Accounting › Section X · Capital budgeting decisions › Topic X.4
Net present value and internal rate of return
Payback and ARR treat a dollar in year 5 like a dollar today. Net present value and the internal rate of return fix that by discounting every cash flow to the present, so a project's costs and benefits are finally measured in the same kind of dollar.
Discounting the whole project
Discounted cash flow methods apply the present-value tools of Present and future value of lump sums and annuities to a project's cash flows. The discount rate is the required rate of return, or hurdle rate, often based on the cost of capital and raised for riskier projects. This section makes three standard simplifying assumptions: the initial investment is paid today (year 0), each later cash flow arrives at the end of its year, and income taxes are ignored. The cash flows themselves are the incremental cash flows identified in Capital investment decisions, including salvage value and any working capital recovered at the end.
Net present value
Net present value (NPV) is the present value of the project's future net cash flows minus the initial investment \(I_0\), discounted at the required rate \(i\):
The decision rule follows from what the number means. A positive NPV means the project earns more than the required return, by that many of today's dollars, so it should be accepted. An NPV of zero means it earns exactly the required return. A negative NPV means it falls short and should be rejected. When the yearly cash flows are equal, the sum is simply the annual cash flow times the annuity factor.
Worked example: NPV with even cash flows
Glenmoor Hotels is considering a laundry system costing $120,000 that saves $28,000 a year for 6 years, with no salvage. The required rate is 10%. 1. Annuity factor for \(i = 10\%\), \(n = 6\): 4.35526. 2. Present value of savings: \(28{,}000 \times 4.35526 = 121{,}947\). 3. NPV: \(121{,}947 - 120{,}000 = 1{,}947\). 4. Decision: the NPV is positive, so the system earns slightly more than 10% and should be accepted, although the margin is thin. 5. Check: the undiscounted savings total $168,000, and discounting removes $46,053 of that, which shows how much timing matters over six years.
Uneven cash flows
When the yearly amounts differ, no single annuity factor applies. Discount each year's cash flow separately with its present value of $1 factor, \((1+i)^{-t}\), and add the results. Salvage value and recovered working capital are simply added to the cash flow of the year they arrive. A table with one row per year keeps the work tidy: the year, the cash flow, the factor and the present value. Factors rounded to five decimals can leave the total a dollar or so away from an exact calculation, which does not change any decision.
Worked example: NPV with uneven cash flows
Talbridge Tools can buy a machine for $200,000. Net cash inflows are $60,000, $70,000, $80,000 and $50,000 in years 1 to 4, and the machine then sells for $20,000. The required rate is 12%. 1. Year 4 cash flow: \(50{,}000 + 20{,}000 = 70{,}000\). 2. Discount each year:
3. Total present value: $210,803. 4. NPV: \(210{,}803 - 200{,}000 = 10{,}803\), positive, so accept.
The profitability index
The profitability index (PI) scales the result by the size of the investment:
It shows the present value returned per dollar invested. A PI above 1 matches a positive NPV, a PI of exactly 1 matches an NPV of zero, and a PI below 1 matches a negative NPV. Glenmoor's laundry system has \(PI = 121{,}947 \div 120{,}000 = 1.016\); Talbridge's machine has \(PI = 210{,}803 \div 200{,}000 = 1.054\). The index is most useful when projects of different sizes compete for a limited budget, which Comparing capital budgeting methods takes up.
The internal rate of return
The internal rate of return (IRR) is the discount rate at which a project's NPV is exactly zero: the present value of the inflows equals the investment. It is the project's own rate of return, allowing for the timing of every cash flow. The decision rule compares it with the required rate. If the IRR exceeds the required rate, the project is acceptable; if it falls below, reject it. For a conventional project, an outflow followed only by inflows, NPV falls as the discount rate rises, so a positive NPV at the required rate always means the IRR is higher than that rate.
Worked example: IRR with even cash flows
With equal inflows, the IRR is the rate whose annuity factor equals investment divided by annual cash flow. Take Glenmoor's laundry system. 1. Target factor: \(120{,}000 \div 28{,}000 = 4.28571\). 2. Look along the 6-period row of the annuity table: at 10% the factor is 4.35526, and at 11% it is 4.23054. 3. The target lies between them, so the IRR is between 10% and 11%. 4. Interpolate:
which is about 10.55% when solved exactly. 5. Check: the IRR is just above the 10% required rate, consistent with the small positive NPV.
Worked example: IRR with uneven cash flows
Uneven flows have no single factor to look up, so the IRR is found by trial: compute the NPV at several rates until it crosses zero. Take Talbridge's machine. 1. At 12% the NPV is +10,803, so the IRR is higher than 12%. 2. At 14%: NPV is about +1,938. 3. At 15%: NPV is about −2,272. 4. The NPV changes sign between 14% and 15%. Interpolate:
5. Check: a numerical solver, or the spreadsheet function =IRR(range of cash flows), gives 14.46%, which beats the 12% required rate, so accept.
Common mistakes to avoid
Forgetting to subtract the initial investment, which turns NPV into a plain present value. Using an annuity factor when the cash flows are uneven. Leaving salvage value or recovered working capital out of the final year. Discounting at the IRR or at some other rate instead of the required rate when computing NPV. Reading a positive NPV as the project's profit in future dollars: it is value added in today's dollars, above the required return. Inverting the profitability index, which flips a good project into an apparently bad one.
Key takeaways
NPV discounts every future net cash flow at the required rate and subtracts the initial investment; accept when it is positive. With even flows use the annuity factor; with uneven flows discount each year separately and add salvage to the final year. The profitability index is present value divided by investment and exceeds 1 exactly when NPV is positive. The IRR is the rate that makes NPV zero: look up the factor investment ÷ annual flow when flows are even, or search by trial when they are uneven. Accept when the IRR exceeds the required rate.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Methods that bring every cash flow to today's value
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A project costs $50,000 and returns $15,000 at the end of each year for 5 years. The required rate is 10% (5-year annuity factor 3.79079). What is its NPV?
Question 2 of 5
A project costs $30,000 and returns $10,000, $12,000 and $15,000 in years 1 to 3. At 8% the PV of $1 factors are 0.92593, 0.85734 and 0.79383. Which is closest to its NPV?
Question 3 of 5
A project's future net cash flows have a present value of $84,000, and it costs $70,000. What is its profitability index?
Question 4 of 5
A project costs $72,096 and returns $20,000 a year for 5 years. Five-year annuity factors: 10%, 3.79079; 12%, 3.60478; 14%, 3.43308. What is its IRR?
Question 5 of 5
A conventional project has an IRR of 9% and the required rate is 11%. What is true of its NPV at 11%?
