Accounting › Section G · Fraud, internal controls, and cash › Topic G.6
Financial statement fraud and Sarbanes-Oxley
When managers falsify the financial statements themselves, investors, lenders and employees can lose billions. The frauds at Enron and WorldCom led directly to the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, which reshaped how US public companies are governed and audited.
What financial statement fraud is
Financial statement fraud is the deliberate misstatement of a company's financial statements, by recording false amounts or leaving out or obscuring information, to mislead the people who rely on them. It is often called cooking the books. Unlike most employee theft, it is usually directed by senior managers, who prepare the statements and can override controls. In the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners' surveys it is the least common kind of occupational fraud but by far the most costly per case. The victims are outsiders: shareholders, lenders, suppliers and employees whose savings hold the company's shares.
Why managers cook the books
The pressure side of the fraud triangle usually comes from the market. Managers may want to meet analysts' earnings forecasts, keep the share price rising, earn bonuses or share options tied to profit, or stay within the limits in loan agreements, called covenants. The rationalisation is often that the problem is temporary and next quarter will close the gap. It rarely does, so each misstatement must grow to keep the story going.
Inflating revenue
Revenue is the most common target. Fictitious or sham sales record sales to customers who do not exist or did not buy. Premature recognition records revenue before it is earned, and improper cutoff pushes next period's sales into this one. Channel stuffing ships far more goods to distributors than they need, often with secret rights to return them, and records it all as sales. Bill-and-hold abuse recognises revenue on goods that stay in the seller's warehouse with no genuine buyer commitment. Round-tripping sells goods to a partner with a promise to buy them back, creating revenue with no economic substance.
Other ways to distort the statements
Expenses can be hidden by capitalising them, recording an ordinary operating cost as a long-term asset so it is spread over years instead of charged now. Liabilities can be kept off the balance sheet through separate entities the company controls but does not report. Inventory and receivables can be overstated. Profits can be smoothed with "cookie-jar" reserves, over-estimated liabilities released in a bad year to boost earnings. Companies may also stress adjusted, non-GAAP measures that leave out costs; SEC rules require them to reconcile any such measure to the most directly comparable GAAP measure and, in SEC filings, not give it greater prominence.
Enron and WorldCom
Enron, a Houston energy and trading company, used special purpose entities, separate partnerships it effectively controlled, to keep large debts and losing investments off its balance sheet while reporting strong profits. When the arrangements unravelled in late 2001 it restated its results, its share price collapsed from about $90 to under $1, and it filed for bankruptcy in December 2001; its auditor, Arthur Andersen, collapsed the following year. WorldCom, a telecommunications company, recorded billions of dollars of line costs, ordinary fees paid to other networks, as capital assets. The misstatements were eventually put at about $11 billion, and its July 2002 bankruptcy was then the largest in US history.
The Sarbanes-Oxley Act
Congress responded with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX), signed in July 2002 and aimed at US public companies. It created the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB), a non-profit overseen by the SEC, which registers, inspects and disciplines the audit firms of public companies and sets their auditing standards, ending the profession's self-regulation of these audits. PCAOB standards now also make auditors of most public companies describe critical audit matters, material areas that needed especially challenging judgement. To protect auditor independence, the Act bans audit firms from providing many non-audit services, such as bookkeeping and financial systems design, to public audit clients, requires the lead and reviewing audit partners to rotate off after five years, and makes the audit committee responsible for hiring and overseeing the auditor.
Key sections of the Act
Section 302 makes the CEO and CFO personally certify every quarterly and annual report. Section 404 requires management's annual assessment of internal control over financial reporting, plus an auditor's report for larger companies; both are covered in "Management's responsibility for internal control". Section 802 makes it a crime, punishable by up to 20 years in prison, to destroy, alter or falsify records to obstruct a federal investigation, and led to SEC rules requiring audit firms to keep audit work papers for seven years. Section 806 protects employees of public companies who report suspected fraud from retaliation. Section 906 adds criminal penalties for knowingly or wilfully certifying a report that does not comply.
Worked example: reading the red flags
Corvane Medical Devices, a fictional company, reports: revenue up from $80 million to $100 million; year-end accounts receivable up from $10 million to $22 million; cash from operating activities down from $9 million to $2 million. 1. Growth rates: revenue rose 25%, but receivables rose 120%. 2. Days sales outstanding, using year-end receivables: $10 million ÷ $80 million × 365 ≈ 46 days last year, and $22 million ÷ $100 million × 365 ≈ 80 days this year. 3. Cash: sales rise while operating cash flow falls. 4. Interpretation: customers are taking far longer to pay, or some recorded sales may never be collected, possibly channel stuffing or premature revenue. 5. Conclusion: not proof of fraud, but a reason for analysts and auditors to dig deeper.
Worked example: capitalising an expense
In its first year, Halvard Freight, a fictional company, spends $6 million on routine repairs that should be expensed, but records them as equipment depreciated straight-line over five years. Ignore taxes. 1. Expense actually recognised in year 1: depreciation of $6 million ÷ 5 = $1.2 million. 2. Expense that should have been recognised: $6 million. 3. Year 1 income is overstated by $6 million − $1.2 million = $4.8 million. 4. Assets at year-end are overstated by the same $4.8 million, the undepreciated balance, so the balance sheet still balances, with retained earnings overstated too. 5. In each later year, $1.2 million of depreciation that should not exist is charged, so the fraud reverses slowly unless new expenses are capitalised to keep profits up.
Has it worked?
Opinions on Sarbanes-Oxley differ. Critics point to its cost, especially the audit of internal control under Section 404, which weighs most heavily on smaller companies; this is one reason companies below the accelerated-filer size are exempt from the auditor's report under 404(b). Supporters argue that certified reports, independent audit committees and PCAOB inspections have made reporting more reliable. Fraud has not disappeared: in 2020 the German payments company Wirecard admitted that about 1.9 billion euros of reported cash probably did not exist, a reminder that rules work only when enforced.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating financial statement fraud as the same as employee theft; it is usually directed by management and harms outside users. Second, assuming every aggressive estimate is fraud; fraud requires an intent to deceive. Third, confusing the cases: Enron hid debt in off-balance-sheet entities, while WorldCom capitalised operating costs. Fourth, believing SOX applies to every business; its main requirements apply to public companies. Fifth, mixing up the PCAOB, which oversees the auditors of public companies, with the SEC, which regulates the companies and markets and oversees the PCAOB.
Key takeaways
Financial statement fraud deliberately misstates the statements to mislead users, usually at management's direction, and is the rarest but costliest kind of occupational fraud. Common schemes inflate revenue (sham sales, premature recognition, channel stuffing, bill-and-hold abuse, round-tripping), capitalise expenses, hide liabilities or overstate assets. Red flags include receivables growing much faster than sales and profits rising while operating cash flow falls. Enron's off-balance-sheet entities and WorldCom's capitalised line costs led to the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, which created the PCAOB, strengthened auditor independence and audit committees, required executive certifications and control reports, and protected whistleblowers.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Deliberately misstating the financial statements to mislead users
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A company records $3 million of routine maintenance as equipment, depreciated straight-line over 5 years. Ignoring taxes, by how much is year 1 income overstated?
Question 2 of 5
Which pattern most strongly suggests a company may be recognising revenue too early?
Question 3 of 5
What is the main role of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB)?
Question 4 of 5
Enron's best-known accounting device for hiding debt and losses was what?
Question 5 of 5
Which is a requirement of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act on auditor independence?
