Accounting › Section E · Merchandising transactions › Topic E.2

Perpetual versus periodic inventory systems

Every merchandiser must know what its goods cost and how many it has left. It can keep a running record that changes with every purchase and sale, or it can count the stock at the end of the period and work backwards. The choice changes the accounts, the journal entries and what managers can see.

Two ways to keep track of goods

Inventory accounting has to answer two questions: what did the goods that were sold cost, and what do the goods still on hand cost? An inventory system is the record-keeping method a business uses to answer them. Under a perpetual system the records are updated continuously, so both answers are available at any moment. Under a periodic system the records are brought up to date only at the end of a period, after a physical count. Both are acceptable under US GAAP, and IFRS also permits either one. The choice of system is separate from the choice of costing method, such as first-in, first-out, which is covered in "Inventory valuation methods".

The perpetual system

A perpetual system updates Inventory, the asset account for merchandise on hand, and Cost of Goods Sold every time goods are bought or sold. A purchase is debited straight to Inventory. Each sale needs two entries: one at selling price for the revenue, and one at cost that moves the goods out of Inventory and into Cost of Goods Sold. Returns, allowances and purchase discounts also adjust Inventory directly. Point-of-sale scanners and inventory software make this practical even for stores with thousands of products, because each scan updates the quantity and cost on file. Managers can see stock levels, reorder needs and gross profit at any time.

The periodic system

A periodic system keeps no running record of the cost of goods sold. Purchases of merchandise are debited to a temporary account called Purchases rather than to Inventory, so during the year the Inventory account still shows the balance from the last count. A sale needs only one entry, for the revenue. Purchase returns and allowances, purchase discounts and the cost of shipping goods in are recorded in their own temporary accounts: Purchase Returns and Allowances and Purchase Discounts, which are contra accounts with credit balances, and Freight-In, which has a debit balance. At the end of the period the business counts what is left and works out the cost of goods sold.

The periodic cost of goods sold

With beginning inventory BI, net cost of purchases P and ending inventory EI from the count,

\text{COGS} = \text{BI} + \text{P} - \text{EI}

The logic is a flow of goods. Beginning inventory plus everything bought during the period is the cost of goods available for sale. Whatever is not still on the shelves at the end must have been sold, or lost. The net cost of purchases is built up in two steps. Net purchases equal Purchases minus Purchase Returns and Allowances minus Purchase Discounts. Adding Freight-In gives the cost of goods purchased, because shipping goods in is part of their cost, as "Shipping terms and freight-in" explains.

Worked example: periodic COGS at Fernway

Fernway Garden Supply Inc. uses a periodic system. For 2026: beginning inventory $42,000; Purchases $186,000; Purchase Returns and Allowances $5,400; Purchase Discounts $3,100; Freight-In $4,500; and the 31 December count values ending inventory at $47,600. 1. Net purchases: $186,000 − $5,400 − $3,100 = $177,500. 2. Cost of goods purchased: $177,500 + $4,500 = $182,000. 3. Cost of goods available for sale: $42,000 + $182,000 = $224,000. 4. Cost of goods sold: $224,000 − $47,600 = $176,400. 5. Check the flow: of $224,000 of goods Fernway could have sold, $47,600 remain and $176,400 left the shelves. The ending inventory of $47,600 becomes the beginning inventory for 2027.

Worked example: one sale recorded both ways

Fernway sells pots on account for $1,100; they cost $700. 1. Perpetual: record the revenue, then the cost. Accounts Receivable is shortened to Accts Receivable in the entry.

\begin{array}{lrr}\text{Account}&\text{Debit}&\text{Credit}\\\hline\text{Accts Receivable}&1{,}100&\\\quad\text{Sales}&&1{,}100\end{array}
\begin{array}{lrr}\text{Account}&\text{Debit}&\text{Credit}\\\hline\text{Cost of Goods Sold}&700&\\\quad\text{Inventory}&&700\end{array}

2. Periodic: record only the first entry. The $700 cost is not recorded now; it is captured in the year-end calculation of COGS. 3. Compare purchases: a $2,000 purchase on account is debited to Inventory under the perpetual system, but to Purchases under the periodic system, with Accounts Payable credited either way.

Counting stock under a perpetual system

A perpetual system shows what should be on hand, not what actually is. Goods are stolen, broken, miscounted or spoil, and the loss of goods for no recorded reason is called shrinkage. So perpetual users still count their stock, at least once a year, and adjust the books to the count. Fernway's sister store keeps perpetual records showing Inventory of $61,300, but the count finds goods costing $59,850. Shrinkage is $61,300 − $59,850 = $1,450, adjusted like this:

\begin{array}{lrr}\text{Account}&\text{Debit}&\text{Credit}\\\hline\text{Cost of Goods Sold}&1{,}450&\\\quad\text{Inventory}&&1{,}450\end{array}

Under a periodic system shrinkage cannot be seen separately: it is buried in COGS, because anything not counted is assumed sold.

Choosing a system

The perpetual system gives up-to-date figures for reordering, pricing and interim statements, and it reveals shrinkage when the count is compared with the records. Its costs are software, scanning equipment and staff training, and the records can drift from reality if counts are rare. The periodic system is cheaper and simpler to run, which can suit a small shop with many low-cost items. Its weaknesses are that cost of goods sold and gross profit are unknown until the count, interim statements need estimates, and losses are hidden. With low-cost point-of-sale software now widely available, many merchandisers, especially medium and large ones, use a perpetual system, and the rest of this section records transactions that way.

Common mistakes to avoid

1. Debiting Inventory for purchases under a periodic system. Purchases go to the Purchases account. 2. Forgetting the second, cost entry for each sale under a perpetual system, which leaves inventory overstated and COGS understated. 3. Subtracting Freight-In when computing the cost of goods purchased. It is added, because it is part of the cost. 4. Thinking a perpetual system removes the need for a physical count. Counts are still needed to find shrinkage. 5. Confusing the inventory system with the costing method: perpetual or periodic describes when records are updated, while methods such as first-in, first-out describe which costs are assigned to the goods sold.

Key takeaways

A perpetual system updates Inventory and Cost of Goods Sold with every purchase and sale, so each sale needs a revenue entry and a cost entry. A periodic system records purchases in a temporary Purchases account, records only the revenue for each sale, and finds cost of goods sold at the end of the period: COGS = beginning inventory + net cost of purchases − ending inventory. Net purchases equal Purchases minus purchase returns, allowances and discounts; adding Freight-In gives the cost of goods purchased. Physical counts are needed under both systems; under a perpetual system they reveal shrinkage, which is recorded by debiting COGS and crediting Inventory.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Perpetual inventory system

Updates Inventory and COGS with every purchase and sale

Point-of-sale scanners make it practical.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Under a periodic system, beginning inventory is $30,000, the net cost of purchases is $95,000 and ending inventory is $28,000. What is cost of goods sold?

Question 2 of 5

A company using a perpetual system sells goods on account. Which entries does it record?

Question 3 of 5

Purchases are $80,000, Purchase Returns and Allowances $2,000, Purchase Discounts $1,500 and Freight-In $3,000. What is the cost of goods purchased?

Question 4 of 5

Perpetual records show inventory of $25,000, but a physical count finds goods costing $24,200. What adjusting entry is needed?

Question 5 of 5

Under a periodic system, a merchandiser buys goods on account. Which account is debited?

← Previous topicNext topic →