Accounting › Section S · Activity-based, variable, and absorption costing › Topic S.4
Variable versus absorption costing
Should fixed factory overhead be part of what a product costs, or a cost of the period? Absorption costing says the first and is required for external reports; variable costing says the second and is often preferred by managers. When inventory changes, the two report different profits.
Two ways to cost a unit
Absorption costing, also called full costing, treats every manufacturing cost as a product cost: direct materials, direct labour, variable overhead and fixed overhead. Variable costing, also called direct or marginal costing, treats only the variable manufacturing costs as product costs and expenses fixed manufacturing overhead in full in the period it is incurred. The only cost the two methods handle differently is fixed manufacturing overhead. Selling and administrative costs, fixed or variable, are period costs under both methods and never enter inventory.
Worked example: Glenridge's unit costs and first year
Glenridge Lamp Works sells desk lamps for $60. Variable manufacturing cost is $26 a lamp ($14 materials, $8 labour, $4 overhead); variable selling cost is $3 per lamp sold. Fixed overhead is $90,000 a year and fixed selling and administrative cost $40,000. In year 1 it makes 6,000 lamps, its normal output, and sells 5,000. 1. Variable costing unit cost: $26. 2. Fixed overhead per lamp: \(90{,}000 \div 6{,}000 = 15\). 3. Absorption unit cost: \(26 + 15 = 41\). 4. Ending inventory of 1,000 lamps: $41,000 under absorption, $26,000 under variable costing. The $15,000 gap is fixed overhead parked in inventory.
Two income statement formats
Year 1 under absorption costing uses the gross profit format:
Cost of goods sold is \(5{,}000 \times 41\); selling and administrative cost is \(5{,}000 \times 3\) plus 40,000. Under variable costing, the contribution format subtracts variable cost of goods sold (130,000) and variable selling (15,000) to give a contribution margin of 155,000, then all fixed costs: 90,000 of overhead and 40,000 of selling and administrative cost. Operating income is $25,000.
The reconciliation rule
Absorption income was $15,000 higher because 1,000 lamps, each carrying $15 of fixed overhead, went into inventory instead of being expensed. In general:
where \(\Delta\)OI is absorption income minus variable income and FOH is fixed manufacturing overhead. When fixed overhead per unit differs between periods, compare the fixed overhead in ending inventory with that in beginning inventory instead. Three cases follow: production equals sales, incomes are equal; production exceeds sales, absorption income is higher; sales exceed production, variable income is higher.
Worked example: Glenridge's second year
In year 2 Glenridge again makes 6,000 lamps but sells 7,000, using up last year's 1,000 (costs are unchanged). 1. Sales: \(7{,}000 \times 60 = 420{,}000\). 2. Absorption: cost of goods sold \(7{,}000 \times 41 = 287{,}000\), gross profit 133,000, less selling and administrative \(21{,}000 + 40{,}000\), operating income $72,000. 3. Variable: contribution margin \(7{,}000 \times (60 - 26 - 3) = 217{,}000\), less fixed costs 130,000, operating income $87,000. 4. Reconcile: inventory fell by 1,000 lamps, so absorption income is \(1{,}000 \times 15 = 15{,}000\) lower. 5. Over two years each method totals $112,000: the difference is timing only.
Effects on the balance sheet
The choice also changes the balance sheet. At the end of Glenridge's first year, inventory is $41,000 under absorption costing and $26,000 under variable costing, so total assets, current assets and equity are all higher under absorption. Ratios built on those figures, such as the current ratio or inventory turnover, differ too. When the inventory is sold, the extra $15,000 flows into cost of goods sold. If it can never be sold and must be written down, the deferred fixed overhead becomes an expense then, often at a less convenient moment.
Producing for inventory
Under absorption costing, making more units than are sold spreads fixed overhead thinner and parks more of it on the balance sheet. Suppose Glenridge had made 8,000 lamps in year 1 and still sold 5,000. Fixed overhead per lamp falls to $11.25, cost of goods sold to \(5{,}000 \times 37.25 = 186{,}250\), and absorption income rises from $40,000 to $58,750 with no extra sales. Variable costing income stays at $25,000. A manager paid on absorption profit can therefore raise reported profit by overproducing, at the cost of storage, obsolescence and a later reversal when the inventory is sold or written down.
Why managers like variable costing
Variable costing income moves with sales, not production, so it is easier to understand and harder to inflate by building inventory. Its contribution format feeds straight into cost-volume-profit analysis, as in The break-even point, and into flexible budgets and short-term decisions, because fixed and variable costs are already separated. It also shows total fixed costs as one visible figure each period, rather than burying part of them in inventory. For these reasons many companies prepare variable costing reports for internal use alongside their external statements.
Why absorption costing is required
US GAAP (ASC 330) requires absorption costing for inventory in external financial statements, and IFRS (IAS 2) does the same. The argument is that fixed production overhead is a necessary cost of making the goods, so it should be expensed as cost of goods sold when the goods are sold, matching it with the related revenue. US tax rules generally require it as well. Both frameworks base fixed overhead per unit on normal capacity, so abnormally low production does not load extra cost into each unit; the unabsorbed amount is expensed in that period. In a period of abnormally high output the rate per unit is lowered, so inventory is not carried above cost. A company using variable costing internally must convert to absorption costing for its published statements.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, putting variable selling costs into product cost: they are period costs under both methods. Second, leaving variable overhead out of variable costing; only fixed overhead is excluded. Third, reconciling with the total fixed overhead instead of the change in inventory units times fixed overhead per unit. Fourth, getting the direction backwards: when inventory rises, absorption income is higher. Fifth, thinking variable costing is acceptable for external reports. Sixth, reading a rise in absorption income as better performance without checking whether inventory grew.
Key takeaways
Absorption costing includes fixed manufacturing overhead in product cost; variable costing expenses it in the period incurred. Selling and administrative costs are period costs under both. Absorption income minus variable income equals the change in inventory units times fixed overhead per unit: equal when production equals sales, higher under absorption when inventory grows, lower when it shrinks. Over time the difference is one of timing. Absorption costing is required for external reporting under US GAAP and IFRS; variable costing supports CVP analysis and resists profit inflation by overproduction.
Flashcards
Flashcard
All manufacturing costs are product costs
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Direct materials are $9, direct labour $6 and variable overhead $3 per unit. Fixed overhead is $80,000 and 10,000 units are made. What is the absorption cost per unit?
Question 2 of 5
Under variable costing, how is fixed manufacturing overhead treated?
Question 3 of 5
A firm makes 12,000 units and sells 10,000. Fixed overhead is $8 per unit. How does absorption income compare with variable costing income?
Question 4 of 5
In a year when sales exceed production, which statement is true?
Question 5 of 5
Which cost is a product cost under absorption costing but a period cost under variable costing?
