American Government › Section P · Domestic policy › Topic P.1

What is public policy?

Laws, budgets, regulations and court rulings add up to something larger: what government actually does about the problems people care about. Knowing what counts as public policy, and what does not, is the starting point for studying it.

Seeing the whole system at work

Earlier sections of this course studied the parts of the political system one at a time: Congress, the presidency, the courts, the bureaucracy, parties, interest groups and the media. Public policy is where those parts meet. A rule on vehicle emissions might begin with scientists and advocacy groups, pass through Congress, be detailed by an agency and finally be tested in court. Studying policy means following an issue across these institutions and asking: what did government end up doing, who gains, and who pays?

Defining public policy

Public policy is a government's relatively stable, purposeful course of action on a matter that concerns a large part of society. Each part of that definition matters. Stable means the policy lasts: a single press release or a one-week emergency order is not yet a policy. Purposeful means it aims at a goal, such as cleaner air or fewer people without health insurance. And a large part of society means the issue reaches beyond one person or one firm. A widely used shorter definition, associated with the political scientist Thomas Dye, counts both what governments choose to do and what they choose not to do.

Policy is built over years

Major policies rarely appear overnight. The Affordable Care Act of 2010 shows this. Proposals to widen health coverage had circulated for decades, and a large plan from President Bill Clinton failed in Congress in 1994. In 2006 Massachusetts, under Governor Mitt Romney, combined a requirement to hold insurance with subsidies and a regulated marketplace. The 2010 federal law borrowed much of that design and built on Medicare and Medicaid, which date from 1965. A law that looked sudden drew on state experiments and years of debate, and it has kept changing since.

Public matters, not private favours

Governments also deal with single individuals and companies, but that is not public policy. Congress occasionally passes private bills, laws that apply to one named person or firm, for example to settle one claim against the government or to grant permanent residence to one immigrant. Such a law helps one person; it does not set a rule for society. By contrast, the general rules on who may become a naturalised citizen, and how, are public policy, because they apply to everyone in the same situation. The test is reach: does the action set terms for a whole class of people?

Deciding not to act

Because policy includes deliberate inaction, keeping the status quo can be a choice with real effects. The federal minimum wage is a clear case. Congress last raised it to $7.25 an hour in July 2009 and has not changed it since. Each year without a change, inflation reduces what $7.25 buys, so the real value of the minimum falls even though no new law is passed. Many states and cities have set higher minimums of their own. Whether Congress should raise the federal level is debated; the point here is that not deciding is itself a decision.

The forms policy takes

Policy is expressed in several ways. Statutes passed by Congress and signed by the President set goals and rules, and appropriations decide how much is spent. Executive orders direct how the executive branch carries out the law; they carry weight but can be revoked by a later president. Agency regulations fill in details: under the Administrative Procedure Act of 1946, agencies usually publish a proposed rule in the Federal Register, take public comments and then issue a final rule. Courts make policy too. In Gideon v. Wainwright (1963) the Supreme Court required states to provide lawyers for poor defendants facing felony charges.

Why Congress delegates

Elected officials rarely have the technical knowledge to settle every detail, so they often state a goal and hand the specifics to an agency. The Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 directed the new Occupational Safety and Health Administration to set workplace standards, leaving experts to decide, for example, how much exposure to a hazardous chemical is permitted. Delegation lets policy keep up with new science, but it also raises questions about how much power unelected officials should hold. The topic Controlling the bureaucracy explains how Congress, the President and the courts keep that power in check.

Worked example: is it public policy?

Test four actions against the definition. 1. A state law sets a 65 mph speed limit on all rural highways. It is lasting, aimed at safety and applies to every driver, so it is public policy. 2. Congress passes a bill paying one farmer's claim for land damaged during an army exercise. It helps one person, so it is a private bill, not public policy. 3. Year after year, a legislature declines to raise the state fuel tax as roads wear out. The repeated choice keeps the status quo, so it counts as policy. 4. A mayor gives one speech praising recycling, with no programme behind it. Nothing lasting or binding follows, so it is not yet policy. Check: each verdict rests on reach, purpose and stability.

Winners, losers and surprises

Almost every policy helps some people and costs others, if only the taxpayers who fund it, and policies can have unintended consequences. In 1990 Congress imposed a 10% luxury tax on the part of the price above set thresholds for boats, private aircraft, jewellery, furs and cars, aiming to raise revenue from wealthy buyers. Boat sales fell sharply, and reports of lost jobs at boatyards led Congress to repeal most of the tax in 1993. Economists still debate how much of the slump the tax caused, since a recession began at about the same time.

Worked example: tracing a policy's effects

A city starts charging shoppers 10 cents for each single-use carrier bag. Trace who gains and who pays. 1. Goal: fewer bags littering streets and filling landfills. 2. Direct cost: shoppers who forget reusable bags pay the fee, a small cost on some people. 3. Gain: cleaner streets and lower clean-up costs, spread across all residents. 4. Possible surprise: some households buy more plastic bin liners, offsetting part of the cut in plastic. 5. Evaluation question: did total plastic use fall, and by how much? Check: the policy has a goal, identifiable payers, widely shared benefits and at least one side effect worth measuring.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, equating policy with a single law: a policy is a lasting course of action that may combine statutes, spending, regulations and court rulings. Second, forgetting that deliberate inaction, such as leaving a wage or tax unchanged, is also policy. Third, treating a private bill or a one-off favour as public policy. Fourth, assuming only Congress makes policy, when presidents, agencies and courts all do. Fifth, judging a policy by its intentions alone instead of its outcomes, including the unintended ones.

Key takeaways

Public policy is a relatively stable, purposeful course of government action on a matter that concerns a large part of society, and it includes deliberate choices not to act. Major policies, such as the Affordable Care Act, grow over years. Private bills that help one person are not public policy. Policy takes the form of statutes, appropriations, executive orders, regulations and court rulings, with Congress often delegating details to agencies. Every policy creates winners and losers, and it is judged by its outcomes, intended or not.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Public policy

A relatively stable, purposeful course of government action on a matter concerning much of society

Stable, aimed at a goal, wide in reach.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which description best fits the definition of public policy?

Question 2 of 5

Congress has left the federal minimum wage at $7.25 an hour since 2009. In policy terms, this is best described as what?

Question 3 of 5

What is a private bill?

Question 4 of 5

Under the Administrative Procedure Act of 1946, how do federal agencies usually make a new rule?

Question 5 of 5

The 1990 luxury tax on expensive boats, which Congress largely repealed in 1993, is mainly an example of what?

← Previous topicNext topic →