Accounting › Section T · Budgeting › Topic T.1
How and why managers budget
A budget turns a company's strategy into numbers for the months ahead: what it expects to sell, spend, borrow and earn. Knowing why budgets exist, and how the way they are built shapes behaviour, is the starting point for every budget schedule in this section.
From strategy to a plan in numbers
A budget is a quantitative plan for a set period: the revenue an organisation expects, the resources it will need, when cash will come and go, and the profit that should result. Budgeting begins with strategy. Senior management sets long-term goals, often after a SWOT analysis of the organisation's strengths and weaknesses and the opportunities and threats outside it. Strategies chosen to reach those goals become plans covering several years, and the first year becomes the detailed annual budget. That year is usually split into quarters or months, with more detail the closer a period is: next month is planned line by line, year three in broad totals.
Four jobs a budget does
1. Planning: building a budget forces managers to state their assumptions and think ahead about bottlenecks, staffing and cash. 2. Coordination: sales, production, purchasing and finance must agree on one set of numbers, so production plans match expected sales and purchases match production. 3. Communication: the budget tells every manager what the organisation expects of them and what resources they have. 4. Control and evaluation: once the period starts, actual results are compared with the budget, so differences show up early and managers can be judged against an agreed benchmark. The planning, controlling and evaluating duties described in "Managerial versus financial accounting" all lean on the budget.
The master budget
The full set of budgets for a period is the master budget. It has two parts. The operating budgets plan revenue and expenses: the sales budget comes first, because expected sales drive everything else, followed by the production, direct materials, direct labour, manufacturing overhead and selling and administrative budgets, which together produce a budgeted income statement. The financial budgets plan assets, liabilities and cash: the capital expenditures budget, the cash budget and the budgeted balance sheet. "Operating budgets" and "Financial budgets and the cash budget" build one company's master budget schedule by schedule.
Top-down, bottom-up, or both
In a top-down budget, senior management sets the figures and passes them down. It ties neatly to strategy, but the people setting the numbers may not understand each department's work, and targets can feel imposed. In a bottom-up, or participative, budget, the managers who will run each area prepare their own figures, which are then reviewed and combined higher up. Their knowledge makes the numbers more realistic and builds commitment, but they may misread the strategy or pad their requests. Many organisations combine the two: senior management sets targets and guidelines, and managers build detailed budgets within them.
Budgetary slack
Budgetary slack is the deliberate understatement of expected revenue or overstatement of expected costs, so that the budget is easier to beat. It is most tempting when bonuses depend on beating the budget and the manager supplies the estimates. Slack makes performance look better than it was, ties up resources other departments could use, and weakens the budget as a planning tool, because the totals no longer show what management really expects. The opposite error also costs: a budget so tight that it cannot be met discourages effort. Reviewing estimates against past results and rewarding accurate forecasts, not only beaten targets, both reduce it.
Worked example: slack and a bonus
Pellbrook Robotics pays its service manager a bonus of 10% of any amount by which actual department costs come in under budget. The manager expects costs of about $200,000 next year. 1. An honest budget is $200,000. If actual costs are $201,000, there is no saving and no bonus. 2. Suppose the manager pads the estimate by 8%: \(200{,}000 \times 1.08 = 216{,}000\). 3. The same actual costs now show a "saving" of \(216{,}000 - 201{,}000 = 15{,}000\), and a bonus of $1,500. 4. Nothing about performance changed. The bonus came from the estimate, and $16,000 of resources was set aside that the company did not need.
Incremental and zero-based budgeting
Incremental budgeting starts from last period's budget or actual figures and adjusts them for expected changes. It is quick, but old spending tends to survive whether or not it is still needed. Zero-based budgeting starts every line at zero, and each amount must be justified by the activity it pays for. It removes spending that no one can defend, but justifying everything takes a great deal of time, so many organisations use it only for selected costs, such as travel or consulting, or rotate it across departments over several years.
Worked example: a travel budget two ways
Pellbrook's sales team spent $48,000 on travel last year. 1. Incremental: management allows a 5% rise, so the budget is \(48{,}000 \times 1.05 = 50{,}400\). 2. Zero-based: the team must list each planned trip. Four trade fairs at $4,500 each cost $18,000; thirty customer installation visits at $700 each cost $21,000; three training trips at $1,500 each cost $4,500. 3. The justified total is \(18{,}000 + 21{,}000 + 4{,}500 = 43{,}500\). 4. The zero-based budget is $6,900 lower than the incremental one, which suggests some past spending no longer supports the team's goals.
Static, flexible, and rolling budgets
A static budget is prepared for one planned level of activity, and the master budget is static. A flexible budget restates revenue and costs for other activity levels, including the level actually reached, which makes comparisons with actual results fairer; "Flexible budgets" develops it. A rolling, or continuous, budget always covers the same length of time ahead: as each month or quarter ends, it is dropped and a new one is added at the far end, and the remaining months are revised. Rolling budgets keep plans current in a fast-changing business, at the cost of constant management time.
Worked example: rolling forward
Pellbrook keeps a 12-month rolling budget. In December 2026 it covers January to December 2027. 1. At the end of January 2027, January is complete, so it leaves the budget and becomes a month of actual results. 2. A new month, January 2028, is added at the end. 3. The budget now covers February 2027 to January 2028, still 12 months. 4. Managers also revise February to December 2027 for anything learned in January, such as a new customer or a supplier's price rise.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating the budget as a prediction that must come true; it is a plan and a benchmark, and differences are information. Second, starting with production or costs instead of sales, which drive the other operating budgets. Third, assuming participation always produces better numbers: it also invites slack. Fourth, confusing a rolling budget, which adds a new period as each one ends, with a flexible budget, which adjusts for activity level. Fifth, pressing managers to hit the budget at any cost, which tempts them to misreport results or shift revenue and expenses between periods; the ethical standards in "Managerial accountants: roles, skills, and ethics" require honest reporting.
Key takeaways
A budget is a quantitative plan that turns strategy into numbers for a period. Budgets support planning, coordination, communication, and control and evaluation. The master budget combines operating budgets, starting with the sales budget and ending in a budgeted income statement, with financial budgets: capital expenditures, cash and the budgeted balance sheet. Budgets are built top-down, bottom-up or both; participation brings realism and commitment but risks slack. Zero-based budgeting justifies every amount from zero; incremental budgeting adjusts last period's figures. Static budgets cover one activity level, flexible budgets several, and rolling budgets are extended period by period.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A quantitative plan for revenue, resources, cash and profit over a set period
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why is the sales budget prepared before the other operating budgets?
Question 2 of 5
A manager expects costs of $150,000 but submits a budget of $165,000 so that the target will be easy to beat. What is this called?
Question 3 of 5
Office supplies cost $20,000 last year. Under incremental budgeting with a 4% allowance, what is this year's budget?
Question 4 of 5
A company keeps a 4-quarter rolling budget covering Q1 to Q4 of 2027. What does it cover once Q1 2027 has ended?
Question 5 of 5
Which statement about participative (bottom-up) budgeting is accurate?
