Most proposals fall into a few groups. Replacement projects swap a worn or outdated asset for a new one. Expansion projects add capacity for existing products. New-product and new-market projects take the business somewhere it has not been. Cost-reduction projects, such as automation or energy-efficient lighting, lower running costs. Required projects meet safety or environmental rules; they usually go ahead whatever the numbers, so the analysis looks for the cheapest way to comply. Projects are also independent or mutually exclusive. Independent projects can all be accepted together. Mutually exclusive projects compete for the same need, such as three quotes for one new delivery van, so accepting one rules out the others.

A step-by-step process

Companies follow a disciplined sequence so that big commitments are not made on instinct. 1. Identify needs and opportunities, from worn equipment to new markets. 2. Estimate each proposal's cash flows: what it costs, what it brings in or saves, and when. 3. Screen the proposals against minimum standards. 4. Rank the proposals that pass. 5. Decide and fund the chosen projects within the capital budget. 6. Carry out a post-audit: once a project has run for a while, compare its actual results with the forecasts. Post-audits reveal over-optimistic estimates and make the people who prepare future proposals more careful.

Screening and preference decisions

Steps 3 and 4 are two different kinds of decision. A screening decision asks whether a proposal meets a minimum standard, such as paying back its cost within four years or earning at least a required return. Proposals that fail are dropped. A preference decision ranks the proposals that passed, so the best are funded first. The minimum return a project must earn is the hurdle rate, or required rate of return. It is often based on the cost of capital, the return that the company's lenders and shareholders expect on the money they supply, with a higher rate set for riskier projects.

Limited resources and capital rationing

Most companies have more promising ideas than money. Capital rationing means working within a fixed budget for capital spending, so some worthwhile projects must wait. Money is not the only limit: projects need managers to oversee them, staff time for installation and training, and time to arrange financing. Under rationing, the goal is the combination of projects that adds the most value within the budget, which is not always the same as funding the single best project first.

Which cash flows count

Capital budgeting works with cash flows, not accounting income, and only with incremental cash flows: amounts that change if the project goes ahead. The initial outlay includes the purchase price, delivery, installation, training and any extra working capital, such as added inventory, less cash from selling an asset being replaced. Operating cash flows are the extra revenue or cost savings minus the extra cash costs. Terminal cash flows include salvage value and the release of working capital at the end. Sunk costs are left out, as Relevant information and sunk costs explains; opportunity costs, such as rent forgone on space the project uses, are included. Depreciation is not a cash payment. This section ignores income taxes unless a problem states them.

Worked example: a replacement decision's cash flows

Quillfield Printworks is considering a new press costing $84,000, plus $6,000 to install. It would need $5,000 more paper stock, recovered when the press is retired. The old press can be sold today for $12,000; its book value is $20,000. The new press saves $22,000 a year for 6 years and has a salvage value of $8,000. Taxes are ignored. 1. Year 0:

-84{,}000 - 6{,}000 - 5{,}000 + 12{,}000 = -83{,}000

2. The $20,000 book value is sunk: it reflects money spent years ago and is the same whatever Quillfield decides, so it is left out. 3. Years 1 to 5: $22,000 each. 4. Year 6: \(22{,}000 + 8{,}000 + 5{,}000 = 35{,}000\). 5. Check: the net total over the life is

-83{,}000 + 5 \times 22{,}000 + 35{,}000 = 62{,}000

before allowing for the time value of money.

Worked example: screening and ranking under a budget

Bramblewood Foods has a $250,000 capital budget and a 10% hurdle rate. Analysts estimate the returns of four independent projects: A costs $120,000 and returns 14%; B costs $90,000 and returns 8%; C costs $100,000 and returns 12%; D costs $60,000 and returns 16%. 1. Screen: B returns less than 10%, so it is dropped. 2. Rank the rest by return: D, then A, then C. 3. Fund in order: D and A together cost $180,000, leaving $70,000. 4. C needs $100,000, so it does not fit. 5. Check the alternatives: A and C together ($220,000) would also fit. A ranking by rate alone cannot say which pair adds more value; Comparing capital budgeting methods introduces a better tool for that.

Beyond the numbers

Qualitative factors can outweigh a close calculation: fit with strategy, product quality, customer service, flexibility to change plans later, employee safety and morale, environmental effects, legal risk and reputation. Estimates are also uncertain, and the managers proposing a project often hope to see it approved, which can bias forecasts upward. Sensitivity analysis changes one assumption at a time, such as savings 20% lower than forecast, to see whether the decision still holds. Scenario analysis builds best, expected and worst cases. Independent review of the forecasts and regular post-audits help keep the process honest.

Common mistakes to avoid

Counting a sunk cost, such as the book value of an old machine, as if it could still be avoided. Using accounting net income where the method calls for cash flows. Forgetting extra working capital at the start and its recovery at the end. Leaving out the cash from selling the asset being replaced. Treating mutually exclusive projects as if they could all be accepted. Under a fixed budget, funding projects strictly by rank without checking whether another combination fits better. Skipping the post-audit, which is the only way to learn whether the forecasts were realistic.

Key takeaways

Capital investments are large, long-lived and hard to reverse. Projects may be replacements, expansions, new products or markets, cost reductions or required projects, and they are either independent or mutually exclusive. The process runs from identifying needs and estimating cash flows through screening, ranking, funding and a post-audit. Screening applies a minimum standard such as the hurdle rate; preference decisions rank the survivors. Analysis uses incremental cash flows: the initial outlay, operating flows and terminal flows, with sunk costs excluded and opportunity costs included. Capital rationing means choosing the best combination within a budget.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Capital investment

Spending on long-lived assets expected to give benefits for several years

Also called capital budgeting.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which of these is a capital expenditure?

Question 2 of 5

A new machine costs $50,000 plus $2,000 to install and needs $3,000 of extra inventory. The old machine, with a book value of $15,000, can be sold for $7,000. Ignoring taxes, what is the net initial outlay?

Question 3 of 5

A company first rejects every proposal that will not pay back within four years, then ranks the rest. What is the first step called?

Question 4 of 5

Which pair of projects is mutually exclusive?

Question 5 of 5

A $200,000 budget and a 12% hurdle rate. Projects: W costs $70,000 (18%), X $90,000 (15%), Y $80,000 (11%), Z $100,000 (13%). Funding by rank, which are chosen?

← Previous topicNext topic →