American Government › Section O · The bureaucracy › Topic O.4
Controlling the bureaucracy
Millions of unelected officials write rules with the force of law and spend trillions of dollars. How do voters and their representatives keep them on course? This topic follows the tools of control held by Congress, the president, the courts, citizens and the bureaucrats themselves.
The control problem
Congress writes laws in general terms, such as "protect workers from unsafe conditions," and leaves the details to agencies with expert staff. Political scientists call this a principal-agent relationship: the principals, elected officials and ultimately voters, delegate work to agents, the agencies, who know more about the task and may have goals of their own. Delegation is efficient, because Congress cannot write rules for every chemical or aircraft part, but it raises the question of how unelected experts stay accountable. The answer is several overlapping controls.
How agencies make rules
Most federal rules are made under the Administrative Procedure Act of 1946 by notice-and-comment rulemaking. The agency publishes a proposed rule in the Federal Register, the government's daily journal of rules and notices; anyone may comment, today mostly online; and the agency must consider the comments and explain its final rule, which then carries the force of law. Critics said the process could become adversarial and slow. The Negotiated Rulemaking Act of 1990, made permanent in 1996, lets an agency first bring affected groups together in a committee, with a neutral convener and facilitator, to seek a consensus draft. That draft still goes through notice and comment.
Congress: purse, people and probes
Congress creates, reorganises and abolishes agencies, and its power of the purse decides each one's budget every year. The Senate confirms top appointees. Committees hold oversight hearings, from routine budget reviews to tense investigations, as in 2013, when the House examined the Internal Revenue Service's extra scrutiny of some groups applying for tax-exempt status. The Government Accountability Office (GAO), Congress's nonpartisan investigative arm, audits programmes and publishes hundreds of reports a year. Under the Congressional Review Act (1996), Congress can also overturn a new rule by a joint resolution passed soon after the rule is issued, subject to the president's veto.
The president: appointments and the budget
The president names cabinet secretaries, agency heads and roughly 4,000 other political appointees who carry the administration's priorities into the agencies. As the topic "Types of bureaucracies" explained, Trump v. Slaughter (2026) widened the president's power to remove commissioners. The Office of Management and Budget (OMB) prepares the president's budget and checks agencies' performance, and within it the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs reviews significant proposed rules before they are published, a practice in place since the 1980s. Presidents also direct agencies through executive orders, and they can cut or redirect staff, as the Trump administration's large workforce reductions of 2025, some of them challenged in court, showed.
The courts
Anyone harmed by an agency action can usually ask a federal court to review it. Under the Administrative Procedure Act, courts set aside actions that exceed the agency's legal authority, ignore required procedures, or are "arbitrary and capricious," meaning not reasonably explained. For forty years, under Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council (1984), judges deferred to an agency's reasonable reading of an unclear statute. In Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo (2024), the Supreme Court overruled Chevron: courts must now decide for themselves what a statute means. The Court's major questions doctrine adds that agencies need clear authority from Congress for decisions of vast economic or political significance.
Worked example: one rule, many checkpoints
Imagine an agency wants a new safety rule for e-bike batteries. 1. Authority: it points to a statute letting it set consumer product safety standards. 2. White House: because the rule is significant, OIRA reviews it before publication. 3. Notice: the proposal appears in the Federal Register, and manufacturers, retailers and fire-safety groups submit comments. 4. Final rule: the agency answers the main comments and publishes the rule. 5. Congress: members opposed could try a Congressional Review Act resolution, which the president could veto. 6. Courts: a manufacturer sues, and after Loper Bright the judge reads the statute independently. 7. Conclusion: each branch has a chance to stop, change or confirm the rule.
Citizens: freedom of information and sunshine
Citizens have tools of their own. The Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) of 1966 lets anyone request federal agency records. Agencies must release them unless one of nine exemptions applies, such as classified national security information, trade secrets, personal privacy or some law-enforcement files, and they often release documents with sensitive parts blacked out. Agencies received about 1.5 million requests in fiscal 2024, a record at the time, according to the Justice Department; the Department of Homeland Security, largely asked for immigration files, received the largest share. The Government in the Sunshine Act (1976) requires agencies led by multi-member boards to hold most meetings in public.
Worked example: a FOIA request
A student journalist wants an agency's inspection reports on a local factory. 1. Request: she files a written request online, describing the records clearly. 2. Deadline: the law gives the agency 20 working days to decide, with extensions in unusual circumstances, although backlogs often cause delays. 3. Response: the agency releases most pages but blacks out the factory's chemical formulas under the trade secrets exemption and inspectors' home addresses under the privacy exemption. 4. Appeal: she may appeal within the agency if she thinks too much was withheld. 5. Court: if the appeal fails, she may sue in federal court. 6. Conclusion: FOIA opens records by default, but exemptions and delays limit it.
Insiders: whistleblowers and inspectors general
A whistleblower is an insider who exposes misconduct, often at risk to a career. The Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 protected federal whistleblowers from reprisal, enforced through the Office of Special Counsel and the Merit Systems Protection Board, and the Whistleblower Protection Acts of 1989 and 2012 strengthened those protections. The Inspector General Act of 1978 created inspectors general, independent auditors and investigators inside major agencies who report to both the agency head and Congress. In January 2025 President Trump removed about 17 inspectors general; supporters called it a fresh start, while critics said it weakened independent oversight.
Privatisation
Another response to inefficiency is privatisation, bringing market forces into government work. The commonest form is contracting out: private firms build, supply or run services under government contracts, and during the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan contractors at times outnumbered U.S. troops. Divestiture sells or hands a function to the private sector entirely: Sallie Mae, a government-sponsored student loan company, became fully private in 2004. Vouchers let citizens buy services in the market, and third-party financing uses private borrowing to pay for public buildings. Supporters argue that competition cuts costs; critics warn that contractors can be costly and harder to hold accountable.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, a proposed rule in the Federal Register is not yet law; it becomes binding only when issued as a final rule. Second, negotiated rulemaking adds a consensus step before notice and comment; it does not replace it. Third, after Loper Bright (2024), courts no longer defer to an agency's reading of an unclear statute. Fourth, FOIA covers federal agency records, not Congress or the federal courts, and it allows nine exemptions. Fifth, the Sunshine Act opens agency meetings, while FOIA opens agency records; they are different laws.
Key takeaways
Delegating to expert agencies creates a principal-agent problem, so control comes from many directions. Agencies make rules by notice and comment under the Administrative Procedure Act (1946), sometimes after negotiated rulemaking. Congress controls budgets, confirmations, hearings, the GAO and Congressional Review Act resolutions. The president appoints, removes and directs through OMB, OIRA review and executive orders. Courts review agency actions, and since Loper Bright (2024) interpret statutes without Chevron deference. Citizens use FOIA (1966) and the Sunshine Act (1976); insiders rely on whistleblower laws and inspectors general. Privatisation shifts work to the market, with disputed results.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Those who delegate cannot fully watch the experts who act for them
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
An agency publishes a proposed rule in the Federal Register and invites public comments. What is the status of the proposal?
Question 2 of 5
What changed after Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo (2024)?
Question 3 of 5
A reporter wants copies of an agency's internal emails. Which law gives her the right to request them?
Question 4 of 5
Which is a tool Congress uses to oversee the bureaucracy?
Question 5 of 5
A city hires a private company to run its bus service under a five-year contract. Which form of privatisation is this?
