Accounting › Section O · Cash flows and statement analysis › Topic O.4

The direct method

Instead of adjusting net income, the direct method lists the cash a company actually collected and paid in its operations. It reads like a cash income statement, and done correctly it lands on exactly the same operating total as the indirect method.

Cash receipts and payments, line by line

The direct method presents operating activities as major classes of gross cash receipts and payments: cash collected from customers, cash paid to suppliers, cash paid to employees, cash paid for interest and for income taxes, and so on. A reader can see at a glance where operating cash came from and where it went, which the indirect method's string of adjustments does not show. Only the operating section differs; the investing and financing sections, and the net change in cash, are identical under both methods.

Converting accrual amounts to cash

Each line of the income statement is turned into a cash amount using the balance sheet account that sits between it and cash. Revenue is adjusted for receivables and unearned revenue; cost of goods sold for inventory and accounts payable; operating expenses for prepaid expenses and accrued liabilities; interest and income tax expense for their payables. Noncash items are simply dropped: depreciation, amortisation and gains or losses on selling assets never appear in a direct-method operating section, because no operating cash moved. The cash from asset sales is reported in investing.

Cash collected from customers

Start with sales revenue, then ask how the receivable changed. If accounts receivable rose, part of this year's sales has not been collected, so subtract the increase; if it fell, customers paid off old balances too, so add the decrease:

\begin{aligned}\text{Collections} &= \text{Sales} \\ &\quad - \text{Increase in AR}\end{aligned}

If the company also takes payment in advance, add any increase in unearned revenue, since that cash arrived before the revenue was recorded, and subtract any decrease. The result is the cash that actually came in from customers during the year.

Cash paid to suppliers

Cash paid for inventory takes two steps. 1. Find purchases: cost of goods sold plus any increase in inventory, or minus any decrease, because goods bought but unsold went into the stockroom rather than cost of goods sold.

\begin{aligned}\text{Purchases} &= \text{COGS} \\ &\quad + \text{Increase in inventory}\end{aligned}

2. Find payments: purchases minus any increase in accounts payable, or plus any decrease, because unpaid bills mean less cash went out. Mixing up the two steps is the commonest error in the whole method, so write each one down separately.

Operating expenses, interest and taxes

Other expenses follow the same logic. Cash paid for an expense equals the expense, plus any increase in a related prepaid account (cash paid ahead), minus any increase in a related accrued liability (expense not yet paid). Decreases reverse the signs. So wages paid equal wages expense plus any fall in wages payable, and insurance paid equals insurance expense plus any rise in prepaid insurance. Interest paid is interest expense adjusted for interest payable, and income taxes paid are tax expense adjusted for income taxes payable. An expense with no related balance sheet account was paid in full.

Worked example: Tidewater by the direct method

Tidewater Supply, from The indirect method, had sales of $500,000, cost of goods sold of $300,000, wages of $80,000, insurance of $6,000, other expenses of $20,000, interest of $4,000 and income taxes of $15,000. Receivables rose $8,000, inventory fell $6,000, payables rose $5,000, wages payable fell $2,000, prepaid insurance rose $1,000 and taxes payable rose $2,000. 1. Collections: \(500{,}000 - 8{,}000 = 492{,}000\). 2. Purchases: \(300{,}000 - 6{,}000 = 294{,}000\); paid \(294{,}000 - 5{,}000 = 289{,}000\). 3. Wages: \(80{,}000 + 2{,}000 = 82{,}000\). 4. Insurance: \(6{,}000 + 1{,}000 = 7{,}000\). 5. Taxes: \(15{,}000 - 2{,}000 = 13{,}000\).

\begin{array}{lr} \text{From customers} & 492{,}000 \\ \text{To suppliers} & (289{,}000) \\ \text{To employees} & (82{,}000) \\ \text{For insurance} & (7{,}000) \\ \text{Other expenses} & (20{,}000) \\ \text{Interest} & (4{,}000) \\ \text{Income taxes} & (13{,}000) \\ \hline \text{Operating cash} & 77{,}000 \end{array}

Proving the two methods agree

Tidewater's indirect method also gave $77,000, and that is no coincidence. Both methods take the same income statement and the same changes in current operating accounts; one adjusts the total, the other adjusts each line. Its $52,000 net income also reflects $25,000 of depreciation and a $2,000 gain: the direct method leaves them out, while the indirect method adds back one and subtracts the other. Under US GAAP, a company that uses the direct method must also present a reconciliation of net income to operating cash flow, which is the indirect-method calculation, in a separate schedule.

Worked example: suppliers and advance payments

Fernhill Outfitters reports cost of goods sold of $180,000, inventory up from $30,000 to $41,000 and accounts payable down from $22,000 to $17,000. 1. Purchases: \(180{,}000 + 11{,}000 = 191{,}000\). 2. The fall in payables means extra cash went out: \(191{,}000 + 5{,}000 = 196{,}000\) paid to suppliers. Fernhill also had sales of $260,000, receivables up $7,000 and unearned revenue up $2,500. 3. Collections: \(260{,}000 - 7{,}000 + 2{,}500 = 255{,}500\). 4. Check the direction of each change: building inventory and paying down suppliers both used cash, so payments exceed cost of goods sold.

Why so few companies use it

Both the FASB and the IASB encourage the direct method, because gross receipts and payments are easier to understand and more useful for predicting future cash flows. Yet most companies choose the indirect method. One reason is the extra work: their accounting systems record revenues and expenses, not cash by category, so the gross cash figures must be derived. Another is that US GAAP still requires the indirect-style reconciliation alongside a direct-method statement, so a direct presentation means preparing both. Many analysts still value the direct method when it is available.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, including depreciation or a gain on sale among the cash payments or receipts. Second, combining the two supplier steps and adjusting cost of goods sold for payables before finding purchases. Third, reversing signs: a rise in receivables lowers collections, a rise in payables lowers payments. Fourth, forgetting unearned revenue when computing collections. Fifth, failing to prove the direct total against the indirect-method reconciliation; if they differ, a balance has been missed or a sign flipped.

Key takeaways

The direct method reports gross operating receipts and payments. Collections are sales adjusted for receivables and unearned revenue. Payments to suppliers need two steps: purchases from cost of goods sold and the inventory change, then payments from purchases and the payables change. Other expenses are adjusted for prepaid and accrued balances, and noncash items are omitted. Operating cash flow is identical under both methods, and US GAAP requires a reconciliation of net income to operating cash flow whenever the direct method is used.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Direct method

Lists gross operating cash receipts and payments

Encouraged by FASB and IASB.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Sales are $400,000. Accounts receivable rose from $30,000 to $42,000. How much cash was collected from customers?

Question 2 of 5

Cost of goods sold is $250,000. Inventory rose by $10,000 and accounts payable rose by $6,000. How much cash was paid to suppliers?

Question 3 of 5

Which item never appears in a direct-method operating section?

Question 4 of 5

Under US GAAP, what else must a company present when it uses the direct method?

Question 5 of 5

Income tax expense is $30,000, and income taxes payable fell by $4,000. How much income tax was paid in cash?

← Previous topicNext topic →