Accounting › Section X · Capital budgeting decisions › Topic X.5

Comparing capital budgeting methods

Payback, ARR, NPV and IRR often agree, and the interesting cases are when they do not. Knowing what each method measures tells you which one to trust when two good projects compete, when the budget runs short, or when the cash flows take an unusual shape.

Four methods, four questions

Each method answers a different question. Payback asks how quickly the cash invested comes back. The accounting rate of return asks how much accounting profit the project earns on the money invested. Net present value asks how many of today's dollars the project adds above the required return. The internal rate of return asks what rate the project itself earns, allowing for timing, and the profitability index asks how much present value each invested dollar brings back. For one conventional, independent project, NPV, IRR and the index always agree on accept or reject. Rankings are where they can part company.

Worked example: one pair, four methods

Hartwell Plastics must choose one of two mutually exclusive moulding lines. S costs $50,000 and returns $20,000 a year for 4 years; L costs $150,000 and returns $52,000 a year for 4 years. Neither has salvage, and the required rate is 10% (annuity factor 3.16987). 1. Present values: \(20{,}000 \times 3.16987 = 63{,}397\) and \(52{,}000 \times 3.16987 = 164{,}833\). 2. ARR on initial investment uses straight-line depreciation of $12,500 and $37,500.

\begin{array}{lrr} \text{Method} & \text{S} & \text{L} \\ \hline \text{Payback} & 2.5\text{ yr} & 2.9\text{ yr} \\ \text{ARR} & 15.0\% & 9.7\% \\ \text{NPV} & 13{,}397 & 14{,}833 \\ \text{IRR} & 21.9\% & 14.5\% \\ \text{PI} & 1.27 & 1.10 \end{array}

3. Every method except NPV ranks S first.

Why the rankings conflict

Payback, ARR, IRR and PI are all ratios or times, so none of them reflects the size of the project. S earns a higher rate on a small sum; L earns a lower, but still acceptable, rate on three times as much money. NPV measures the dollars of value added, so it rewards L for putting more money to work above the 10% hurdle. Rankings can also conflict because of timing: a project whose cash arrives early tends to have a higher IRR than one with the same NPV but later cash. Neither ratio is wrong. They simply answer a different question from the one a company choosing between mutually exclusive projects needs answered.

Worked example: settling it with the increment

Look at what Hartwell gets by choosing L instead of S. 1. Extra investment: \(150{,}000 - 50{,}000 = 100{,}000\). 2. Extra cash flow: \(52{,}000 - 20{,}000 = 32{,}000\) a year for 4 years. 3. NPV of the increment:

32{,}000 \times 3.16987 - 100{,}000 = 1{,}436

which equals \(14{,}833 - 13{,}397\). 4. IRR of the increment: the factor \(100{,}000 \div 32{,}000 = 3.125\) lies between the 4-period factors at 10% (3.16987) and 11% (3.10245), so the extra $100,000 earns about 10.7%. 5. Conclusion: the extra money beats the 10% hurdle, so L is the better choice. When funds are available and only one project can be chosen, pick the higher NPV.

Worked example: a limited budget

When independent projects compete for a fixed budget, the best combination matters more than the best project. Ivybridge Brewing has $300,000 and four independent proposals: A costs $300,000 with NPV $45,000 (PI 1.15); B costs $120,000 with NPV $30,000 (PI 1.25); C costs $180,000 with NPV $36,000 (PI 1.20); D costs $100,000 with NPV $12,000 (PI 1.12). 1. Ranking by NPV picks A first, which uses the whole budget: total NPV $45,000. 2. Ranking by PI picks B, then C, costing exactly $300,000: total NPV $66,000. 3. Check the other combinations that fit: B and D give $42,000; C and D give $48,000. 4. B and C win. The PI ranking is a good guide under rationing, but confirm with the totals, because leftover budget can upset it.

Payback and ARR: strengths and weaknesses

Payback is quick, easy to explain and useful as a first screen. It favours projects that return cash fast, which suits a company short of cash or facing fast-changing technology. But it ignores the time value of money and every cash flow after the payback point, so it says nothing about profitability. ARR uses familiar income-statement figures and covers the whole life, and it matches how managers' results are often reported, as Return on investment, residual income, and EVA shows. But it also ignores timing, depends on the depreciation method, and changes with the investment base chosen.

NPV, IRR and PI: strengths and weaknesses

NPV allows for the timing of every cash flow, states the answer in dollars of value added, and can be added across projects. Its weaknesses are that it depends on an estimated required rate and is less intuitive to non-specialists than a percentage. IRR is easy to communicate and lets managers compare a project with the required rate without stating NPV in dollars, but it ignores scale, can rank mutually exclusive projects differently from NPV, and is often described as assuming that cash flows are reinvested at the IRR itself. The profitability index corrects for size and suits rationing, but as a ratio it can mislead between mutually exclusive projects.

When IRR breaks down

A conventional project has one sign change: money out, then money in. Some projects have more, such as a mine that needs a large clean-up payment at the end. Consider cash flows of \(-100{,}000\) now, \(+230{,}000\) in year 1 and \(-132{,}000\) in year 2. The NPV is exactly zero at both 10% and 20%, so the project has two IRRs, and neither tells you whether to accept. Between those rates the NPV is positive (about +189 at 15%); outside them it is negative (about −680 at 5%). With more than one sign change, rely on NPV at the required rate.

Methods in practice

Companies rarely rely on one number. A common pattern is to screen with payback or a minimum ARR, then make the final choice with NPV, supported by IRR because managers like to see a percentage. Sensitivity analysis checks how far the savings, costs or required rate can move before the decision flips, and qualitative factors such as strategy, quality and safety are weighed alongside the figures. Post-audits compare actual results with the original forecasts, and the lessons improve the next round of estimates. A method is only as good as the cash flow forecasts fed into it.

Common mistakes to avoid

Choosing between mutually exclusive projects by IRR or PI when the higher-NPV project is affordable. Ranking independent projects by NPV under a tight budget without checking which combination fits best. Treating payback as a profitability measure. Reporting a single IRR for cash flows that change sign more than once. Comparing an ARR with a hurdle rate set on a different investment base. Forgetting that every method depends on forecasts: a precise answer from poor estimates is still a poor answer.

Key takeaways

Payback measures speed, ARR accounting profit, NPV dollars of value added, IRR the project's own rate and PI value per dollar invested. For a single conventional independent project, NPV, IRR and PI agree on accept or reject. They can rank differently because ratios ignore scale and timing; for mutually exclusive projects choose the higher NPV, which incremental analysis confirms. Under capital rationing, rank by PI and confirm the total NPV of the combinations that fit. Cash flows with more than one sign change can have several IRRs, so use NPV.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Payback asks

How fast does the cash invested come back?

Speed and risk, not profit.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Two mutually exclusive projects: X has an NPV of $18,000 and an IRR of 16%; Y has an NPV of $24,000 and an IRR of 13%. The required rate is 10% and funds are available. Which should be chosen?

Question 2 of 5

A $200,000 budget. Independent projects: P costs $200,000 (NPV $30,000), Q costs $80,000 (NPV $20,000), R costs $120,000 (NPV $24,000). Which choice adds the most value?

Question 3 of 5

Which capital budgeting method is built on accounting net income rather than cash flows?

Question 4 of 5

A project's cash flows are −$100,000 now, +$230,000 in year 1 and −$132,000 in year 2. Why should the decision rest on NPV rather than IRR?

Question 5 of 5

Mutually exclusive projects: S costs $40,000 with NPV $9,000; L costs $90,000 with NPV $12,000. What is the NPV of the extra investment in L, and which project should be chosen?

← Previous topicNext topic →