Accounting › Section R · Job order and process costing › Topic R.4
Costing a job and fixing misapplied overhead
A finished job cost sheet tells managers what a job really cost and whether its price made sense. At year end, one more step remains: the overhead charged to jobs never quite matches the overhead actually spent, and the difference has to be cleared.
Pulling a job's cost together
By the time a job is finished, three streams of cost have reached its job cost sheet. Direct materials arrive from materials requisitions, direct labour from time tickets, and overhead from the predetermined rate times the base the job used, as set out in "Predetermined overhead rates". The sheet is the subsidiary record behind work in process: while the job is open, its total is part of the Work in Process Inventory balance, and when it is finished, that total moves to Finished Goods Inventory. When the goods are delivered and the sale is recorded, the same total becomes cost of goods sold. This topic completes a job cost sheet for Brackenridge Cabinetry and then deals with overhead that was charged too high or too low.
What a job cost sheet shows
A job cost sheet has a header and three cost sections. The header gives the job number, the customer, a short description, and the dates started and completed. The materials section lists each requisition by number and amount. The labour section lists hours and cost from time tickets, often by department. The overhead section shows the base used, the rate and the amount applied. A summary at the bottom totals the three, divides by the units in the job to give a unit cost, and often records the selling price, so the sheet shows the job's gross profit. Because every figure points to a source document, the sheet also gives an audit trail for each charge.
Worked example: Job 302
Job 302 is a 16-cabinet kitchen. Requisitions R-411, R-418 and R-425 supplied materials; 80 hours were spent on assembly and 40 on finishing at $25 an hour; overhead is $30 per labour hour.
1. Materials total $5,600. 2. Labour is \(120 \times 25 = 3{,}000\). 3. Overhead is \(120 \times 30 = 3{,}600\). 4. Total cost is $12,200, and the cost per cabinet is \(12{,}200 \div 16 = 762.50\), or $762.50.
Using the job cost
Brackenridge prices kitchens at cost plus a 35% markup, so Job 302's price is \(12{,}200 \times 1.35 = 16{,}470\), or $16,470. Comparing each completed sheet with the original quote shows where estimates were wrong, perhaps too few finishing hours, and improves the next quote. Job costs also matter under cost-plus contracts, where the customer pays cost plus a fee. These create a temptation to load extra overhead or unused materials onto a job. Accountants must charge only costs the job actually used, at the rate disclosed, because a padded job cost is a misstatement and may amount to fraud against the customer.
Underapplied and overapplied overhead
During the year, actual overhead is debited to Manufacturing Overhead (shortened to Mfg. Overhead) and applied overhead is credited to it. The two rarely match, because actual overhead differs from the estimate and the actual base differs from the estimated base. A debit balance at year end means actual overhead exceeded applied overhead: overhead is underapplied, and jobs were charged too little. A credit balance means applied exceeded actual: overhead is overapplied, and jobs were charged too much.
Because most of the jobs have been sold, the error sits mainly in cost of goods sold, which must be corrected before the financial statements are prepared.
Worked example: underapplied at year end
Brackenridge set its 2026 rate at $30 per labour hour. 1. Actual overhead for the year was $371,400. 2. Actual labour hours were 11,800, so applied overhead was \(11{,}800 \times 30 = 354{,}000\). 3. The difference, \(371{,}400 - 354{,}000 = 17{,}400\), is a debit balance: overhead is underapplied by $17,400. 4. The usual entry, when the amount is small, closes the balance to cost of goods sold:
5. Cost of goods sold rises, because jobs sold during the year carried too little overhead, and Mfg. Overhead now has a zero balance.
Overapplied overhead
The opposite case leaves a credit balance. Suppose instead that Brackenridge's actual overhead had been $349,500 against $354,000 applied. Overhead would be overapplied by \(354{,}000 - 349{,}500 = 4{,}500\), meaning jobs carried $4,500 more overhead than was spent. Closing it reduces cost of goods sold:
In both cases the entry moves the balance so that Mfg. Overhead ends at zero, and the debit or credit to cost of goods sold matches the direction of the original error.
Worked example: prorating a large balance
When the balance is material, closing it all to cost of goods sold would misstate inventory, so it is prorated. Brackenridge's $354,000 of applied overhead sits in Work in Process Inventory (WIP Inventory) $21,240, Finished Goods Inventory (FG Inventory) $35,400 and cost of goods sold $297,360. 1. Shares: 6%, 10% and 84%. 2. WIP gets \(0.06 \times 17{,}400 = 1{,}044\); FG gets \(0.10 \times 17{,}400 = 1{,}740\); cost of goods sold gets \(0.84 \times 17{,}400 = 14{,}616\). 3. Check: they sum to $17,400.
Some firms prorate on total account balances instead; this topic uses applied overhead.
Reading the balance
A small balance that flips between underapplied and overapplied from year to year suggests the rate is about right. A balance that runs the same way every year is a warning. Overhead overapplied five years running means the rate is set too high, so job costs and cost-based quotes have been overstated, and the firm may have lost bids it could have won. Persistent underapplication means jobs have been underpriced. Managers split the gap into a spending part (costs differed from budget) and a volume part (activity differed from plan), an analysis developed in "Overhead variances".
Common mistakes to avoid
First, reversing the labels: a debit balance in Mfg. Overhead is underapplied, a credit balance overapplied. Second, computing applied overhead with estimated instead of actual hours. Third, closing underapplied overhead with a credit to cost of goods sold; underapplied overhead increases it. Fourth, closing a large balance entirely to cost of goods sold when much of it belongs in ending inventories. Fifth, leaving a job cost sheet without overhead because the job is unfinished at period end. Sixth, dividing the total job cost by the wrong number of units, or ignoring that the sheet total must agree with the inventory accounts.
Key takeaways
A job cost sheet totals requisitioned materials, time-ticket labour and applied overhead, and gives a unit cost and a basis for pricing; Job 302 cost $12,200, or $762.50 a cabinet. Actual overhead is debited and applied overhead credited to Mfg. Overhead. A year-end debit balance is underapplied overhead and a credit balance overapplied. A small balance is closed to cost of goods sold; a material one is prorated among WIP, finished goods and cost of goods sold. Brackenridge's $17,400 underapplied balance raised cost of goods sold, or was split $1,044, $1,740 and $14,616.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Materials, labour and applied overhead for one job, with totals
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A job has materials of $4,200 and 60 labour hours at $22 an hour. Overhead is applied at $35 per labour hour. What is the job's total cost?
Question 2 of 5
Actual overhead was $512,000. Overhead is applied at $16 per machine hour, and 31,000 machine hours were used. What is the result and how is it closed?
Question 3 of 5
At year end Mfg. Overhead has a small credit balance of $6,000. Which entry closes it?
Question 4 of 5
Overhead is underapplied by $20,000, a material amount. Applied overhead sits 10% in WIP, 15% in finished goods and 75% in cost of goods sold. How much is charged to cost of goods sold?
Question 5 of 5
A job of 20 identical tables cost $14,500 and is priced at cost plus 30%. What is the price per table?
