American Government › Section Q · Foreign policy › Topic Q.3
Institutional relations in foreign policy
The Constitution splits foreign-policy powers between the president and Congress, yet presidents usually lead. Seeing how the branches share power, why presidents gained the upper hand, and which officials actually run policy explains much of how the United States acts abroad.
An invitation to struggle
The Constitution gives each branch real foreign-policy powers and leaves the boundary between them vague. The constitutional scholar Edward Corwin famously described it as an "invitation to struggle" for control of American foreign policy. The president is commander in chief, negotiates treaties, nominates ambassadors and receives foreign ambassadors, which the Supreme Court in Zivotofsky v. Kerry (2015) read as an exclusive power to recognise foreign governments. Congress declares war, raises and funds the armed forces, regulates foreign commerce and makes the laws agencies follow, while the Senate consents to treaties and confirms officials. Almost every major action therefore needs both branches at some point.
Shared power in practice
Most foreign-policy outputs require some congressional role. Laws and agency budgets need majorities in both chambers; treaties need two-thirds of senators present; congressional-executive agreements need majorities in both chambers; and appointments need Senate confirmation. Even a sole executive agreement often needs money that only Congress can provide. Presidents who ignore Congress risk retaliation on other issues. In the 1950s, angered by agreements made without the Senate, Senator John Bricker led a push for a constitutional amendment to limit treaties and executive agreements; it narrowly failed in 1954.
The two presidencies thesis
In 1966 the political scientist Aaron Wildavsky argued that the United States has two presidencies: one for domestic affairs, where the president struggles to get his way, and one for foreign affairs, where he usually prevails. His reasons were partly formal. The Constitution makes the president commander in chief, chief negotiator and the nation's voice abroad, and presidents act faster and with more secret information than Congress. They were also partly informal. During the Cold War many legislators believed the country should speak with one voice, an idea summed up in the saying that politics stops at the water's edge, often associated with Senator Arthur Vandenberg in the late 1940s.
Has the thesis lasted?
Later studies give a mixed answer. Presidents still win a larger share of congressional votes on foreign policy than on domestic policy, on average, but the gap has narrowed since the Cold War. Two changes explain much of this. First, the end of the Cold War around 1989 to 1991 removed a single overriding threat that had encouraged members to rally behind the president. Second, the parties in Congress became more polarised from the 1980s onwards, so the opposition party now challenges presidents on foreign policy far more openly, as Democrats did over the Iraq War under George W. Bush and Republicans did over the 2015 Iran nuclear deal under Barack Obama.
Worked example: testing the two presidencies
A researcher studies one president's record on roll-call votes where the White House took a clear position. 1. Data: the president won 78 of 100 foreign-policy votes and 58 of 100 domestic votes. 2. Win rates: 78 percent against 58 percent. 3. Gap: 78 - 58 = 20 percentage points, so the foreign-policy presidency is stronger, as Wildavsky predicted. 4. Look deeper: on the foreign votes he won, check how many opposition members voted no; if the share is rising, partisanship is reaching foreign policy. 5. Conclusion: a positive gap supports the thesis, but comparing it with earlier presidents shows whether it is shrinking.
Why most legislators stay at home
Individual members of Congress spend relatively little time on foreign policy, unless a crisis or a war arises. The reason is electoral: voters care more about jobs, prices, health care and crime than about relations with distant countries, and in polls asking for the nation's most important problem, few name a foreign-policy issue other than immigration. Leaders speak for their parties on every issue, and some members seek seats on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, the House Foreign Affairs Committee, the two Armed Services committees or the intelligence committees, perhaps because their district hosts a military base, because of personal interest, or because they hope for a future executive post.
The White House team
The National Security Council, created in 1947, brings together the president, vice president and the secretaries of state and defense, among others, to coordinate policy; the national security adviser runs its staff and is often the president's closest foreign-policy aide. The highest-ranking officer, the Joint Chiefs chair, advises the president on military matters but commands no troops; the Joint Chiefs include the heads of the Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps, Space Force and National Guard Bureau. The director of national intelligence, a post created in 2004, oversees the whole intelligence community, including the CIA. The US trade representative leads trade negotiations, and the Office of Management and Budget prepares the foreign-affairs budget.
The departments
America's chief diplomat, the secretary of state, runs the State Department and the Foreign Service and stands fourth in the line of presidential succession. The secretary of defense is a civilian who heads the Department of Defense, keeping the military under civilian control; a September 2025 executive order authorised "Department of War" as a secondary title, while a permanent change of name requires an act of Congress. The Department of Homeland Security protects borders and infrastructure, and the Treasury enforces economic sanctions. Foreign aid was long run by the US Agency for International Development, created in 1961; in 2025 the administration moved its remaining programmes into the State Department, a step contested in Congress and the courts.
Worked example: who acts in a crisis?
Suppose a foreign government seizes an American cargo ship and its crew. 1. The president convenes the National Security Council to weigh options. 2. The secretary of state calls allies and the other government, seeking release through diplomacy. 3. The Treasury prepares sanctions on the officials responsible. 4. The defense secretary and the Joint Chiefs chair prepare military options, with intelligence agencies tracking the crew. 5. Congressional leaders and committee heads are briefed, and Congress may pass emergency funding. 6. Conclusion: the president decides, but carrying out each option depends on departments, and any lasting response depends on Congress.
Voices beyond government
Official institutions are not the only actors. Interest groups, from business associations seeking open markets to unions seeking protection from imports and human rights advocates, lobby both branches. Think tanks such as the Council on Foreign Relations, founded in 1921, produce research and supply officials to new administrations. Public opinion sets broad limits: support for a military operation tends to rise at first, a rally-round-the-flag effect, then fall if casualties mount and success is unclear.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming the president controls foreign policy alone; Congress funds, legislates and confirms, and the Senate consents to treaties. Second, treating the two presidencies thesis as settled; its gap has narrowed since the Cold War. Third, confusing the chair of the Joint Chiefs, the top military adviser, with a commander of forces; operational orders run from the president through the defense secretary. Fourth, thinking the CIA director heads all intelligence; the director of national intelligence does. Fifth, assuming an executive order can rename a department in law; that needs Congress.
Key takeaways
The Constitution divides foreign-policy powers, an "invitation to struggle": the president commands, negotiates and recognises governments, while Congress declares war, funds, regulates commerce and confirms. Wildavsky's two presidencies thesis (1966) holds that presidents fare better on foreign than domestic policy; the gap persists but has narrowed with the Cold War's end and polarisation. Most legislators focus on domestic issues, apart from committee specialists. The NSC, national security adviser, secretaries of state and defense, Joint Chiefs, director of national intelligence and Treasury carry out policy, and groups, think tanks and public opinion shape it.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Corwin's description of the Constitution's split of foreign-policy powers
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which foreign-policy power did the Supreme Court in Zivotofsky v. Kerry (2015) treat as belonging to the president alone?
Question 2 of 5
According to Wildavsky's two presidencies thesis, what should we expect?
Question 3 of 5
Why do most members of Congress spend little time on foreign policy?
Question 4 of 5
Which official oversees the entire US intelligence community?
Question 5 of 5
Why has the gap between presidents' foreign and domestic success narrowed since the Cold War?
