Accounting › Section H · Accounting for receivables › Topic H.1

The revenue recognition principle

Revenue is usually the largest number on an income statement, and deciding when it has been earned is one of the hardest calls in accounting. US GAAP answers that question with a single five-step model that applies to almost every sale a business makes.

When has a sale really happened?

Picture an outdoor-gear shop on a Saturday. One customer pays cash for a tent, another charges a kayak to an in-house credit account, a third pays by card, and a fourth buys a gift card for a friend. Cash arrives at four different times. If revenue followed cash, the gift card would count as a sale before anything had been handed over, and the kayak would not count until the bill was paid. Accrual accounting rejects both answers: it ties revenue to what the business has done for the customer, not to when money changes hands.

The principle and the standard behind it

The revenue recognition principle says a company recognises revenue when, or as, it transfers promised goods or services to a customer, at the amount it expects to be entitled to in exchange. In the US the rule is set by the Financial Accounting Standards Board in ASC 606, Revenue from Contracts with Customers. Its international counterpart, IFRS 15, was developed jointly with it and is largely the same. Both replaced older industry-specific rules: ASC 606 took effect for US public companies in 2018 and for private companies later, and IFRS 15 took effect in 2018. The key word is control: revenue is earned when the customer gains control of what was promised.

Steps 1 and 2: the contract and the promises

Step 1 is to identify the contract. It can be written, spoken or implied by normal business practice, but it must be approved by both parties, set out each party's rights and the payment terms, have commercial substance, and make it probable that the seller will collect substantially all of what it is owed. Step 2 is to identify the performance obligations: the distinct goods or services promised. A promise is distinct if the customer can benefit from it on its own and it is separately identifiable from the other promises. A laptop sold with a two-year support plan contains two performance obligations, because each could be bought and used separately.

Steps 3 and 4: price and allocation

Step 3 is to determine the transaction price, the total consideration the seller expects to receive. A fixed price is easy. Variable amounts, such as volume rebates, performance bonuses or expected returns, must be estimated, and only the amount unlikely to be significantly reversed later is included. Step 4 is to allocate that price to the performance obligations in proportion to their standalone selling prices, the prices at which the seller would sell each item separately. When a bundle is sold at a discount, the discount is normally shared across all the items.

Step 5: a point in time or over time

Step 5 is to recognise revenue when, or as, each obligation is satisfied. Most sales of goods are satisfied at a point in time, when control passes. Signs of that moment include the customer taking physical possession or legal title, accepting the goods, bearing the risks and rewards of ownership, or the seller having a present right to payment. An obligation is satisfied over time if the customer receives the benefit as the seller performs (a monthly cleaning contract), if the customer controls the asset while it is being built, or if the asset has no alternative use to the seller and the seller has an enforceable right to payment for work done so far. The topic "Revenue recognition on long-term projects" measures that progress.

Worked example: a bundled sale

Larkspur Fitness sells a rowing machine with a 12-month app subscription for a single price of $1,440, paid in cash and delivered on 1 October. Sold separately, the machine is priced at $1,200 and the subscription at $400. 1. Contract: a paid sales agreement. 2. Obligations: the machine and the subscription, each distinct. 3. Price: $1,440. 4. Allocate by standalone prices, which total $1,600: machine \(1{,}440 \times \frac{1{,}200}{1{,}600} = 1{,}080\), subscription \(1{,}440 \times \frac{400}{1{,}600} = 360\). 5. The machine is a point-in-time sale on delivery; the subscription is earned over time at $30 a month.

\begin{array}{lrr} \text{Account} & \text{Debit} & \text{Credit} \\ \hline \text{Cash} & 1{,}440 & \\ \quad\text{Sales} & & 1{,}080 \\ \quad\text{Unearned Revenue} & & 360 \end{array}

By 31 December, $90 has moved to Service Revenue and $270 remains a liability. Check: $1,080 plus $360 is $1,440.

Matching the costs of a sale

The expense recognition principle, often called matching, says that costs which help earn revenue are recognised in the same period as that revenue. When goods are sold, their cost leaves inventory and becomes cost of goods sold at the moment the sale is recognised, so every sale of goods produces two entries: one for the revenue and one for its cost. Costs with no direct link to a sale, such as office rent, are period costs, recognised as time passes. Recognising revenue a period late understates this period's profit; delaying an expense overstates it.

Worked example: credit and card sales

Harbourline Outfitters sells two sea kayaks to a club on account for $8,000; the kayaks cost $5,200. 1. Control passes on delivery, so revenue is recognised now, even though cash comes later (entries shorten Accounts Receivable to Accts Receivable).

\begin{array}{lrr} \text{Account} & \text{Debit} & \text{Credit} \\ \hline \text{Accts Receivable} & 8{,}000 & \\ \quad\text{Sales} & & 8{,}000 \\ \text{Cost of Goods Sold} & 5{,}200 & \\ \quad\text{Inventory} & & 5{,}200 \end{array}

2. When the club pays, debit Cash and credit Accounts Receivable for $8,000; no new revenue arises. 3. A walk-in customer buys a $600 paddle set by card, and the card processor deposits the money the same day minus a 3% fee: debit Cash $582 and Credit Card Expense $18, credit Sales $600. Revenue is the full $600, because the fee is a cost of collecting, not a price cut.

Cash first: unearned revenue and gift cards

When a customer pays before the seller performs, the seller has an obligation, not revenue. The cash is recorded with a credit to Unearned Revenue, a liability that ASC 606 calls a contract liability, and revenue is recognised only as the goods or services are delivered. Gift cards follow the same logic: selling a $50 card creates a $50 liability, and revenue arises when the holder redeems it. Some cards are never used. A seller that can reasonably estimate this unused portion, called breakage, recognises it in step with redemptions, but in some states unused balances count as unclaimed property and must be handed to the state instead.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, recognising revenue when cash arrives rather than when control transfers. Second, allocating a bundle's discount entirely to one component instead of by relative standalone selling prices. Third, recording a card sale at the net amount deposited: the fee is an expense, and Sales is the full price. Fourth, forgetting the cost of goods sold entry that goes with a sale of goods. Fifth, treating a deposit, a gift card or a subscription paid in advance as revenue on the day the cash arrives.

Key takeaways

Revenue is recognised when, or as, control of promised goods or services passes to the customer, at the amount the seller expects to be entitled to. ASC 606 and IFRS 15 use five steps: identify the contract, identify the performance obligations, determine the transaction price, allocate it by standalone selling prices, and recognise revenue as each obligation is satisfied, at a point in time or over time. Matching puts the cost of goods sold in the same period as the sale. Cash received in advance is unearned revenue, a liability, until the seller performs.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Revenue recognition principle

Recognise revenue when, or as, control of promised goods or services passes to the customer

At the amount the seller expects to be entitled to.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Under ASC 606, which step comes immediately after determining the transaction price?

Question 2 of 5

A bundle sells for $900. Sold separately, item A would be $600 and item B $400. How much of the price is allocated to item A?

Question 3 of 5

A customer pays $1,000 by card and the processor deposits $975 the same day after a 2.5% fee. What amount is credited to Sales?

Question 4 of 5

A shop sells a $50 gift card in November, and the holder redeems it for goods in January. When is the $50 of revenue recognised?

Question 5 of 5

Which of these is a performance obligation satisfied over time?

← Previous topicNext topic →