American Government › Section G · Voting and elections › Topic G.3
How elections work
An American election is not one event but a sequence: someone decides to run, raises money under federal and state rules, wins a party nomination, and then faces the general electorate. Knowing each stage explains who ends up on the ballot and why.
From candidacy to Election Day
The Constitution sets only a few rules for federal candidates. A member of the House must be at least 25, a citizen for seven years and a resident of the state; a senator at least 30, a citizen for nine years and a resident; a president at least 35, a natural-born citizen and a resident for 14 years. States add filing rules, such as petition signatures or fees. Beyond the law, would-be candidates weigh their chances. An incumbent, the current officeholder, is hard to beat: House members seeking re-election usually win more than 90 percent of the time. An open seat, with no incumbent running, draws more and stronger challengers.
Money and viability
Early money signals viability, the appearance of being able to win, which attracts more donors, staff and press attention. Incumbents often hold a war chest, money left over from earlier campaigns, which can scare off challengers. The sums are large. The Federal Election Commission (FEC) reported in April 2025 that, across 2023 and 2024, presidential candidates raised about $2.0 billion and House and Senate candidates about $3.8 billion, while independent expenditures by outside groups totalled about $4.4 billion. Rules govern where that money may come from and how it must be reported, and they have changed many times.
The rules on campaign money
The Tillman Act of 1907 banned corporate contributions to federal candidates. The Federal Election Campaign Act of 1971 (FECA) required disclosure, and its 1974 amendments set contribution limits and created the FEC to enforce them. In Buckley v. Valeo (1976) the Supreme Court upheld contribution limits but struck down limits on campaign spending, treating spending as protected speech. The Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002, known as McCain-Feingold, banned unlimited soft money gifts to national parties. Citizens United v. FEC (2010) then allowed corporations and unions to spend without limit on independent political messages, which, with a lower-court ruling the same year, opened the way for super PACs.
Worked example: applying the contribution limits
For 2025-26 the FEC's limits are $3,500 per election from an individual to a candidate, $5,000 a year to a PAC and $44,300 a year to a national party committee. Jordan wants to support a House candidate. 1. Count the elections: the primary and the general election are separate, so Jordan may give $3,500 to each, $7,000 in all. 2. Add a PAC: a further $5,000 a year to a PAC that backs the candidate is allowed. 3. Add a super PAC: Jordan may give any amount, because a super PAC spends independently and may not give to or coordinate with the campaign. 4. Check: every gift must be reported, and the candidate's committee must refund anything over the limit.
Choosing nominees: primaries
The Constitution says nothing about nominations, so parties and states decide how nominees are picked. Most use a primary, an election in which voters choose a party's candidate. In a closed primary only registered party members may vote; in an open primary any voter may choose either party's ballot; semi-closed primaries let unaffiliated voters join. California and Washington use a top-two primary, in which all candidates run together and the two leaders advance, even if they share a party. In California Democratic Party v. Jones (2000), the Court struck down a blanket primary that let anyone help pick a party's nominee, but it later upheld Washington's top-two system, where the candidates are not party nominees.
Caucuses, the calendar and conventions
A caucus is a gathering of party members who discuss candidates and then express a preference, often by gathering in groups; turnout is usually lower than in primaries. For president, primaries and caucuses award delegates to each party's national convention. Iowa and New Hampshire traditionally go first, though for 2024 the Democrats put South Carolina first. States crowding their contests early is called frontloading. Democrats award delegates in proportion to the vote, for candidates above 15 percent; Republicans let states choose, including winner-take-all. At the summer convention, delegates formally nominate the ticket and adopt a platform. The topic on the presidential election process covers this in more depth.
The general election
Federal general elections fall on the Tuesday after the first Monday in November. States and counties run them, printing ballots, staffing polls and certifying results. Most American contests use plurality voting in single-member districts: whoever gets the most votes wins, even without a majority. Some states differ. Georgia requires a majority, with a runoff between the top two if no one reaches it, and Maine and Alaska have used ranked-choice voting for some contests, in which voters rank candidates and the last-placed are eliminated until one has a majority. In midterm elections, held halfway through a presidential term, the president's party usually loses House seats; 1934, 1998 and 2002 were rare exceptions.
The Electoral College
Voters for president actually choose electors. Each state has as many electors as it has members of Congress, and the Twenty-Third Amendment (1961) gives Washington, DC three, for 538 in all; a candidate needs 270, a majority. Forty-eight states and DC give all their electors to the statewide winner. Maine and Nebraska give two to the statewide winner and one to the winner of each congressional district. Because of winner-take-all, a candidate can win the presidency while losing the national popular vote, as happened in 2000 and 2016. Congress counts the electoral votes in January; the Electoral Count Reform Act of 2022 clarified that the vice president's role in that count is ministerial, with no power to reject electoral votes.
Worked example: counting electors
Apply the rule electors = House seats + 2. 1. Texas has 38 House seats, so it has 40 electors; Wyoming has one seat, so it has 3. 2. Winner-take-all: a candidate who carries Texas by one vote or by a million receives all 40. 3. Maine's split rule: in 2024 Kamala Harris carried Maine statewide and its 1st District, winning 3 electors, while Donald Trump carried the 2nd District, winning 1. 4. Nebraska worked the other way: Trump won 4 electors and Harris 1, from the 2nd District. 5. Total: Trump finished with 312 electoral votes and Harris with 226, which add to 538.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking the Constitution sets out how parties nominate candidates; nominations are governed by party rules and state law. Second, confusing an open primary, where voters pick one party's ballot, with a top-two primary, where all candidates share one ballot. Third, saying super PACs can give money straight to candidates; they must spend independently. Fourth, believing every state awards electors winner-take-all; Maine and Nebraska do not. Fifth, assuming American winners always need a majority; most contests need only a plurality.
Key takeaways
Elections run from candidacy through nomination to the general election. Incumbents usually win, and early money signals viability. FECA (1971, 1974) set disclosure and limits and created the FEC; Buckley (1976) protected spending; McCain-Feingold (2002) banned soft money; Citizens United (2010) led to super PACs. Nominees are chosen in closed, open, semi-closed or top-two primaries, or caucuses, and presidential delegates meet at conventions. Most contests use plurality rule. The Electoral College has 538 electors and needs 270; all states but Maine and Nebraska award electors winner-take-all.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The current holder of an office
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did the Supreme Court decide in Buckley v. Valeo (1976)?
Question 2 of 5
In a top-two primary, what happens to the candidates?
Question 3 of 5
Under the 2025-26 FEC limits, what is the most an individual may give directly to one House candidate's campaign across the primary and general election?
Question 4 of 5
Why can a presidential candidate win the Electoral College while losing the national popular vote?
Question 5 of 5
Georgia requires a majority, so what happens if no candidate for an office gets one in the general election?
