American Government › Section D · Civil liberties › Topic D.1
What are civil liberties?
Civil liberties mark out what government may not do to you: silence you, force a faith on you, lock you up without a hearing. Knowing where they come from, and how they came to bind the states, explains much of what the Supreme Court argues about today.
Liberties and rights
In everyday speech "liberties" and "rights" mean much the same, but political scientists separate them. Civil liberties are limits on government: freedoms it may not take away, such as the free exercise of religion or protection from cruel and unusual punishment. Civil rights are guarantees of equal treatment: that government, and often employers or landlords, will not treat people differently because of race, sex or similar traits. The Constitution protects most liberties for "persons", not only citizens, so visitors and immigrants in the United States hold them too. Civil rights are the subject of the next section.
A Constitution without a bill of rights
The founders believed, with the English philosopher John Locke, that people hold natural rights no ruler can remove; the Declaration of Independence (1776) called them "unalienable", and states such as Virginia wrote them into their own constitutions. Yet the Constitution of 1787 had no bill of rights; a proposal to add one was rejected late in the Philadelphia convention. It did contain some protections: Article I, Section 9 bans bills of attainder and ex post facto laws and limits suspension of habeas corpus, and Article III guarantees jury trial in federal criminal cases. Federalists said more was unnecessary, because Congress had only listed powers. In Federalist No. 84 Alexander Hamilton warned that a list of rights could be dangerous, because people might assume any right left off the list was unprotected.
The Anti-Federalists win the argument
Anti-Federalists replied that the necessary and proper clause and the supremacy clause would let the new government reach into every part of life, so written limits were essential. The dispute nearly sank ratification, as the topic "Ratifying the Constitution" describes. To win votes in states such as Massachusetts, Virginia and New York, Federalists promised amendments. James Madison kept the promise in the First Congress in 1789. Congress sent twelve amendments to the states; ten were ratified in 1791 and became the Bill of Rights. One of the other two, on congressional pay, was finally ratified in 1992 as the Twenty-seventh Amendment.
What the Bill of Rights covers
The ten amendments fall into three groups. The First to Fourth protect basic freedoms: religion, speech, press, assembly and petition; keeping and bearing arms; freedom from having soldiers quartered in homes; and security against unreasonable searches and seizures. The Fourth to Eighth protect people suspected or accused of crimes, or involved in lawsuits: grand juries, no double jeopardy or forced self-incrimination, due process, speedy public trials, lawyers, civil juries, and no excessive bail or cruel and unusual punishment. The Ninth and Tenth are reminders: the people keep rights not listed, and powers not delegated are reserved to the states or the people.
Liberty under pressure
Written guarantees have not always held in a crisis. The Sedition Act of 1798 punished criticism of the government. During the Civil War President Abraham Lincoln suspended habeas corpus, and after the war the Supreme Court ruled in Ex parte Milligan (1866) that civilians could not be tried by military courts where civilian courts were open. In the Second World War about 120,000 people of Japanese ancestry, most of them US citizens, were forced into camps, and the Court upheld the removal in Korematsu v. United States (1944). In Trump v. Hawaii (2018) the Court said Korematsu had been "gravely wrong the day it was decided."
Barron v. Baltimore (1833)
At first the Bill of Rights restrained only the national government. John Barron's Baltimore wharf became useless after city works silted up the harbour around it, and he claimed Fifth Amendment compensation. In Barron v. Baltimore (1833), Chief Justice John Marshall held for a unanimous Court that the amendments limited only the federal government; protection against state governments had to come from state constitutions. For the next several decades, a state could restrict speech or religion without breaching the federal Bill of Rights at all.
The Fourteenth Amendment
The Civil War changed that. Southern states passed Black Codes restricting the rights of formerly enslaved people, and Congress responded with the Fourteenth Amendment, ratified in 1868. It says no state shall abridge "the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States," nor deprive "any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law," nor deny any person "the equal protection of the laws." The Court read the privileges or immunities clause narrowly in the Slaughter-House Cases (1873). Instead, it gradually used the due process clause as the route by which most Bill of Rights protections came to bind the states.
Selective incorporation
Rather than applying the whole Bill of Rights at once, the Court incorporated it one right at a time, asking whether each is fundamental to American liberty. This is selective incorporation. Early steps included just compensation for takings (1897) and free speech in Gitlow v. New York (1925). Many protections for suspects followed in the 1960s. Recent examples are the right to keep and bear arms in McDonald v. Chicago (2010), the ban on excessive fines in Timbs v. Indiana (2019) and the requirement of a unanimous jury to convict of a serious crime in Ramos v. Louisiana (2020). A few provisions remain unincorporated, notably the grand jury requirement and the right to a jury in civil cases.
Worked example: liberty or right?
Classify each complaint. 1. A city bans a newspaper from criticising the mayor. The issue is government restricting expression, so it is a civil liberty, under the First Amendment. 2. A state university rejects applicants of one race. The issue is unequal treatment, so it is a civil right, under the equal protection clause. 3. Police hold a suspect for weeks without bringing any charge. The issue is a limit on government power over the person, so it is a civil liberty, protected by habeas corpus and due process. 4. Check: liberties ask what government may not do; rights ask whether people are treated equally.
Worked example: does it bind the state?
Suppose a state court today convicts a defendant of a felony by a 10-to-2 jury vote. Was a right violated? 1. The Sixth Amendment guarantees an impartial jury in criminal trials. 2. Under Barron, that alone would bind only federal courts. 3. The Fourteenth Amendment's due process clause lets the Court apply fundamental rights to the states. 4. The jury right was incorporated in 1968, but in 1972 the Court allowed non-unanimous state verdicts. 5. In Ramos v. Louisiana (2020) it overruled that decision and required unanimity for serious offences in state courts too. 6. Conclusion: the 10-to-2 conviction is unconstitutional; when Ramos was decided, only Louisiana and Oregon still allowed such verdicts.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, liberties limit government; rights guarantee equal treatment. Second, the original Constitution did protect some liberties, such as habeas corpus and the bans on bills of attainder and ex post facto laws. Third, the Bill of Rights did not bind the states until incorporation; Barron (1833) said so plainly. Fourth, incorporation happened mainly through the due process clause, not the privileges or immunities clause.
Key takeaways
Civil liberties limit what government may do; civil rights guarantee equal treatment. Natural-rights ideas from the Declaration shaped state bills of rights. The 1787 Constitution protected habeas corpus and banned bills of attainder and ex post facto laws, but Anti-Federalist pressure produced the Bill of Rights in 1791. Liberties have been strained in wartime, from the Sedition Act to Korematsu. Barron (1833) limited the Bill of Rights to the national government. The Fourteenth Amendment (1868) opened the way to selective incorporation, from Gitlow (1925) to McDonald (2010), Timbs (2019) and Ramos (2020).
Flashcards
Flashcard
Limits on government that protect individual freedoms
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which situation is mainly about a civil liberty rather than a civil right?
Question 2 of 5
Why did Alexander Hamilton argue in Federalist No. 84 that a bill of rights could be dangerous?
Question 3 of 5
What did the Supreme Court hold in Barron v. Baltimore (1833)?
Question 4 of 5
Through which part of the Constitution has the Supreme Court mainly applied the Bill of Rights to the states?
Question 5 of 5
What did Ramos v. Louisiana (2020) decide?
