Accounting › Section E · Merchandising transactions › Topic E.1
Merchandising versus service businesses
A consulting firm sells its people's time; a kitchen shop sells blenders it bought from someone else. That one difference, owning goods for resale, adds new accounts, a longer cash cycle and a new line on the income statement: the cost of the goods sold.
Two ways to earn revenue
A service business earns revenue by performing work for customers: a law firm, a plumbing contractor, a tutoring company or an accounting practice. It has no goods for sale, so its main costs are wages, rent and similar operating expenses. A merchandising business earns revenue by buying finished goods and reselling them without changing their form. Retailers, such as a hardware store or an online clothing shop, sell to the final consumer; wholesalers buy in bulk from producers and sell to retailers and other businesses. A manufacturer, by contrast, makes the goods it sells from raw materials, and its costs are covered in the managerial topic "Merchandising, manufacturing, and service costs". This section focuses on merchandisers.
Two operating cycles
The operating cycle is the time it takes to turn cash back into cash through normal business. For a service firm the cycle is short: it pays staff and other costs, performs the service, bills the client and collects. A merchandiser's cycle has an extra stage. It spends cash on inventory, holds the goods until they sell, sells them for cash or on credit, and then collects from customers. Its cycle is therefore roughly the days goods sit in stock plus the days it takes to collect. If Brackenhill Kitchen Supply Inc. holds a typical item for about 65 days and collects in about 30, its cycle is about 95 days. During all that time its cash is tied up, which is why merchandisers watch inventory levels so closely.
New accounts for a merchandiser
Holding goods for resale needs accounts that a service firm never uses. Inventory (in full, merchandise inventory) is a current asset that holds the cost of goods on hand. Sales is the revenue account for goods sold to customers. Cost of Goods Sold, often shortened to COGS, is the expense that records the cost of the goods that were sold; under the matching idea, that cost becomes an expense in the period the goods are sold, not the period they were bought. Contra-revenue accounts, Sales Returns and Allowances and Sales Discounts, carry debit balances and reduce Sales. How and when these accounts are updated depends on the inventory system, the subject of "Perpetual versus periodic inventory systems".
The language of purchases
Gross purchases are the invoice cost of goods bought before any reductions. A purchase return is goods sent back to the supplier for a full refund or credit. A purchase allowance is a price reduction the supplier grants when the buyer keeps goods that are damaged or not quite as ordered. A purchase discount is a reduction for paying early. Credit terms of 2/10, n/30 mean the buyer may deduct 2% if it pays within 10 days of the invoice date; otherwise the full amount is due within 30 days. Net purchases are gross purchases minus returns, allowances and discounts. A trade discount, a reduction from a list price agreed before the sale, is not recorded separately: the purchase is simply recorded at the agreed price.
The language of sales
The seller sees each of those events from the other side. Gross sales are total sales at invoice prices. A sales return occurs when a customer sends goods back; a sales allowance is a price cut given to a customer who keeps imperfect goods; a sales discount is the reduction a customer takes for paying within the discount period. Net sales equal gross sales minus sales returns and allowances and sales discounts. Net sales is the revenue figure that a merchandiser compares with its cost of goods sold. The journal entries on each side are set out in "Recording merchandise purchases" and "Recording sales, returns, and discounts".
Two income statements
A service company's income statement is short: revenues minus expenses equals net income. A merchandiser's statement inserts a step. Net sales minus cost of goods sold gives gross profit, also called gross margin: the amount left from sales, after paying for the goods themselves, to cover every other expense and provide a profit. Operating expenses such as wages, rent, advertising and delivery are then subtracted. Gross profit is the line that tells you whether the business can buy and sell goods at a sensible mark-up at all. The full layouts, including other revenues, expenses and income taxes, are covered in "Multi-step and simple income statements".
Worked example: a service firm beside a merchandiser
Ignoring income taxes to keep the comparison simple, here are one year's results. 1. Sorrelby Lane Consulting Inc., a service firm:
2. Brackenhill Kitchen Supply Inc., a retailer (Sales Ret. and Allow. is Sales Returns and Allowances):
3. Check: $400,000 − $252,000 = $148,000, and $148,000 − $101,000 = $47,000.
Worked example: reading Brackenhill's margins
Percentages of net sales show where each sales dollar goes. 1. Gross margin percentage: gross profit ÷ net sales = $148,000 ÷ $400,000 = 37%. Of every $1 of sales, 63 cents paid for the goods and 37 cents was left. 2. Operating expenses: $101,000 ÷ $400,000 = 25.25% of sales. 3. Net income: $47,000 ÷ $400,000 = 11.75% of sales, which is 37% minus 25.25%. 4. Interpret: if a supplier raised prices and COGS rose to 66% of sales, gross margin would fall to 34% and, with the same operating expenses, net income would fall to 8.75% of sales. Gross margin percentages vary widely between industries, so compare a store with similar stores, not with a consulting firm.
Common mistakes to avoid
1. Recording the cost of inventory as an expense when it is bought. It is an asset until the goods are sold, and only then does it become Cost of Goods Sold. 2. Treating gross profit as net income. Operating expenses still have to be subtracted. 3. Reporting gross sales as the revenue figure, which ignores returns, allowances and discounts. 4. Thinking contra-revenue accounts are expenses. They reduce Sales and have debit balances, but they are not costs of running the business. 5. Recording a trade discount as a separate item; the purchase or sale is simply recorded at the discounted price. 6. Calling every seller of goods a merchandiser: a business that makes its products is a manufacturer.
Key takeaways
Service businesses sell work; merchandisers buy finished goods and resell them, as retailers or wholesalers; manufacturers make their goods. A merchandiser's operating cycle runs from cash to inventory to sale to collection, so it is usually longer than a service firm's. Merchandisers add Inventory, Sales, Cost of Goods Sold and contra-revenue accounts. Net purchases equal gross purchases minus returns, allowances and discounts; net sales equal gross sales minus returns, allowances and discounts. Terms of 2/10, n/30 offer 2% off for payment within 10 days, with the full amount due in 30. Net sales minus cost of goods sold is gross profit, and gross profit ÷ net sales is the gross margin percentage.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Earns revenue by performing work; holds no goods for sale
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which of these is a merchandising business?
Question 2 of 5
Gross sales are $150,000, sales returns and allowances are $4,000 and sales discounts are $1,000. What are net sales?
Question 3 of 5
Net sales are $200,000, cost of goods sold is $130,000 and operating expenses are $45,000. What is gross profit?
Question 4 of 5
What do credit terms of 2/10, n/30 mean?
Question 5 of 5
When does the cost of goods a merchandiser buys become an expense?
