Accounting › Section S · Activity-based, variable, and absorption costing › Topic S.1
Traditional overhead allocation and cost drivers
Materials and labour can be traced to each product, but factory rent, supervision and machine maintenance cannot. Traditional costing spreads that overhead with one volume-based rate, and its accuracy depends on how well the chosen base reflects what really drives the cost.
The overhead problem
A product's manufacturing cost has three parts, as Product cost components and their flow explains: direct materials, direct labour and manufacturing overhead. The first two can be traced to each unit from requisitions and time records. Overhead cannot, because it is shared: one supervisor oversees every product line and one building houses them all. Yet managers need a full unit cost to set prices, judge which products pay their way and value inventory. So overhead must be allocated, assigned to products by some reasonable rule. How that rule is chosen is the subject of this topic.
What counts as manufacturing overhead
Manufacturing overhead is every factory cost other than direct materials and direct labour. It includes indirect materials (glue, lubricants, cleaning supplies), indirect labour (supervisors, maintenance staff, quality inspectors, material handlers), and factory depreciation, rent, insurance, utilities and machine repairs. Selling and administrative costs, such as advertising, sales salaries and head-office rent, are not manufacturing overhead: they are period costs and are not assigned to inventory under GAAP. Some overhead is variable, like machine power, and some is fixed, like factory insurance.
One plantwide rate
The traditional method uses a single predetermined overhead rate for the whole factory, set before the year begins, as in Predetermined overhead rates:
The allocation base is a measure of volume, usually direct labour hours, direct labour cost or machine hours. During the year, each product receives the rate times the base it actually uses. Because the rate rests on estimates, applied overhead rarely equals actual overhead; the difference is handled as in Costing a job and fixing misapplied overhead.
Worked example: Halvorsen Audio's plantwide rate
Halvorsen Audio plans to make 40,000 Cove bookshelf speakers and 5,000 Summit studio monitors. A Cove needs $30 of materials and 1 direct labour hour; a Summit needs $95 of materials and 2 hours. Labour costs $24 an hour, and estimated overhead is $1,500,000. 1. Total hours: \(40{,}000 \times 1 + 5{,}000 \times 2 = 50{,}000\). 2. Rate: \(1{,}500{,}000 \div 50{,}000 = 30\) dollars per labour hour. 3. Overhead per unit: Cove $30, Summit $60. 4. Unit cost: Cove \(30 + 24 + 30 = 84\); Summit \(95 + 48 + 60 = 203\). 5. At prices of $110 and $260, gross margins are $26 and $57 a unit.
Cost drivers
A cost driver is an activity or factor whose changes cause a cost to change. Machine hours drive power and machine wear; the number of setups drives setup labour; the number of purchase orders drives purchasing costs; square feet drive cleaning and building costs; inspection hours drive quality-control wages. An allocation base works well only when it is a genuine driver of the overhead it allocates, so that products using more of the base really do cause more of the cost. When the base and the cost are unrelated, the allocation is arithmetic, not measurement.
Choosing the base
Direct labour hours made sense when factories were labour-intensive and overhead was a small share of cost: more labour meant more supervision, more space and more wear. In automated plants, labour may be a small fraction of cost while overhead, much of it depreciation and maintenance on robots and software, has grown large. There, machine hours usually track overhead better. A related warning sign is a very high rate per labour hour: a few dollars of labour then carries many dollars of overhead, and small errors in labour hours produce large errors in product cost.
Departmental rates
A middle path between one plantwide rate and a full activity analysis is a separate rate for each production department, each with its own base. A labour-intensive assembly department might use labour hours while a machining department uses machine hours. Products then pick up overhead in proportion to their use of each department. Departmental rates are more accurate when products use departments in different proportions, but they still assume that overhead within each department moves with volume, which is not true of costs such as setups or engineering changes.
Worked example: Halvorsen's two departments
Halvorsen splits its $1,500,000 into Assembly, $700,000 on 50,000 labour hours, and Machining, $800,000 on 40,000 machine hours. A Cove uses 1 labour hour and 0.75 machine hours; a Summit uses 2 of each. 1. Assembly rate: \(700{,}000 \div 50{,}000 = 14\) dollars per labour hour. 2. Machining rate: \(800{,}000 \div 40{,}000 = 20\) dollars per machine hour. 3. Cove: \(14 + 0.75 \times 20 = 29\). 4. Summit: \(2 \times 14 + 2 \times 20 = 68\). 5. Check: 40,000 Coves at $29 plus 5,000 Summits at $68 is $1,500,000. The Summit's share rises from $60 to $68.
Value-added and non-value-added costs
Studying drivers also shows which activities add value. A value-added activity is one a customer would willingly pay for, such as machining a speaker cabinet or applying a finish. A non-value-added activity consumes resources without improving the product: moving parts between buildings, storing excess stock, or reworking defects. The rework may be necessary today, but the goal is to shrink it. Knowing what drives such costs is the first step to cutting them, which is why cost-driver analysis matters even before a firm changes its costing system.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, including selling or administrative costs in manufacturing overhead. Second, computing the rate with actual figures at year-end instead of estimates at the start. Third, dividing by the wrong base, such as total units, when the rate is per labour hour. Fourth, forgetting to convert the rate into overhead per unit by multiplying by each product's hours per unit. Fifth, keeping labour hours as the base after automation has made them a poor driver. Sixth, assuming that because totals reconcile, each product's share must be right.
Key takeaways
Manufacturing overhead is all factory cost other than direct materials and direct labour, and it must be allocated. Traditional costing uses one predetermined rate, estimated overhead divided by an estimated volume base such as labour or machine hours, and assigns overhead by each product's use of that base. A cost driver is a factor that causes a cost to change; allocation is accurate only when the base is a real driver. Departmental rates improve accuracy when departments use different bases. Driver analysis also exposes non-value-added activities.
Flashcards
Flashcard
All factory costs except direct materials and direct labour
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A factory estimates overhead of $840,000 and 35,000 direct labour hours. A product needs 1.5 labour hours per unit. How much overhead is allocated to each unit?
Question 2 of 5
Which of these costs is part of manufacturing overhead?
Question 3 of 5
A unit uses $40 of materials and 3 labour hours at $20 per hour. Overhead is applied at $15 per labour hour. What is its full unit cost?
Question 4 of 5
A plant has replaced most of its assembly workers with robots. Which allocation base is most likely to track its overhead?
Question 5 of 5
What makes an allocation base a good cost driver?
