Accounting › Section P · Managerial accounting and cost behavior › Topic P.5
Variable, fixed, and mixed costs
If a business makes twice as many products next month, will its costs double? Some will, some will not move at all, and some will do a bit of both. Knowing which is which is the foundation of budgeting, pricing and almost every decision in the managerial half of this course.
How costs respond to activity
"Merchandising, manufacturing, and service costs" sorted costs by what they are for: product or period, direct or overhead. Managers also need to know how a cost behaves, meaning how its total changes when activity changes. Activity is measured by a cost driver, the activity that causes the cost: units produced, machine hours, labour hours, kilometres driven, patients seen. A cost can be described two ways: in total, for the period, and per unit of activity. The two views behave differently, and mixing them up is the commonest error in managerial accounting. Throughout, assume activity stays within the range the business normally operates in.
Variable costs
A variable cost changes in total in direct proportion to activity, while the cost per unit stays the same. If each candle uses $3.20 of wax, wick and jar, then 1,000 candles need $3,200 of materials and 2,000 candles need $6,400, but the cost per candle is $3.20 either way. Other common variable costs are piece-rate wages, sales commissions set as a percentage of sales, card-processing fees and packaging. On a graph of total cost against activity, a variable cost is a straight line through the origin, and its slope is the cost per unit. Zero activity means zero variable cost.
Fixed costs
A fixed cost stays the same in total over a period, whatever the activity level, within the relevant range. Rent, insurance, a supervisor's salary, straight-line depreciation and a software subscription are typical. Because the total is constant, the fixed cost per unit falls as activity rises: $12,000 of monthly rent is $6.00 per candle at 2,000 candles but $2.40 at 5,000. This spreading of fixed cost over more units is why higher volume lowers average cost. Fixed does not mean unchangeable forever; managers can renegotiate a lease or add a supervisor. It means the cost does not move with this period's activity.
Worked example: totals and per-unit costs
Corriemoor Candles, a fictional workshop, has materials, a variable cost, of $3.20 per candle and rent, a fixed cost, of $12,000 a month; its other costs come later. Total cost is fixed cost plus variable cost per unit times units.
1. At 2,000 candles: \(12{,}000 + 3.20 \times 2{,}000 = 18{,}400\) dollars. 2. Variable cost per candle stays at $3.20 at every level. 3. Fixed cost per candle falls from $6.00 to $3.00 to $2.40. 4. So total cost per candle falls from $9.20 to $5.60. 5. Check: at 5,000 candles, $16,000 variable plus $12,000 fixed is $28,000.
The relevant range
The relevant range is the band of activity over which the assumed cost behaviour holds, usually the levels the business can reach with its current premises, equipment and staff. Corriemoor's workshop can make about 6,000 candles a month. Beyond that it would need more space, so rent would jump, and fixed costs would no longer be $12,000. Variable cost per unit can change outside the range too: very large orders may earn bulk discounts on wax, while overtime at peak output may raise labour cost per unit. Cost estimates and the decisions built on them are reliable only inside the range they were measured for.
Step costs
A step cost is constant over a band of activity and then jumps to a new level. Corriemoor's packers each handle up to 1,500 candles a month and earn $2,400 a month. Up to 1,500 candles one packer is enough; from 1,501 to 3,000 two are needed; from 3,001 to 4,500, three. Step costs with wide steps, such as one more supervisor per shift, are usually treated as fixed within the relevant range. Steps that are narrow compared with normal changes in activity behave almost like variable costs and are often treated as variable. Either way, a decision that crosses a step must include the jump.
Mixed costs
A mixed cost, also called semivariable, has a fixed part and a variable part. Corriemoor's electricity bill has a standing charge of $900 a month plus about $0.10 per candle for the melting ovens, so it is $1,320 at 4,200 candles and $1,380 at 4,800. A delivery van leased for a flat monthly fee plus fuel per kilometre, or a phone plan with a base fee and charges for extra data, works the same way. Any mixed cost can be written as total cost = fixed part + variable rate × activity. "Estimating a cost equation" shows how to find the two parts when only the total bills are known.
Worked example: an extra order
Corriemoor normally makes 4,200 candles a month. A shop asks for 600 more, which would take output to 4,800. What extra cost would the order cause? 1. Materials: \(600 \times 3.20 = 1{,}920\) dollars. 2. Electricity, variable part only: \(600 \times 0.10 = 60\) dollars; the $900 standing charge does not change. 3. Packers: 4,200 candles need three, but 4,800 needs four, so one more packer costs $2,400. 4. Rent and other fixed costs stay the same, since 4,800 is inside the relevant range. 5. Extra cost: $1,920 + $60 + $2,400 = $4,380, or \(4{,}380 \div 600 = 7.30\) dollars per extra candle. Ignoring the step would have understated it by more than half. Pricing such an order is covered in "Accepting or rejecting a special order".
Classifying familiar costs by behaviour
Behaviour cuts across the product-cost categories. Direct materials are variable. Direct labour is usually treated as variable, although a fixed salaried workforce that cannot be adjusted quickly behaves more like a fixed cost. Manufacturing overhead is a mixture: indirect materials are variable; a supervisor's salary, factory insurance and straight-line depreciation are fixed; utilities are mixed. Among period costs, sales commissions are variable, while advertising campaigns and office salaries are fixed. The same cost can behave differently in different businesses, so always ask what drives it there.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating fixed cost per unit as if it were variable: Corriemoor's cost is $6.20 per candle at 4,000, but 5,000 candles cost $28,000, not \(5{,}000 \times 6.20 = 31{,}000\) dollars, because the fixed $12,000 does not grow. Second, assuming fixed costs can never change; they are fixed only within the relevant range and the period. Third, ignoring step costs when a decision crosses a step. Fourth, extending a cost pattern far outside the range it was observed in. Fifth, assuming a cost behaves the same way in every business.
Key takeaways
Cost behaviour describes how a cost's total changes with activity, measured by a cost driver. Variable costs change in total in proportion to activity and are constant per unit. Fixed costs are constant in total within the relevant range and fall per unit as activity rises. Step costs are constant over a band and then jump. Mixed costs combine a fixed part and a variable rate: total cost = fixed part + variable rate × activity. All these patterns hold only within the relevant range, and every decision should count the costs that actually change, including any step it crosses.
Flashcards
Flashcard
How a cost's total changes when activity changes
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A firm's fixed costs are $30,000 a month and variable cost is $4 per unit. What is total cost per unit at 10,000 units?
Question 2 of 5
Within the relevant range, output rises from 2,000 to 3,000 units. What happens to fixed cost per unit and variable cost per unit?
Question 3 of 5
At 4,000 units a product's total cost is $24,800, or $6.20 per unit, of which $12,000 is fixed. What will total cost be at 5,000 units, within the relevant range?
Question 4 of 5
Each inspector can check up to 2,000 parts a month and costs $3,000 a month. Output rises from 3,800 to 4,300 parts. By how much does inspection cost rise?
Question 5 of 5
A phone plan costs $40 a month plus $0.05 per minute. What kind of cost is it, and what is the bill for 600 minutes?
