Accounting › Section X · Capital budgeting decisions › Topic X.2

Payback and accounting rate of return

Before anyone discounts a cash flow, two quick tests ask how fast a project returns its cost and how much profit it earns on the money put in. They are simple, widely used for screening, and blind to the timing of money in ways every manager should understand.

Two quick tests

The payback period and the accounting rate of return (ARR) are the two common capital budgeting methods that ignore the time value of money: a dollar received in year 5 counts the same as a dollar received today. That makes them quick to compute and easy to explain, which is why many companies use them for screening decisions, as described in Capital investment decisions. Payback works with cash flows and measures speed. ARR works with accounting net income and measures profitability. Neither should be the only basis for a large commitment, and later topics add methods that do allow for timing.

Payback with even cash flows

The payback period is the time an investment takes to recover its initial cost from its net cash inflows. A net cash inflow is the extra revenue or cost saving minus the extra cash costs. Depreciation is not subtracted, because it is not a cash payment and this section ignores income taxes. When the inflow is the same every year:

\text{Payback} = \frac{\text{Initial investment}}{\text{Annual net cash inflow}}

A company sets a maximum acceptable payback period. A project that pays back sooner passes the screen; one that takes longer is dropped. Shorter payback means the money is at risk for less time.

Worked example: payback with even flows

Oxbury Bakery is considering an oven costing $72,000 that saves $16,000 a year in cash for 8 years and then sells for $8,000. The bakery's maximum payback is 5 years. 1. Payback: \(72{,}000 \div 16{,}000 = 4.5\) years. 2. Compare: 4.5 years is within the 5-year limit, so the oven passes the screen. 3. Note that the $8,000 salvage arrives in year 8, long after payback, so it does not shorten the payback period. 4. Check by counting: after 4 years the oven has recovered \(4 \times 16{,}000 = 64{,}000\), leaving $8,000, which is half of year 5's inflow.

Payback with uneven cash flows

When the inflows differ from year to year, the formula no longer works and you track the cumulative total instead. Add each year's inflow to a running total until it first equals or exceeds the investment. Payback is the number of full years before that point plus a fraction of the next year:

\text{Fraction} = \frac{\text{Cost still unrecovered}}{\text{Inflow in the payback year}}

The fraction assumes the year's cash arrives evenly through the year. A common error is to average the inflows and divide; that gives the wrong answer whenever the large inflows come early or late.

Worked example: payback with uneven flows

Fallowmere Dairy can buy a bottling line for $150,000. Its net cash inflows are $30,000, $45,000, $50,000, $40,000 and $35,000 in years 1 to 5. 1. Running totals: $30,000 after year 1, $75,000 after year 2, $125,000 after year 3 and $165,000 after year 4. 2. The total first passes $150,000 during year 4. 3. Unrecovered at the end of year 3: \(150{,}000 - 125{,}000 = 25{,}000\). 4. Fraction of year 4: \(25{,}000 \div 40{,}000 = 0.625\). 5. Payback is 3.625 years, or about 3.6 years. Check: averaging would give \(150{,}000 \div 40{,}000 = 3.75\) years, which is wrong because the larger inflows come in years 2 and 3.

What payback misses

Payback is easy to compute, highlights liquidity and favours projects that return cash before forecasts become unreliable. Its blind spots are serious. It ignores the time value of money. It also ignores every cash flow after the payback point. Compare two projects that each cost $40,000. Project P returns $20,000 a year for 2 years and then nothing: payback 2 years, total inflows $40,000, so it never earns more than its cost. Project Q returns $10,000 a year for 8 years: payback 4 years, total inflows $80,000. Payback prefers P, although only Q makes money. Payback measures speed, not profitability.

The accounting rate of return

ARR compares a project's accounting profit with the money invested. Incremental net income is the incremental revenue, including cost savings, minus the incremental expenses, including depreciation. This course divides by the initial investment:

\text{ARR} = \frac{\text{Average annual incremental net income}}{\text{Initial investment}}

Some companies divide by the average investment instead, \((\text{cost} + \text{salvage}) \div 2\), which gives a higher percentage (exactly double when there is no salvage). Both are in use, so always state the base and compare the ARR with a hurdle rate built on the same base. A project passes if its ARR meets or beats that hurdle.

Worked example: ARR on two bases

Take Oxbury's oven: cost $72,000, salvage $8,000, 8-year life, cash savings $16,000 a year. 1. Straight-line depreciation: \((72{,}000 - 8{,}000) \div 8 = 8{,}000\) a year, as in Depreciation methods. 2. Incremental net income: \(16{,}000 - 8{,}000 = 8{,}000\) a year. 3. ARR on the initial investment: \(8{,}000 \div 72{,}000 = 11.1\%\). 4. Average investment: \((72{,}000 + 8{,}000) \div 2 = 40{,}000\), so ARR on that base is \(8{,}000 \div 40{,}000 = 20.0\%\). 5. Against a 12% hurdle on the initial investment, the oven fails, even though it passed the payback screen. Check: net income plus depreciation equals the $16,000 cash saving.

ARR with uneven income, and its limits

When income varies, average it over the life. Fallowmere's line has total inflows of $200,000 and total depreciation of $150,000 with no salvage, so total net income is $50,000 over 5 years, or $10,000 a year. ARR on the initial investment is \(10{,}000 \div 150{,}000 = 6.7\%\). ARR uses figures managers already see in the income statement and looks at profit over the whole life, unlike payback. But it ignores the time value of money, treats early and late income alike, depends on the depreciation method chosen and gives different answers for different bases.

Common mistakes to avoid

Subtracting depreciation from cash inflows when computing payback: payback uses cash. Forgetting depreciation when computing ARR: ARR uses net income, so depreciation is an expense. Averaging uneven cash flows to find payback instead of building a running total. Counting salvage value towards payback when it arrives years later. Comparing an ARR on average investment with a hurdle set on initial investment. Treating a short payback as proof that a project is profitable.

Key takeaways

Payback is the time needed to recover the investment from net cash inflows: investment divided by annual inflow when flows are even, or a running total plus a fraction of the payback year when they are uneven. It measures speed and risk but ignores time value and later cash flows. ARR is average annual incremental net income, after depreciation, divided by the investment; this course uses the initial investment, while some firms use the average investment. ARR measures profitability but ignores time value. Both suit screening; neither should decide a large project alone.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Payback period

Time needed to recover the initial investment from net cash inflows

Measures speed, not profit.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A machine costs $90,000, has a 6-year life with no salvage, and produces net cash inflows of $24,000 a year. What is its payback period?

Question 2 of 5

A project costs $100,000 and returns net cash inflows of $40,000, $35,000, $30,000 and $20,000 in years 1 to 4. What is its payback period?

Question 3 of 5

Equipment costs $60,000 with a 5-year life and no salvage. It adds revenue of $30,000 and cash expenses of $14,000 a year. What is the ARR on the initial investment?

Question 4 of 5

A project costs $80,000, has a salvage value of $10,000 and earns average incremental net income of $7,000 a year. What is its ARR on the average investment?

Question 5 of 5

Which is a weakness of the payback method?

← Previous topicNext topic →