Accounting › Section W · Short-term decision making › Topic W.4
Keeping or dropping a segment
A product line or store that reports a loss looks like an obvious candidate for closure. Often it is not: much of that loss can come from shared costs that would simply move to the rest of the business if the segment closed.
When a segment reports a loss
A segment is any part of a business that management reports on separately: a product line, a store, a region or a group of customers. When one segment shows an operating loss year after year, managers naturally ask whether to close it. Closing a segment is usually harder to reverse than the decisions earlier in this section, but the analysis uses the same idea from "Relevant information and sunk costs": compare the company's future revenues and costs with and without the segment, and count only what would change. The reported loss itself is not the test.
Traceable and common fixed costs
A segment's fixed costs come in two kinds. Traceable fixed costs, also called direct fixed costs, exist because of that segment: its manager's salary, advertising for its products, equipment used only by it. Common fixed costs are shared by the whole business, such as head-office salaries, the accounting department or the building's insurance. Companies often allocate common costs to segments by a formula, for example in equal shares, in proportion to sales, or by floor area. Allocation is useful for reminding every segment that shared costs must be covered, but closing one segment rarely makes a common cost go away; its share is simply spread over the segments that remain.
Segment margin
A segmented income statement in contribution format, building on "Contribution margin", shows each segment's sales less variable costs, giving its contribution margin, and then subtracts its traceable fixed costs. The result is the segment margin:
Common costs are shown only once, below the segment margins, for the company as a whole. A positive segment margin means the segment is helping to pay the shared costs and earn the company's profit. A segment whose segment margin is positive can still report a loss once common costs are allocated to it.
The decision rule
Closing a segment loses its contribution margin and saves its avoidable fixed costs. If the contribution margin lost is larger than the fixed costs saved, operating income falls, so the segment should be kept, unless other effects change the picture. Be careful: not every traceable fixed cost is avoidable. Depreciation on equipment used only by the segment is traceable, but the purchase is a sunk cost, and a lease that cannot be cancelled must still be paid. Only the costs that would actually stop are set against the lost contribution margin. Two methods give the same answer: compare total company income with and without the segment, or work out the change directly.
Worked example: the garden department at Marchbank
Marchbank Home Stores, a fictional retailer, has three departments. Sales are $500,000, $400,000 and $200,000 for Kitchenware, Bedding and Garden, with contribution margins of $200,000, $180,000 and $70,000. Traceable fixed costs are $80,000, $70,000 and $45,000. Common costs of $180,000 are split equally, $60,000 each, so Garden reports $70,000 − $45,000 − $60,000 = −$35,000. Company income is $450,000 − $195,000 − $180,000 = $75,000. Of Garden's $45,000, $30,000 is staff wages that would end; $15,000 is depreciation on its fixtures. 1. Garden's segment margin is $25,000, positive. 2. Dropping Garden:
3. Check by totals: traceable fixed costs fall to $165,000, because Garden's $15,000 of depreciation stays, so $380,000 − $165,000 − $180,000 = $35,000, which is $40,000 below $75,000. 4. Keep Garden: its reported loss came from the $60,000 of common costs.
Allocation changes the picture, not the total
Suppose Marchbank allocated its $180,000 of common costs in proportion to sales instead. Total sales are $1,100,000, so Garden's share would be $180,000 × 200,000 ÷ 1,100,000 = $32,727, rounded to the nearest dollar, and its reported result would be $25,000 − $32,727 = −$7,727. Garden still shows a loss, but a much smaller one, and Kitchenware and Bedding would carry larger shares. Company income stays at $75,000 under either method, because allocation only moves costs between segments. That is why the segment margin, not the allocated result, should drive the decision. Choosing a fairer basis is still worthwhile for evaluating managers, but it cannot change the answer.
Worked example: using the freed floor space
Marchbank's managers then notice that if Garden closed, Kitchenware could take over its floor area. They forecast extra Kitchenware sales of $150,000 at Kitchenware's 40% contribution margin ratio, needing $10,000 of extra staff. 1. Extra contribution margin: 40% × $150,000 = $60,000. 2. Net effect of dropping Garden and expanding Kitchenware: −$70,000 + $30,000 + $60,000 − $10,000 = +$10,000. 3. Company income would rise to $85,000, so with this alternative use, dropping Garden is now the better choice. 4. The margin is thin. If losing garden shoppers cut Bedding's contribution margin by more than $10,000, keeping Garden would win again, so the forecast of lost customer traffic matters.
Side effects and qualitative factors
Segments affect one another. Customers who come in for one product often buy another, so closing a line can reduce the sales of the lines that remain. A freed space or machine may have a valuable alternative use, which is an opportunity cost of keeping the segment. Beyond the numbers, closure means job losses and can damage morale among the staff who stay; it may disappoint loyal customers and change how the brand is seen. A segment that is weak this year may be young or seasonal and worth keeping for its future. Closure costs, such as redundancy pay or lease-break fees, are also relevant.
Common mistakes to avoid
1. Dropping a segment because it reports a loss after allocated common costs. 2. Assuming common costs disappear with the segment; they are spread over the rest. 3. Treating every traceable fixed cost as avoidable, including depreciation and lease payments that continue. 4. Ignoring the effect on other segments' sales. 5. Forgetting the alternative use of freed space or equipment. 6. Thinking a better allocation basis changes company income. 7. Leaving out one-off closure costs and qualitative effects on staff and customers.
Key takeaways
A segment's reported loss can be caused by allocated common costs that would not disappear if it closed. The segment margin, contribution margin less traceable fixed costs, shows what the segment adds towards shared costs and profit. Drop a segment only if the fixed costs actually avoided, plus any benefit from using the freed capacity, exceed the contribution margin lost, including lost sales in other segments. Allocation methods move costs between segments but never change company income. Qualitative effects on staff, customers and the brand belong in the final judgement.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A part of a business reported on separately
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A product line has a contribution margin of $40,000, traceable fixed costs of $30,000 that would all end if it closed, and $25,000 of allocated common costs, so it reports a $15,000 loss. If it is dropped, what happens to company income?
Question 2 of 5
What is a segment margin?
Question 3 of 5
A store is deciding whether to close its toy department. Which cost is irrelevant to the decision?
Question 4 of 5
A company changes the basis for allocating its common costs from equal shares to floor area. What happens to company operating income?
Question 5 of 5
Dropping a segment loses $50,000 of contribution margin and saves $20,000 of fixed costs. The freed space would let another line earn $40,000 more contribution margin with $5,000 of extra costs. What is the net effect of dropping?
