American Government › Section Q · Foreign policy › Topic Q.4
Approaches to foreign policy
Should the United States stay out of other countries' quarrels, lead alliances, or use its power to spread its values? Competing schools of thought give different answers, and recognising them makes sense of debates that run from Washington's day to today.
Why schools of thought matter
Every foreign-policy choice rests on assumptions. Can other states be trusted? Should the United States act with allies and international bodies, which is multilateralism, or alone, which is unilateralism? When is force justified? Schools of thought are bundles of answers to such questions, and they help explain why leaders facing the same facts reach different conclusions. Few presidents follow one school consistently. Most mix approaches as circumstances change, and scholars often disagree about how to classify a given administration. The schools are best used as lenses for analysing a decision, not as labels that settle an argument.
Isolationism
Isolationism holds that a country should stay out of foreign alliances and wars and concentrate on affairs at home. In his Farewell Address of 1796, George Washington advised that "'Tis our true policy to steer clear of permanent alliances with any portion of the foreign world"; the warning against entangling alliances came from Thomas Jefferson's first inaugural address in 1801. The Monroe Doctrine of 1823 told European powers not to colonise the Americas further. After the First World War, the Senate rejected the League of Nations, and Neutrality Acts in the 1930s tried to keep the country out of another war. Historians note that the young republic still traded widely and expanded across the continent.
Realism and idealism
Realists see world politics as a competition for power among states, with no higher authority to keep order. They expect states to act in their own interest, distrust promises without enforcement, and value military strength and a balance of power. Hans Morgenthau's Politics Among Nations (1948) is a classic statement. Idealists, often called liberals in international relations, believe states can cooperate through law, trade, democracy and international institutions. President Woodrow Wilson's Fourteen Points of 1918, which proposed open diplomacy, freer trade and a league of nations, are the classic American example. Most American policy blends the two outlooks in some proportion.
Liberal internationalism and containment
Liberal internationalism calls for the United States to engage actively in world affairs, working with other democracies through alliances and institutions. After 1945 the United States helped build such an order: the International Monetary Fund and World Bank, agreed at Bretton Woods in 1944, the United Nations in 1945 and NATO in 1949. That order served containment, the Cold War strategy of limiting the spread of Soviet power and communism, set out by the diplomat George Kennan in 1946 and 1947. Nuclear deterrence, the threat of a devastating response, underpinned it, since both superpowers faced mutually assured destruction in any full-scale war.
Hard power, soft power and grand strategy
Hard power is the ability to make others act through coercion: military force or economic pressure such as sanctions and payments. Soft power, a term introduced by the political scientist Joseph Nye around 1990, is the ability to attract others through a country's culture, political values and policies seen as legitimate. Nye later argued that the most effective policy, which he called smart power, combines the two. A grand strategy links all of a country's diplomatic, economic and military resources to its long-term interests. After the Second World War, American bases in Germany, Japan and South Korea, among many places, became part of such a strategy.
Worked example: two lenses on the Marshall Plan
From 1948 the Marshall Plan gave Western Europe about $13 billion to rebuild after the war. 1. Realist reading: a weak, hungry Europe might turn to communism, so aid strengthened allies and contained Soviet influence. 2. Liberal reading: prosperous democracies trading with one another would be more peaceful and would buy American goods. 3. Hard or soft power? Mostly soft: the plan attracted support rather than coercing it, though it came with conditions. 4. Effects: European output recovered strongly, and most recipients also joined NATO. 5. Conclusion: one policy can serve both realist and liberal aims, which helps explain its broad support in Congress.
Neoconservatism
Neoconservatism grew partly out of reactions to the Vietnam War and the détente of the 1970s. Neoconservatives argue that the United States should use its power assertively, including military force, to defend and spread democracy and American values, and should be willing to act alone when allies or the United Nations will not. Preemption, striking an enemy before it can attack, is associated with this view. The 2002 National Security Strategy, often called the Bush Doctrine, embraced preemption, and the 2003 invasion of Iraq is widely cited as its leading example. Supporters see moral clarity and strength; critics point to the costs of the Iraq War and to the limits of building democracy by force.
Restraint and selective engagement
Neo-isolationism, close to what many scholars call restraint, accepts trade and diplomacy but seeks to cut military commitments abroad, spend less on defence and keep distance from international bodies seen as limiting American freedom of action. Advocates of non-intervention include Ron Paul and his son Rand Paul, who both sought the presidency. Selective engagement takes a middle path: keep strong forces and key alliances, but intervene only where vital interests are at stake and avoid acting as the world's police officer. Many scholars describe recent presidents as hybrids. Supporters describe the "America First" approach as putting national interests first, while scholars debate whether it is closer to realism, restraint or a new nationalism.
Russia and China
After the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, the United States encouraged democracy and market reform in its former republics and Eastern Europe, and many of those states later joined NATO and the European Union. Relations with Russia worsened, especially after Russia annexed Crimea in 2014 and launched a full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, to which the United States and its allies responded with sanctions and aid to Ukraine. China opened to the United States after President Nixon's 1972 visit, and the two established diplomatic relations in 1979. Since about 2018, administrations of both parties have treated China as a strategic competitor, using tariffs and limits on technology exports.
Worked example: naming the approach
Classify three imaginary proposals. 1. A president wants to bring most troops home from Europe and leave several UN agencies, while keeping trade open. Fewer commitments and distance from institutions point to restraint or neo-isolationism. 2. Another builds a broad coalition through the UN Security Council to enforce sanctions on an aggressor. Multilateral action through institutions points to liberal internationalism. 3. A third orders a strike on a hostile regime before it can attack, aiming to install a democracy, despite allies' objections. Preemption, unilateral action and spreading democracy point to neoconservatism. 4. Check: identify the assumptions about allies, institutions and force before choosing a label.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, crediting Washington with the phrase "entangling alliances"; it is Jefferson's, while Washington warned against permanent alliances. Second, treating sanctions as soft power; in Nye's terms, economic coercion is hard power, and soft power works by attraction. Third, confusing neoconservatism with isolationism; neoconservatives favour assertive engagement abroad. Fourth, assuming realists always favour war; many realists opposed the 2003 Iraq War as against American interests. Fifth, expecting a president to fit one school neatly.
Key takeaways
Isolationism, rooted in Washington's 1796 warning and Jefferson's 1801 phrase, favours staying out of alliances and wars. Realists stress power and national interest; idealists stress cooperation, law and institutions. Liberal internationalism built the post-1945 order and supported containment of Soviet power, backed by nuclear deterrence. Hard power coerces and soft power, Nye's term, attracts. Neoconservatism favours assertive, sometimes unilateral and preemptive action to spread democracy, as in Iraq in 2003. Restraint seeks fewer commitments; selective engagement keeps alliances but intervenes only for vital interests. Russia and China are now treated as major rivals.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Acting with allies and institutions ⁄ acting alone
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Who first used the phrase "entangling alliances with none"?
Question 2 of 5
In Joseph Nye's terms, which is an example of soft power?
Question 3 of 5
A president launches a strike on a hostile regime before it attacks, aiming to replace it with a democracy, though key allies object. Which school does this fit best?
Question 4 of 5
What was the goal of containment during the Cold War?
Question 5 of 5
A realist and a liberal both supported the Marshall Plan. How would their reasons differ?
