Accounting › Section O · Cash flows and statement analysis › Topic O.3
Cash flow ratios for liquidity and solvency
Accrual profit depends on estimates; cash in the bank does not. Ratios built from the statement of cash flows show whether a company can pay its bills, carry its debt and still invest, and they are a quick test of how much its reported profit is worth.
Why ratios built on cash
Ratios such as the current ratio use balance sheet amounts at a single date, and profit ratios use net income, which rests on estimates of useful lives, bad debts and much else. Cash flow ratios use the actual cash a business generated over a whole year. That makes them harder to flatter with accounting choices, although not impossible: a company can boost one year's operating cash by delaying payments to suppliers. Analysts therefore read cash flow ratios alongside the accrual ratios, never instead of them, and over several years rather than one.
Free cash flow
Free cash flow (FCF) is the cash left after a business has paid to keep and expand its productive capacity:
Capital expenditures are the cash spent on property, plant and equipment, taken from the investing section. FCF is what is available to repay debt, pay dividends, buy back shares or fund acquisitions without new borrowing. Some analysts use a stricter version that also subtracts cash dividends, on the view that most companies treat their dividend as almost fixed. Always state which definition you are using.
Free cash flow to sales and to assets
Free cash flow in dollars is hard to compare between firms of different sizes, so it is scaled. Free cash flow to sales, \(\text{FCF} \div \text{Net sales}\), shows how many cents of each sales dollar end up as free cash. Free cash flow to assets, \(\text{FCF} \div \text{Average total assets}\), shows how much free cash the company's asset base generates. A closely related measure, the cash flow margin, divides operating cash flow by net sales. When free cash flow is negative, these ratios are negative too, and the useful question becomes why.
A cash measure of liquidity
The operating cash flow ratio compares a year's operating cash with the obligations due within a year:
Average current liabilities are the beginning and ending balances added and halved; some analysts use the ending balance alone, so check a source's method. A ratio of 1.5 means the year's operations produced $1.50 of cash for every dollar of current liabilities. Unlike the current ratio, which assumes receivables and inventory will turn into cash, this ratio counts cash that actually arrived.
A cash measure of solvency
The cash debt coverage ratio stretches the same idea to all debts:
A ratio of 0.40 means one year's operating cash would cover 40% of total liabilities, so on that basis the company could clear its debts in about two and a half years without borrowing more. Lenders like this ratio because liabilities are ultimately paid in cash, not in profit. A falling ratio over several years, especially alongside rising debt, signals growing strain even when net income looks steady.
Cash and the quality of earnings
The quality of income ratio, \(\text{Operating cash flow} \div \text{Net income}\), asks how much of reported profit arrived as cash. Because depreciation is added back, healthy companies often score above 1. A ratio persistently below 1, or net income rising while operating cash falls, deserves a closer look: receivables or inventory may be piling up, or revenue may be recognised too early. Such a gap is not proof of manipulation, since a fast-growing firm naturally ties up cash in receivables, but it is one of the clearest warning signs analysts have.
Worked example: a full set for Northfield Bakeries
Northfield reports operating cash flow of $240,000, capital expenditures of $90,000, dividends of $30,000, net sales of $1,600,000 and net income of $160,000. Average balances: total assets $1,200,000, current liabilities $160,000 (from $140,000 and $180,000) and total liabilities $600,000. 1. FCF: \(240{,}000 - 90{,}000 = 150{,}000\); the stricter version is $120,000. 2. FCF to sales: \(150{,}000 \div 1{,}600{,}000 \approx 9.4\%\). 3. FCF to assets: 12.5%. 4. Operating cash flow ratio: \(240{,}000 \div 160{,}000 = 1.5\). 5. Cash debt coverage: 0.40. 6. Quality of income: \(240{,}000 \div 160{,}000 = 1.5\). Every measure points to strong cash generation.
Worked example: profit up, cash down
Quarry Lane Tools reports net income of $100,000 in Year 1 and $130,000 in Year 2, a 30% rise. Operating cash flow went the other way, from $120,000 to $85,000, a fall of about 29%. 1. Quality of income in Year 1: \(120{,}000 \div 100{,}000 = 1.2\). 2. In Year 2: \(85{,}000 \div 130{,}000 \approx 0.65\). 3. Investigate: the indirect-method reconciliation shows receivables up sharply in Year 2. 4. Conclude: the profit growth has not yet turned into cash. An analyst would ask whether customers are paying more slowly or whether sales were booked before they were truly earned.
Reading negative free cash flow
Negative free cash flow is not automatically bad news. Tidewater Supply, from The indirect method, generated $77,000 of operating cash but spent $90,000 on equipment, so its FCF was \(-13{,}000\), or \(-33{,}000\) after its $20,000 dividend. If that spending is a one-off expansion funded by a sensible loan, future operating cash may more than repay it. If FCF is negative year after year while borrowing climbs and dividends continue, the company is paying owners with borrowed money, which cannot last. The pattern over several years matters more than any single figure.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, mixing free cash flow definitions, with and without dividends, when comparing companies. Second, using net income in place of operating cash flow. Third, taking capital expenditures from the wrong place: they are purchases of property, plant and equipment in investing, not total investing cash, which may include sale proceeds and securities. Fourth, mixing averages and year-end balances between years. Fifth, reading one year's negative free cash flow as failure without asking what the spending bought.
Key takeaways
Free cash flow is operating cash flow minus capital expenditures, with a stricter version that also subtracts dividends. Scaled versions divide it by net sales or average total assets. The operating cash flow ratio, operating cash over average current liabilities, measures liquidity; cash debt coverage, operating cash over average total liabilities, measures solvency. The quality of income ratio, operating cash over net income, tests how much profit became cash. Read every cash ratio over several years and alongside the accrual-based ratios.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Operating cash flow − capital expenditures
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Operating cash flow is $85,000, capital expenditures are $30,000 and dividends are $10,000. Using operating cash flow minus capital expenditures, what is free cash flow?
Question 2 of 5
Operating cash flow is $96,000. Current liabilities were $70,000 at the start of the year and $90,000 at the end. What is the operating cash flow ratio, using the average?
Question 3 of 5
Net income is $200,000 and operating cash flow is $120,000, while receivables rose sharply. What is the quality of income ratio, and what does it suggest?
Question 4 of 5
Operating cash flow is $150,000. Total liabilities were $400,000 at the start of the year and $600,000 at the end. What is cash debt coverage, using the average?
Question 5 of 5
Free cash flow is $48,000 and net sales are $960,000. What is free cash flow to sales?
