Accounting › Section G · Fraud, internal controls, and cash › Topic G.2
Internal controls and their purpose
Internal controls are the everyday rules that keep assets safe and records reliable: who may sign a cheque, who counts the cash, who checks the bank statement. Designed well, they make honest mistakes visible and dishonest ones hard to hide.
What internal control means
Internal control is a process, run by an organisation's board, managers and other staff, that gives reasonable assurance that the organisation meets its objectives in three areas. Operations: working effectively and efficiently, including safeguarding assets from theft, waste and misuse. Reporting: producing reliable financial and other reports. Compliance: obeying laws and regulations. Internal controls are the specific policies and procedures that make up this process. Every kind of organisation needs them: US federal agencies follow the Government Accountability Office's "Green Book" of control standards, and not-for-profits must make sure donations restricted to a purpose are spent on it.
The COSO framework
The most widely used framework in the United States comes from the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO), a private-sector group backed by five professional bodies, including the American Institute of CPAs and the Institute of Internal Auditors. Its Internal Control – Integrated Framework was first published in 1992 and updated in 2013. It defines internal control around the three objective areas above and names five components that must all be present and working together. Most US public companies use the COSO framework when management assesses internal control over financial reporting, as the topic "Management's responsibility for internal control" explains.
COSO's five components
The control environment is the foundation: management's integrity and ethical values, the board's oversight, the organisation's structure and its commitment to competent staff, often called the tone at the top. Risk assessment identifies what could go wrong, including the risk of fraud, and how likely and serious it is. Control activities are the policies and procedures that respond to those risks, such as approvals, reconciliations and separated duties. Information and communication get reliable information to the right people in time. Monitoring activities check, through ongoing reviews and separate evaluations such as internal audits, that controls keep working, and report weaknesses.
Control activities in practice
Most control activities follow a few principles. Clear responsibility: each task belongs to a named person, so one cashier per register makes any shortage traceable. Separation of duties: authorising a transaction, holding the asset and recording it are done by different people. Documentation: prenumbered, approved forms leave a trail, and gaps in a sequence show something is missing. Physical and IT safeguards: safes, locked storerooms, passwords, access rights and off-site backups. Independent checks: reconciliations, surprise counts, job rotation and mandatory holidays. Insurance and bonding: a fidelity bond is insurance that repays the employer for losses caused by dishonest employees.
Preventive and detective controls
Controls can be grouped by when they act. Preventive controls stop an error or fraud before it happens: requiring two signatures on large cheques, limiting system access by password, or a supplier invoice that cannot be paid unless it matches an approved order. Detective controls find a problem after it has happened, so it can be corrected and the cause fixed: bank reconciliations, comparing counted inventory with the records, reviewing reports for unusual entries, and surprise cash counts. A sound system uses both, because no preventive control is perfect, and knowing that detective checks exist also deters fraud.
Controlling cash receipts
Cash is the asset most easily stolen, so it gets the tightest controls. Two people open the post together and list every payment received. Each cheque is stamped with a restrictive endorsement, "For deposit only" to the company's account, as soon as it arrives. All receipts are deposited intact and promptly, usually daily, so the deposit can be compared with the list. Registers or POS systems record every sale, and a supervisor compares the system's totals with the cash counted at each shift change. The person who handles cash does not post customer accounts, and someone independent of both prepares the bank reconciliation.
Controlling cash payments
Payments are made by cheque or electronic transfer, never from cash receipts, except for small amounts from petty cash, covered in the topic "Petty cash funds". New suppliers are added to an approved supplier list by someone outside purchasing and payments. Before a bill is paid, a three-way match compares the purchase order (what was ordered), the receiving report (what arrived) and the supplier's invoice (what is charged). The person who prepares a payment does not approve or sign it, larger payments need two approvals, and each paid invoice is stamped "Paid" so it cannot be submitted twice. Bank statements go to someone who does not handle payments.
Worked example: separating duties in a small office
Marlow Tutoring has three people: the owner, an office assistant and a part-time bookkeeper. Six cash tasks need owners. 1. Opening the post and listing cheques received: the assistant. 2. Endorsing and depositing them: the assistant. 3. Posting customer payments from the assistant's list: the bookkeeper. 4. Preparing supplier cheques from approved, matched bills: the bookkeeper. 5. Approving bills and signing cheques: the owner. 6. Receiving the bank statement unopened and reconciling it: the owner. Check each person: the assistant holds cash but records nothing; the bookkeeper records but never touches cash or signs; the owner authorises and checks. No one person can both take cash and hide it in the records.
Worked example: diagnosing a weakness
At Tamsin Fabrication, one purchasing officer can add a new supplier to the system, approve that supplier's invoices and release electronic payments. 1. Risk: she could create a fake supplier, send it invoices and pay them, a billing scheme. 2. Principle broken: separation of duties, because authorising, recording and paying sit with one person. 3. Fixes: supplier set-up moves to an accounts payable supervisor who verifies tax numbers and bank details; invoices are paid only after a three-way match; payments are released by the controller. 4. Detective back-up: a monthly report of new suppliers and of suppliers sharing an employee's bank account or address. Check: each fix removes a step she controls alone.
Why controls give only reasonable assurance
No system can guarantee that errors or fraud will never happen. Controls cost money, so managers weigh each one's cost against the loss it prevents; nobody posts a guard at the stationery cupboard. Separation of duties fails when two or more employees work together to defeat it, which is called collusion. Senior managers may override controls, which is why the control environment and board oversight matter so much. People make careless errors, and controls go out of date as staff, systems and risks change. Small businesses too small to separate every duty rely on the owner's direct review.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking internal control is only about preventing theft; it also aims at efficient operations, reliable reports and legal compliance. Second, listing separation of duties as a COSO component; it is a control activity, and the five components are control environment, risk assessment, control activities, information and communication, and monitoring. Third, letting the person who handles cash also record it or reconcile the bank account. Fourth, expecting controls to guarantee safety; they give reasonable assurance and can be defeated by collusion or management override. Fifth, paying a bill without checking that the goods were ordered and received.
Key takeaways
Internal control is a process giving reasonable assurance about operations, including safeguarding assets, reporting and compliance. COSO's framework, first issued in 1992 and updated in 2013, has five components: control environment, risk assessment, control activities, information and communication, and monitoring activities. Control activities rest on clear responsibility, separation of authorising, custody and recording, documentation, physical and IT safeguards, independent checks, and insurance and bonding. Preventive controls stop problems; detective controls find them. Cash receipts are listed, endorsed and deposited intact; payments need approved suppliers, a three-way match and separate signers. Collusion, override, cost and human error limit every system.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A process giving reasonable assurance about operations, reporting and compliance objectives
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which of these is NOT one of the five components of internal control in the COSO framework?
Question 2 of 5
Before paying a supplier's bill, a clerk performs a three-way match. Which three documents are compared?
Question 3 of 5
Which pair of duties is most important to give to different people?
Question 4 of 5
A cashier and her supervisor agree to void real sales and split the cash. Which limitation of internal control does this show?
Question 5 of 5
An internal auditor makes an unannounced count of a store's cash drawers. What kind of control is this?
