American Government › Section D · Civil liberties › Topic D.2
Religion, speech, press, and assembly
The First Amendment packs five freedoms into one sentence: religion, speech, press, assembly and petition. Courts have spent two centuries working out what each one protects, where its limits lie and how to balance it against other public interests.
One sentence, five freedoms
In 45 words the First Amendment guards two religious freedoms, a ban on establishing religion and the free exercise of faith, and four freedoms of expression: speech, press, peaceful assembly and petitioning the government. Its text names Congress, but through incorporation, explained in the topic "What are civil liberties?", it now binds state and local governments too, including public schools and universities. It restrains government only: a private employer or a social media company is not bound by it, although other laws may apply to them.
The establishment clause
The establishment clause stops government from setting up an official church, and courts have read it to bar favouring one religion over others or religion over non-religion. Thomas Jefferson described it in 1802 as building "a wall of separation between Church & State." In Engel v. Vitale (1962) the Supreme Court held that official prayers led in public schools were unconstitutional, even if voluntary. From 1971 courts often used the Lemon test, from Lemon v. Kurtzman, which asked about a law's purpose, effect and entanglement with religion. In Kennedy v. Bremerton School District (2022) the Court instead said such questions should be judged by historical practices and understandings, and the majority said the Court had long since abandoned Lemon.
Practising a faith
Belief itself is protected absolutely, but religiously motivated conduct can sometimes be regulated. In Sherbert v. Verner (1963) and Wisconsin v. Yoder (1972), the Court required a compelling government interest before burdening religious practice; Yoder let Amish parents end formal schooling after eighth grade. In Employment Division v. Smith (1990), involving members of the Native American Church fired for using peyote, it changed course: neutral, generally applicable laws apply to everyone, believers included. Congress answered with the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (1993), restoring the compelling-interest test by statute for federal action.
Worked example: prayer at a public school
Apply both religion clauses to three cases. 1. A teacher opens each lesson by leading a class prayer. The school is sponsoring religious exercise for children who must attend, which Engel and later cases forbid. 2. A student quietly prays before a test. That is private religious exercise, and the free exercise clause protects it; banning it would be unconstitutional. 3. A coach kneels for a short, personal prayer on the field after a game, not asking players to join. In Kennedy v. Bremerton (2022) the Court held this was protected private expression, though the dissent argued it pressured students. 4. Check: the key questions are who is speaking, whether students are coerced and whether the government is endorsing the prayer.
Free speech: from danger to incitement
Speech protection grew through the twentieth century. In Schenck v. United States (1919), the Court upheld the conviction of a man who urged resistance to the First World War draft, saying speech could be punished if it created a "clear and present danger." Today's standard comes from Brandenburg v. Ohio (1969), which overturned a Ku Klux Klan leader's conviction: advocacy of force or law-breaking is protected unless it is directed to inciting imminent lawless action and is likely to produce it. Political speech, even hateful or offensive speech, receives the strongest protection.
Symbolic speech and students
Expression need not be words. In Tinker v. Des Moines (1969) students wearing black armbands against the Vietnam War won; students do not, the Court said, shed their rights "at the schoolhouse gate," and schools may restrict speech only if it would cause substantial disruption or invade others' rights. Schools have more control over speech they sponsor, such as a school newspaper (Hazelwood, 1988). In Texas v. Johnson (1989) the Court held that burning the American flag in protest is protected, and it struck down a federal flag law the next year. In Mahanoy Area School District v. B. L. (2021) it ruled for a student disciplined over a profane weekend post made off campus.
Speech the Constitution does not protect
Some categories get little or no protection: incitement to imminent lawless action, true threats, fighting words aimed at provoking a fight, obscenity and defamation. Obscenity is judged by the Miller test (1973), which asks whether a work, taken as a whole, appeals to prurient interest, is patently offensive under community standards and lacks serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value. Defamation means false statements that harm a reputation. In New York Times v. Sullivan (1964) the Court ruled that public officials must prove "actual malice": the speaker knew the statement was false or acted with reckless disregard for the truth.
Press, assembly and petition
The press clause bars prior restraint, censorship before publication, except in the rarest cases. In Near v. Minnesota (1931) the Court struck down a law letting officials shut down "scandalous" newspapers, and in New York Times v. United States (1971) it let newspapers publish the Pentagon Papers, a secret history of the Vietnam War. Assembly and petition protect peaceful protest and lobbying, even by groups most people find abhorrent; in Snyder v. Phelps (2011) the Court protected a church's picketing near a military funeral. Governments may set reasonable time, place and manner rules, such as permits, but those rules must be content-neutral and treat all viewpoints alike.
Worked example: a campus protest
A state university bans a student group from holding a rally on the main lawn because officials dislike its message. 1. Is there government action? Yes: a state university is bound by the First Amendment. 2. Is the lawn a forum open to student expression? It is regularly used for events, so yes. 3. Is the rule content-neutral? No: it targets the group's message, which is viewpoint discrimination. 4. Could the speech be unprotected? Only if it were incitement, a true threat or similar, which disliked opinions are not. 5. Conclusion: the ban is very likely unconstitutional. 6. Contrast: a rule limiting all amplified rallies to certain hours would be a lawful time, place and manner rule.
The Second and Third Amendments
The Second Amendment protects "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms." Its link to a "well regulated Militia" long divided courts. In District of Columbia v. Heller (2008) the Court held that it protects an individual right, at least to keep a handgun at home for self-defence; McDonald v. Chicago (2010) applied it to the states. In New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022) it struck down New York's requirement to show special need for a carry licence and held that gun laws must fit the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. In United States v. Rahimi (2024) it upheld disarming people a court has found to be a credible threat to others. The Third Amendment, on quartering soldiers in homes, is rarely litigated.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, the First Amendment limits government, not private companies or employers. Second, prayer in public schools is not banned outright: officially led prayer is, but private, voluntary prayer is protected. Third, Schenck's "clear and present danger" test is no longer the standard; Brandenburg's imminent lawless action test is. Fourth, offensive or hateful speech is generally protected; only narrow categories such as true threats and incitement fall outside.
Key takeaways
The establishment clause bars official religion; Engel (1962) ended school-led prayer, and Kennedy (2022) replaced Lemon with a historical approach. Free exercise protects belief; Smith (1990) lets neutral laws apply to religious conduct, and RFRA (1993) restores stricter review for federal action. Brandenburg (1969) protects advocacy short of imminent incitement; Tinker, Texas v. Johnson and Mahanoy protect symbolic and student speech. Obscenity, threats and defamation are limited, with Sullivan's actual malice rule for officials. Prior restraint is almost never allowed. Heller, McDonald, Bruen and Rahimi define the Second Amendment's individual right.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Bars an official religion and government favouring religion
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which school practice does the establishment clause forbid?
Question 2 of 5
What did Employment Division v. Smith (1990) decide?
Question 3 of 5
Under Brandenburg v. Ohio (1969), when may government punish someone for advocating violence?
Question 4 of 5
A governor sues a newspaper over a false story. What must the governor prove under New York Times v. Sullivan (1964)?
Question 5 of 5
In New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022), what did the Supreme Court hold?
