American Government › Section P · Domestic policy › Topic P.2
Categorizing public policy
Why does government build flood barriers but leave sandwich shops to the market? The answer starts with the kind of good involved, and the type of policy chosen then shapes who pays, who benefits and how fierce the political fight becomes.
An argument about the role of government
Americans disagree about how much government should do. Broadly, many liberals favour an active government that reduces inequality and protects consumers and the environment. Many conservatives prefer a smaller government and see markets, families and private groups as better suited to most tasks. Libertarians go further, arguing that government almost always works less efficiently than private enterprise and should be kept to a minimum. Each view rests on values as well as evidence. Economics offers a shared vocabulary for the debate by asking first what kind of good is at stake.
Two questions about any good
Economists use the word goods for the products, services and systems that satisfy people's wants and needs, from a loaf of bread to a national highway network. Two questions sort them. First, is the good excludable: can people who do not pay be kept from using it? Second, is it rival: does one person's use leave less for everyone else? Together the two yes-or-no questions produce four types of good, and each type raises a different question about whether, and how, government should be involved.
Private goods and markets
Most things you buy are private goods: excludable and rival. A shop can refuse to hand over a sandwich until you pay, and once you eat it, no one else can. Because private goods can be owned and traded, markets handle them well: sellers compete for buyers, and prices signal what people want. Supporters of free-market economics argue that for nearly any good that can be owned, voluntary exchange allocates it more efficiently than government can. Even so, markets depend on government to define property rights, enforce contracts and maintain a stable currency.
Public goods and free riders
Public goods are the opposite case: non-excludable and non-rival. National defence protects everyone in the country, and one more resident does not reduce the protection others receive. A flood barrier around a town and a tornado warning siren work the same way. The difficulty is the free-rider problem: because no one can be excluded, each person gains by letting others pay, so a private seller would struggle to fund the good at all. Governments therefore usually supply public goods and pay for them through taxes.
Common-pool resources
Common-pool resources are non-excludable but rival. Anyone can fish an open ocean or pump from a shared aquifer, yet every fish caught or gallon pumped leaves less for others. The ecologist Garrett Hardin called the result, in a 1968 essay, the tragedy of the commons: each user gains the full benefit of taking more but bears only a small share of the damage, so the resource is overused. Governments respond with catch limits, permits and pollution rules. The political economist Elinor Ostrom, who shared the 2009 Nobel prize in economics, showed that many communities also manage commons successfully through rules they write themselves.
Toll goods
Toll goods, also called club goods, are excludable but largely non-rival. A cable or streaming service can shut off anyone who stops paying, but one more viewer does not reduce what others see. A toll road is similar until traffic grows heavy and congestion makes it rival. Toll goods can be provided by private firms or by government. As industrialisation concentrated economic power, and again during the Great Depression, Americans increasingly turned to government to regulate or provide such goods.
Worked example: classifying goods
Sort four goods using the two questions. 1. A town's tornado siren: no one can be kept from hearing it, and one more listener takes nothing away, so it is a public good, normally funded by taxes. 2. The fish in a lake open to all anglers: no one is excluded, but every fish taken leaves fewer, so it is a common-pool resource, and catch limits guard against overfishing. 3. A paid music streaming service: non-payers are locked out, but one more listener costs others nothing, so it is a toll good. 4. A loaf of bread: excludable and rival, so it is a private good. Check: two yes-or-no answers place each good in exactly one of the four boxes.
Lowi's three types of policy
In 1964 the political scientist Theodore Lowi argued that the type of policy shapes the politics around it. Distributive policies give benefits to particular groups or places, paid from general revenue: dams, highways, farm subsidies and research grants. Conflict is usually low, because costs are spread thinly and lawmakers trade support for one another's projects, a practice called logrolling. Regulatory policies set rules on behaviour, such as safety standards, and pit those regulated against those seeking protection. Redistributive policies shift resources between broad groups, such as from higher-income to lower-income households, and produce the widest, most ideological conflict. Lowi later added a fourth type, constituent policy, concerning the rules of government itself.
Concentrated or diffuse costs and benefits
A related approach, associated with the political scientist James Q. Wilson, asks whether a policy's costs and benefits fall on a few people or are spread across many. When benefits are concentrated and costs diffuse, as with a subsidy to one industry, the winners organise while the payers barely notice. When benefits are diffuse and costs concentrated, as with pollution limits, the few who pay fight hard, so change often needs a policy entrepreneur to rally the public. Ralph Nader's 1965 book on car safety helped produce a federal vehicle safety law in 1966. Redistributive policies concentrate costs on one group and benefits on another, so both sides mobilise.
Worked example: predicting the politics
Classify three proposals and predict the fight. 1. A federal grant to rebuild one region's port: benefits go to that region, costs are spread over all taxpayers, so it is distributive. Expect local lawmakers to push hard against little opposition. 2. A rule requiring power plants to cut mercury emissions: costs fall on plant owners, benefits spread to everyone who breathes the air, so it is regulatory. Expect the industry to lobby against it and health and environmental groups to back it. 3. A larger tax credit for low-income working families, paid for by a higher top income tax rate: it is redistributive. Expect a broad, partisan debate. Check: each label depends on who pays and who benefits, not on whether the policy is wise.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, calling anything the government provides a public good: a public school place or a postal delivery is excludable, so it does not meet the definition. Second, confusing public goods, which are non-rival, with common-pool resources, which can be used up. Third, forcing every programme into one box: Pell grants give help to individual students, a distributive feature, but target lower-income students, a redistributive one. Fourth, treating these categories as verdicts on whether a policy is good; they describe who pays and who benefits. Fifth, assuming toll goods must be privately run.
Key takeaways
Goods are sorted by two questions: are they excludable, and are they rival? Private goods are both and suit markets. Public goods are neither, invite free riding and are usually provided by government through taxes. Common-pool resources are rival but not excludable and risk the tragedy of the commons. Toll goods are excludable but largely non-rival. Lowi divided policies into distributive, regulatory and redistributive types, each with its own politics. Whether costs and benefits are concentrated or diffuse helps predict who will organise.
Flashcards
Flashcard
People who do not pay can be kept from using the good
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which pair of properties defines a public good?
Question 2 of 5
Anglers on a lake open to everyone keep taking more fish until the stock collapses. What does this illustrate?
Question 3 of 5
In Lowi's typology, farm subsidies paid for from general tax revenue are which type of policy?
Question 4 of 5
A proposed rule would impose costs on a few firms while its benefits are spread across the whole public. What pattern of politics is most likely?
Question 5 of 5
A paid streaming service cuts off anyone who stops paying, but one more viewer takes nothing away from the others. What type of good is it?
