American Government › Section G · Voting and elections › Topic G.4
Campaigns and voting
A campaign has two jobs: persuade people to support its candidate and make sure those supporters actually vote. How campaigns raise money, reach voters and read the electorate, and how voters reach a decision, explain much of what happens in an American election.
Two jobs: persuade and mobilise
Every campaign divides the electorate into groups. Firm supporters need mobilising, a reminder and a push to vote. Undecided or weakly attached voters need persuading. Firm opponents are usually left alone, because money spent on them is mostly wasted. Campaigns build these groups from voter files, the public records of who is registered and which past elections they voted in (but never how they voted), combined with polling and commercial data. The previous topic showed the stages of an election and the rules on money; this one looks at strategy, and at how voters make up their minds.
Fundraising
Money buys staff, advertising and travel, and early money signals that a candidate is viable. The group EMILY's List, founded in 1985 to back Democratic women who support abortion rights, took its name from the acronym "Early Money Is Like Yeast", because early gifts help later ones grow. Candidates raise money from large donors at events, from political action committees and, increasingly, from small online gifts through platforms such as ActBlue for Democrats and WinRed for Republicans. Candidates may also spend unlimited amounts of their own money, because Buckley v. Valeo treated a candidate's own spending as protected speech. Outside groups such as super PACs often spend heavily too, so a campaign does not control every message made on its behalf.
Primary campaigns versus general campaigns
In a primary, every candidate shares the same party label, so voters cannot use party as a guide. Name recognition matters enormously, and lesser-known candidates chase media coverage, debate time and early wins to gain momentum. Primary voters are fewer and more committed, so candidates often stress positions popular with their party's base. In the general election each party has one candidate, and most partisans will vote for their own side. The contest then turns on mobilising the base and winning independents and undecided voters. For president, campaigns concentrate on battleground states; in 2024 the main ones were Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Nevada, North Carolina, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin.
Advertising and its tone
Television spot advertising took off in the 1952 presidential race, when Dwight Eisenhower answered short questions in filmed spots. Ads can be positive, introducing the candidate; contrast ads, comparing records; or negative, attacking an opponent. The 1964 "Daisy" ad for Lyndon Johnson, which cut from a girl counting petals to a nuclear blast, aired only once as a paid ad but was replayed widely on the news. The 2002 McCain-Feingold law added the "stand by your ad" rule: candidates must say on air that they approved the message. Studies find that voters remember negative ads, but researchers disagree about whether such ads lower turnout.
The ground game
Get-out-the-vote (GOTV) work tries to turn supporters into voters through door-knocking, phone calls, texts and rides to the polls. Political scientists Alan Gerber and Donald Green tested these methods with randomised field experiments, beginning in New Haven, Connecticut, in 1998. They and later researchers found that personal, face-to-face contact raises turnout more reliably than mailers or pre-recorded calls. Campaigns now run thousands of such tests. The lesson is that a conversation with a real person, especially a neighbour, makes voting feel expected, which connects to the sense of civic duty discussed in the topic on voter turnout.
Technology and new risks
Campaigns moved online around 2000, then onto social media, where they can speak to supporters directly and cheaply. Microtargeting combines voter files with consumer data to send different messages to small groups, such as parents in one suburb. Candidates also reach audiences through late-night shows and podcasts. New tools bring new risks. Before the January 2024 New Hampshire primary, robocalls used an artificially generated imitation of President Joe Biden's voice to tell people not to vote. In February 2024 the Federal Communications Commission ruled that AI-generated voices in robocalls fall under an existing ban on artificial voices without consent. Many states have since passed laws on deceptive AI election content.
Worked example: spending the last $10 million
A presidential campaign has $10 million left for the final two weeks. 1. Rank states by closeness: polls show State A tied, State B leaning to the candidate by 3 points and State C safely won by 15. 2. Apply winner-take-all: extra votes in C add no electors, so C gets nothing. 3. Persuade or mobilise: in tied State A, split money between ads for undecided voters and GOTV for supporters. 4. Protect B: a smaller GOTV effort keeps the lead. 5. Check the logic: spending follows the chance of changing the result, not the number of voters, which is why voters in safe states see few campaign visits.
How voters decide: shortcuts
Few voters study every candidate, so most use shortcuts, called heuristics. The strongest is party identification. Political scientists often see party-line voting as reasonable, because parties take fairly consistent positions. A few states let voters choose straight-ticket voting, marking one box for every candidate of a party. Long ballots cause roll-off, when people vote for top offices but skip lower ones, such as judges. Voters also respond to candidates' traits, including perceived competence, experience, age, gender and race, and to endorsements from trusted groups. Some are single-issue voters, who decide on one question, such as abortion or gun policy.
Issues, the economy and strategy
Voters who weigh records engage in retrospective voting, judging the party in power on how things went, often the economy. Prospective voting looks forward, asking which candidate will handle the future better. Pocketbook voters focus on their own finances; sociotropic voters judge the economy of the whole country, and research suggests the national economy usually weighs more. Strategic voting means backing a second choice because a first choice cannot win, as when a supporter of a minor party votes for the major-party candidate closest to their views to stop the other side.
Worked example: naming a voter's reasoning
Classify each voter. 1. Ana says, "Prices rose under the governor, so I'm voting her out." She judges past performance: retrospective. 2. Ben says, "My hours were cut, so I'm voting for change." He reasons from his own finances: pocketbook. 3. Chloe says, "Whatever my own job, the country is in a slump." She judges the national economy: sociotropic. 4. Dev prefers a minor-party candidate but votes for a major-party one with a chance to win: strategic. 5. Eli picks the candidate whose plan he expects to work best next term: prospective. 6. Check: a voter can combine several of these at once.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming campaigns try to persuade everyone; they target persuadable voters and mobilise supporters. Second, thinking voter files show how people voted; they record only whether they voted. Third, confusing retrospective voting, which looks back, with prospective voting, which looks forward. Fourth, treating pocketbook and sociotropic voting as the same; one is personal, the other national. Fifth, assuming a super PAC's ad is the candidate's own; super PACs may not coordinate with campaigns.
Key takeaways
Campaigns persuade the undecided and mobilise supporters, using voter files, polls and data. Early money signals viability, and small online gifts now matter a great deal. Primaries reward name recognition and appeals to the base; general elections turn on independents and battleground states. Ads range from positive to negative, and McCain-Feingold added "stand by your ad". Face-to-face GOTV contact raises turnout most reliably. Voters use shortcuts such as party identification, and judge records retrospectively or futures prospectively, through pocketbook or sociotropic lenses, sometimes voting strategically.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Getting supporters to vote vs winning over the undecided
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A voter says: "My own job is fine, but the country's economy has been weak under this president, so I'm voting for the challenger." Which kind of economic voting is this?
Question 2 of 5
Why do presidential campaigns spend little in states that one party is sure to win?
Question 3 of 5
What did Gerber and Green's field experiments, and later studies, find about getting out the vote?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement about voter files is correct?
Question 5 of 5
A voter prefers a minor-party candidate but votes for a major-party candidate who can win, to stop the other major party. What is this called?
