Accounting › Section P · Managerial accounting and cost behavior › Topic P.4

Merchandising, manufacturing, and service costs

A physiotherapy clinic, a bookshop and a toy factory all need to control costs, but they incur very different ones. This topic shows how each type of organisation accounts for its costs and introduces the cost vocabulary of manufacturing that the rest of the managerial half depends on.

Three ways to earn revenue

"Merchandising versus service businesses" contrasted firms that sell work with firms that resell goods. Managerial accounting adds a third type and looks closely at costs. A service organisation earns revenue mainly by providing something intangible: treatment, advice, transport, education. A merchandising organisation buys finished goods and resells them without changing their form. A manufacturing organisation buys raw materials and components and converts them into finished products. Many real businesses mix types, such as a bakery that bakes bread and resells coffee beans, but the classification still tells you which costs will dominate and how they flow through the accounts.

Service organisations

A service firm has no merchandise to hold, so its costs are mostly people and premises: wages, rent, utilities, insurance, software and supplies. Its income statement is the simplest: revenue minus operating expenses equals operating income. That does not make costing unimportant. A physiotherapy clinic still needs the cost of a typical patient visit, built from therapist time, treatment-room costs and administration, to set fees, decide whether to accept an insurer's rates and judge whether a new clinic would pay. Because labour usually dominates, the cost of an hour of staff time is often the key figure.

Merchandising organisations

A merchandiser carries one kind of inventory: goods bought for resale. Their cost, including freight-in, sits in Inventory as an asset until the goods are sold and then becomes Cost of Goods Sold. As "Cost of goods sold under the periodic method" showed, cost of goods sold equals beginning inventory plus net purchases minus ending inventory. The income statement subtracts cost of goods sold from net sales to give gross profit, then subtracts selling and administrative expenses. For a merchandiser the biggest managerial questions are usually about buying: what to stock, how much, from whom and at what mark-up.

Manufacturers and three inventories

A manufacturer's inventory passes through three stages, each with its own account. Raw Materials Inventory holds materials bought but not yet used. Work in Process Inventory holds partly finished products, carrying the materials, labour and overhead put into them so far. Finished Goods Inventory holds completed products awaiting sale. When products are sold, their cost moves from Finished Goods Inventory to Cost of Goods Sold. All three are current assets on the balance sheet. The income statement looks like a merchandiser's, except that the cost of goods sold comes from the factory rather than from a supplier's invoice.

The three product cost components

Direct materials are materials that become part of the product and can be traced to it economically, such as the beech wood in a toy train. Direct labour is the pay of workers who make the product by hand or by operating machines. Manufacturing overhead is every other factory cost: indirect materials too small or awkward to trace (glue, sandpaper), indirect labour (supervisors, maintenance staff, quality inspectors), and factory utilities, rent, insurance and depreciation on factory equipment. Together these three make up the product cost. How they move through the inventory accounts is developed in "Product cost components and their flow".

Product costs and period costs

Product costs, also called inventoriable costs, are the costs of making or buying the goods. They are held in inventory as assets and become an expense, cost of goods sold, only when the goods are sold, which may be a later period. Period costs are all the others: selling costs such as advertising, sales commissions and delivery to customers, and administrative costs such as office rent and accounting staff. They are expensed in the period they are incurred. The test is what the cost was for, not what it is called. Depreciation on a factory lathe is overhead and therefore a product cost; depreciation on the head office's computers is a period cost.

Prime costs and conversion costs

Two more groupings are used widely. Prime costs are direct materials plus direct labour, the costs most directly tied to each unit. Conversion costs are direct labour plus manufacturing overhead, the costs of converting materials into a finished product. Direct labour belongs to both groups, so prime costs and conversion costs must never be added together to find total product cost: that would count direct labour twice. Conversion costs matter especially in highly automated factories and in process costing, where materials and conversion are often tracked separately, as "Process costing and conversion costs" explains.

Worked example: classifying a toymaker's costs

Brindlewood Toys, a fictional maker of wooden toys, lists some of its monthly costs. 1. Beech wood for the toys: direct materials, a product cost. 2. Wages of lathe operators: direct labour, a product cost. 3. Glue and sandpaper: indirect materials, part of manufacturing overhead. 4. The factory supervisor's salary: indirect labour, also overhead. 5. Depreciation on the lathes and the factory's electricity: overhead. 6. Sales commissions and delivery to toy shops: selling costs, period costs. 7. Office rent and the bookkeeper's wages: administrative, period costs. 8. Groupings: prime costs are items 1 and 2; conversion costs are items 2 to 5. Item 2, direct labour, appears in both.

Worked example: from factory to income statement

Brindlewood's year: raw materials of $18,000 at the start, $96,000 purchased and $14,000 left at the end; direct labour $72,000; overhead $54,000; work in process $21,000 at the start and $25,000 at the end; finished goods $30,000 at the start and $34,000 at the end. Assume all raw materials used were direct.

\begin{array}{lr} \text{Direct materials used} & 100{,}000 \\ \text{Direct labour} & 72{,}000 \\ \text{Overhead} & 54{,}000 \\ \hline \text{Manufacturing costs} & 226{,}000 \end{array}

1. Materials used: $18,000 + $96,000 − $14,000 = $100,000. 2. Cost of goods manufactured: $21,000 + $226,000 − $25,000 = $222,000. 3. Cost of goods sold: $30,000 + $222,000 − $34,000 = $218,000. 4. With sales of $340,000, gross profit is $122,000, and $61,000 of selling and administrative costs leaves operating income of $61,000.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, expensing factory costs when they are incurred; overhead is a product cost and waits in inventory until the goods are sold. Second, putting sales commissions or office costs into product cost; they are period costs. Third, adding prime and conversion costs to get total product cost, which double-counts direct labour. Fourth, confusing cost of goods manufactured with cost of goods sold; the first is the cost of goods finished this period, the second the cost of goods sold, and the change in finished goods separates them. Fifth, assuming service firms need no costing because they hold no inventory.

Key takeaways

Service firms sell intangible work, and their costs are mostly labour and premises. Merchandisers resell finished goods through one inventory account. Manufacturers convert materials into products through Raw Materials Inventory, Work in Process Inventory and Finished Goods Inventory. Product cost is direct materials plus direct labour plus manufacturing overhead; it stays in inventory until the goods are sold. Period costs, selling and administrative, are expensed when incurred. Prime costs are direct materials plus direct labour; conversion costs are direct labour plus overhead. Cost of goods manufactured adjusts manufacturing costs for the change in work in process; cost of goods sold adjusts that for the change in finished goods.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Service organisation

Earns revenue mainly from intangible services

Costs are mostly labour and premises.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A furniture maker pays a factory maintenance technician's wages. How are they classified?

Question 2 of 5

Direct materials are $40,000, direct labour $25,000 and overhead $30,000. What are prime costs and conversion costs?

Question 3 of 5

Manufacturing costs this year are $150,000, beginning work in process is $12,000 and ending work in process is $18,000. What is cost of goods manufactured?

Question 4 of 5

Which cost is a period cost for a manufacturer?

Question 5 of 5

Cost of goods manufactured is $180,000, beginning finished goods $25,000 and ending finished goods $31,000. What is cost of goods sold?

← Previous topicNext topic →