Accounting › Section W · Short-term decision making › Topic W.5
Sell or process further
Many products can be sold as they are or worked on further and sold for more. Whether the extra work pays depends only on what it adds, never on what was spent to get the product this far.
When to stop processing
A dairy can sell cream as it is or churn it into butter. A sawmill can sell rough boards or plane and treat them. A bakery can sell day-old bread or turn it into croutons. Each faces a sell-or-process-further decision: sell a product at its current stage, or spend more to turn it into something worth more. The decision is short-term, because it can be revisited batch by batch, and it is analysed with the tools of "Relevant information and sunk costs". The key is to see which costs the decision can still change and which are already locked in.
Joint products and the split-off point
Some processes turn one input into several products at once. Raw milk separates into cream and skimmed milk; crude oil is refined into petrol, diesel and other fuels; a log becomes boards, offcuts and sawdust. These are joint products, and the costs of the shared process that produces them are joint costs. The split-off point is the stage at which the products become separately identifiable and can each be sold or processed further. A by-product is an output of the joint process whose sales value is small compared with the main joint products, such as sawdust at a sawmill. Costs incurred after split-off for one product alone are its separable costs.
Why joint costs are irrelevant here
By the time a manager asks whether to process cream into butter, the milk has been bought and separated. Those joint costs are incurred whatever happens to the cream next, so they do not differ between selling and processing, and they cannot affect the choice. Joint costs become relevant only to a different question: whether to run the joint process at all. That question is answered by comparing the total value of all the joint products with the joint costs plus any separable costs. Mixing up the two questions is the commonest error in this topic.
The decision rule
Process a product further if the extra revenue it brings exceeds the extra cost of processing:
A positive gain means process further; a negative one means sell at split-off. Separable costs include materials, labour, packaging, and any fixed costs that exist only because of the further processing, such as leasing a machine. Watch quantities: processing can change the amount of output, as when cream loses weight in becoming butter, so compute each total from the quantity actually sold.
Worked example: butter at Vellacott Dairy
Vellacott Dairy, a fictional business, separates raw milk each month at a joint cost of $52,000, giving 10,000 litres of cream and 90,000 litres of skimmed milk. At split-off, cream sells for $3.20 a litre and skimmed milk for $0.55. Churning the cream would yield 4,200 kg of butter selling at $9.50 a kg, with separable costs of $5,600. 1. Cream at split-off: 10,000 × $3.20 = $32,000. 2. Butter: 4,200 × $9.50 = $39,900. 3. Analysis:
4. Churn the cream: income rises by $2,300 a month. 5. The $52,000 joint cost was ignored, correctly. Checking the whole process: split-off sales of $32,000 + $49,500 = $81,500 exceed the joint cost by $29,500, so running it is worthwhile too.
Allocating joint costs for the accounts
Although joint costs do not affect further-processing decisions, they cannot be left out of the financial statements. Under US GAAP, production costs are part of the cost of inventory, so the joint cost must be divided among the joint products to value inventory and cost of goods sold. Common methods include the physical units method, which shares joint cost by litres, kilograms or other measures of output, and the relative sales value method, which shares it by each product's sales value at split-off. A variant, the net realisable value method, uses the final sales value less separable costs. Each gives a different cost per product.
Worked example: an allocation that misleads
Vellacott could turn its 90,000 litres of skimmed milk into yogurt selling for $72,000, with separable costs of $26,000. 1. Incremental analysis: extra revenue $72,000 − $49,500 = $22,500, less $26,000 of separable costs, gives −$3,500. Sell the skimmed milk at split-off. 2. Now look at allocated figures. By physical units, skimmed milk carries 90% of the joint cost, $46,800, and yogurt shows a 'profit' of $72,000 − $46,800 − $26,000 = −$800. By relative sales value, it carries $52,000 × 49,500 ÷ 81,500 = $31,583, rounded, and yogurt shows +$14,417, which looks attractive. 3. But under the same allocation, skimmed milk sold at split-off shows $49,500 − $31,583 = $17,917, which is $3,500 more. 4. The allocated cost is identical under both options, so it cancels, and only the incremental answer is reliable.
Other factors to weigh
Further processing may need capacity that has another use, which adds an opportunity cost. It may need new skills, storage or equipment, and the market for the processed product may be uncertain: the forecast price for yogurt or butter is an estimate, so a small gain deserves caution. A processed product can also take sales from existing lines; a furniture maker that starts selling finished pieces may sell fewer unfinished ones. Against that, a new product can strengthen a brand, use waste that would otherwise go to landfill, or open a new market.
Common mistakes to avoid
1. Including joint costs, or an allocated share of them, in a further-processing decision. 2. Judging a processed product by its allocated 'profit' alone instead of comparing it with selling at split-off. 3. Using the processed price without subtracting the value given up at split-off. 4. Forgetting separable fixed costs, such as a machine lease needed only for further processing. 5. Ignoring a change in quantity, such as weight lost in processing. 6. Confusing the further-processing question with the question of whether to run the joint process at all.
Key takeaways
Joint products emerge together from one process, and the split-off point is where they become separately saleable. Joint costs are incurred regardless of what happens after split-off, so they are irrelevant to further-processing decisions; they matter only when deciding whether to run the joint process at all. Process further if the increase in sales value exceeds the separable costs. Joint costs are still allocated, by physical units, relative sales value or net realisable value, to value inventory, but an allocated 'profit' is no guide to the decision. Weigh capacity, market risk and effects on other products.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Several products produced together from one input and process
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A product sells for $20 a unit at split-off, or for $28 after further processing that costs $6 a unit. Its allocated joint cost is $15 a unit. What should the firm do?
Question 2 of 5
Why are joint costs irrelevant when deciding whether to process a joint product further?
Question 3 of 5
A firm can sell 2,000 kg of a joint product at split-off for $4 a kg. Processing it further yields 1,500 kg selling at $7 a kg, with separable costs of $2,000. What is the gain from processing further?
Question 4 of 5
When do joint costs become relevant to a decision?
Question 5 of 5
What is the main purpose of allocating joint costs among joint products?
