Accounting › Section H · Accounting for receivables › Topic H.2
Uncollectible accounts and the allowance method
Every business that sells on credit will meet customers who never pay. The allowance method estimates those losses in advance, so that receivables are shown at the cash the company really expects and bad debts land in the same period as the sales that caused them.
The cost of selling on credit
Selling on account wins customers who would not pay cash up front, but some of them will fall behind, go out of business or simply disappear. An account that will never be collected is an uncollectible account, or bad debt, and the loss is a normal cost of a credit policy. Two questions follow. When should the loss reach the income statement? And how should receivables appear on the balance sheet when the company knows some of them are worthless but does not yet know which ones? The two methods in this topic give different answers, and only one of them satisfies US GAAP for material amounts.
The direct write-off method
Under the direct write-off method, nothing is recorded until a specific account is judged worthless. Then the company debits Bad Debt Expense and credits Accounts Receivable for that customer's balance. It is simple, and US income tax rules generally work this way, but it breaks the matching principle: a sale made in December 2026 may be written off in mid-2027, so 2026 shows the revenue and 2027 shows the loss. It also leaves receivables overstated in the meantime. GAAP therefore allows it only when bad debts are immaterial, which is realistic for a small business with few credit customers.
The allowance method
The allowance method estimates bad debts at the end of each period, before the bad accounts are known. The estimate is recorded with a debit to Bad Debt Expense and a credit to Allowance for Doubtful Accounts, shortened to Allowance in the entries below. The allowance is a contra-asset: it sits beneath Accounts Receivable and reduces it to net realisable value, the amount the company expects to collect. Under the current expected credit loss standard, ASC 326, the estimate must reflect losses expected over the receivables' lives, using past experience, current conditions and reasonable forecasts. The two classic ways to make it are percentage of sales and percentage of receivables.
Percentage of sales: the income statement approach
The percentage-of-sales method asks how much of this period's credit sales will go bad, based on history. It computes the expense directly, as credit sales times a loss rate:
Whatever is already in the allowance is ignored when computing the entry; the expense is simply added to it. This method matches expense to revenue closely, because both come from the same period's sales. Its weakness is that the allowance balance can drift away from what is actually uncollectible if the rate is out of date, so companies using it should compare the resulting balance with their receivables from time to time.
Worked example: percentage of sales
Copperline Supply made credit sales of $640,000 in 2026 and expects 1.5% of credit sales to prove uncollectible. Before adjusting, Accounts Receivable is $150,000 and the allowance has a credit balance of $1,200. 1. Expense: \(640{,}000 \times 0.015 = 9{,}600\). 2. Record it, ignoring the existing balance:
3. The allowance ends at $1,200 + $9,600 = $10,800 credit. 4. Net realisable value: $150,000 − $10,800 = $139,200. Check: the expense on the income statement is exactly 1.5% of credit sales.
Percentage of receivables and the aging schedule
The balance sheet approach works backwards. It first estimates how much of the year-end receivables will not be collected; that figure is the required ending balance of the allowance, and the adjusting entry is whatever moves the allowance there. A single rate can be applied to total receivables, but most companies prepare an aging schedule, which sorts each customer's balance by how long it has been outstanding and applies a higher loss rate to older groups, since the longer a bill goes unpaid, the less likely it is to be paid. Because the entry depends on the existing balance, a credit balance reduces the expense and a debit balance increases it.
Worked example: an aging schedule
Copperline instead ages its $150,000 of receivables: current $96,000 at 2%, 1 to 30 days past due $30,000 at 5%, 31 to 90 days $18,000 at 15%, and over 90 days $6,000 at 40%. 1. Estimates: $1,920 + $1,500 + $2,700 + $2,400 = $8,520, the required allowance. 2. The allowance already holds $1,200 credit, so the entry is $8,520 − $1,200 = $7,320: debit Bad Debt Expense, credit Allowance. 3. Net realisable value: $150,000 − $8,520 = $141,480. 4. Had the allowance started with a $900 debit balance, from write-offs exceeding last year's estimate, the entry would be $8,520 + $900 = $9,420. Check: the four groups add to $150,000.
Writing off and recovering an account
When a specific customer is finally judged uncollectible, the allowance absorbs the loss. Suppose Copperline writes off a $2,300 balance (the entry shortens Accounts Receivable to Accts Receivable):
No expense is recorded, because it was recognised when estimated. Net realisable value is unchanged: $147,700 − $6,220 = $141,480, as before. If the customer later pays after all, reverse the write-off (debit Accounts Receivable, credit Allowance), then record the collection as usual (debit Cash, credit Accounts Receivable). Reinstating first keeps a record of the customer's payment history.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, subtracting the existing allowance balance under percentage of sales: that method computes the expense directly. Second, forgetting the existing balance under the aging method, where the computed figure is the target balance, not the entry. Third, treating a debit balance in the allowance like a credit balance; a debit balance must be added. Fourth, debiting Bad Debt Expense when writing off an account under the allowance method, which counts the loss twice. Fifth, thinking a write-off changes net receivables; it reduces Accounts Receivable and the allowance by the same amount.
Key takeaways
The direct write-off method expenses a bad debt only when an account is written off; it breaks matching and is acceptable under GAAP only for immaterial amounts. The allowance method estimates bad debts each period with a debit to Bad Debt Expense and a credit to the contra-asset Allowance for Doubtful Accounts, so receivables appear at net realisable value. Percentage of sales computes the expense; percentage of receivables, usually through an aging schedule, computes the required allowance balance. Write-offs debit the allowance, not the expense, and leave net receivables unchanged.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A receivable that will never be collected; a bad debt
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Credit sales are $500,000 and the company estimates bad debts at 2% of credit sales. The allowance has a $1,500 credit balance before adjusting. What is bad debt expense?
Question 2 of 5
An aging schedule says the allowance should be $12,000. Before adjusting, the allowance has a $700 debit balance. What is the adjusting entry?
Question 3 of 5
Under the allowance method, a $4,000 account is written off. What happens to net realisable value of receivables?
Question 4 of 5
When is the direct write-off method acceptable under US GAAP?
Question 5 of 5
Which approach first estimates the required ending balance of the allowance, then records whatever entry reaches it?
