American Government › Section L · The presidency › Topic L.1
The design and evolution of the presidency
The framers wrote only a few hundred words about the president, then left the details to practice. How that short text became the most visible office in American government is a story of design choices, crises and ambitious occupants.
Inventing an executive
The Articles of Confederation had no executive branch, and many delegates in 1787 feared that a strong one would revive monarchy. The Virginia Plan proposed a "national executive" chosen by Congress, without saying whether it would be one person or several. Early votes favoured a single executive serving one seven-year term; the New Jersey Plan offered a weak executive committee; Alexander Hamilton suggested a life term. In Federalist No. 70 he defended a single president: "Energy in the executive is a leading character in the definition of good government." One person, he argued, could act quickly and be held responsible.
Electors and the Twelfth Amendment
Delegates rejected both election by Congress, which invited intrigue, and direct popular election. A version of James Wilson's idea of electors won, producing the Electoral College and a four-year term open to re-election. Today there are 538 electors, one for each member of Congress plus three for the District of Columbia, and a candidate needs 270. Originally each elector cast two votes, and the runner-up became vice president. When Thomas Jefferson and his own running mate, Aaron Burr, tied in 1800, the House needed 36 ballots to choose Jefferson. The Twelfth Amendment (1804) created separate votes for president and vice president.
Who can serve, and for how long
Article II requires a president to be a natural-born citizen, at least 35 years old and a resident for at least 14 years. It set no limit on re-election; Washington's choice to stop after two terms became a custom. After Franklin Roosevelt won four elections, the Twenty-Second Amendment (1951) limited presidents to two elected terms. The Twenty-Fifth Amendment (1967) confirmed that the vice president becomes president if the office falls vacant, let the president fill a vacant vice presidency with the approval of both chambers, and covered presidential disability. The vice president's only regular constitutional job is presiding over the Senate and breaking ties.
The powers in Article II
Article II opens with the vesting clause: "The executive Power shall be vested in a President of the United States of America." It then lists powers. The president is commander in chief, may pardon federal offences except in cases of impeachment, makes treaties with the consent of two-thirds of senators present, and nominates ambassadors, judges and senior officers for Senate approval. The president receives foreign ambassadors, reports on the state of the union, may call Congress into special session, and must "take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed." The veto, which two-thirds of each chamber can override, is set out in Article I.
Impeachment: the framers' safety valve
The framers built in removal for "Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors." It takes two steps. The House impeaches, meaning it brings formal charges, by a simple majority. The Senate then holds a trial, with the chief justice presiding when a president is tried, and conviction needs two-thirds of senators present. Three presidents have been impeached: Andrew Johnson in 1868, Bill Clinton in 1998 and Donald Trump in 2019 and again in 2021. All four Senate trials ended in acquittal, Johnson's by a single vote. Richard Nixon resigned in 1974 before the full House voted.
Worked example: the Watergate succession
Trace how the succession rules worked in 1973-74. 1. In October 1973 Vice President Spiro Agnew resigned over a separate corruption scandal, leaving the vice presidency empty. 2. Under the new Twenty-Fifth Amendment, President Nixon nominated House minority leader Gerald Ford, and both chambers confirmed him. 3. As the Watergate cover-up came to light, the House Judiciary Committee approved articles of impeachment in July 1974. 4. Facing likely impeachment and removal, Nixon resigned in August 1974, and Ford became president. 5. Result: Ford is the only president elected to neither national office. 6. Lesson: an amendment written for vacancies settled an unplanned crisis.
Early presidents stretch the office
Washington built powers the text did not spell out. He gathered department heads into a cabinet, and in 1793 he proclaimed neutrality in the war between Britain and France without asking Congress. In 1796 he refused the House's request for papers on the Jay Treaty, an early form of what is now called executive privilege. Jefferson bought Louisiana in 1803 despite his own doubts that the Constitution allowed it. Monroe's 1823 message, later called the Monroe Doctrine, warned Europe against new colonies in the Americas. Andrew Jackson vetoed bills over policy disagreements, issuing 12 vetoes, more than all earlier presidents combined.
War and emergency powers
The biggest growth came in war. In 1846 James K. Polk sent troops into territory disputed with Mexico, and the clash that followed led Congress to declare war; a young congressman, Abraham Lincoln, criticised him. As president, Lincoln went much further. He enlarged the army and spent money before Congress met, suspended habeas corpus in some areas, and used his war powers to issue the Emancipation Proclamation in 1863. He argued that preserving the Union justified these steps. Historians still debate where necessity ended and overreach began, but later wartime presidents cited his precedents.
The modern presidency takes shape
Two readings of the vesting clause emerged in the early twentieth century. Theodore Roosevelt's stewardship theory held that a president may do anything the Constitution and laws do not forbid; William Howard Taft replied that a president needs a specific grant of power. Congress also handed the office new tools. The Budget and Accounting Act of 1921 made the president propose a single executive budget and created the Bureau of the Budget, renamed the Office of Management and Budget in 1970. The Depression, two world wars and the Cold War then put the president at the centre of national life.
Worked example: limits on inherent power
In 1952, during the Korean War, a steel strike threatened weapons production, and President Truman ordered the government to seize the mills. Analyse the Court's response in Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer. 1. No statute authorised the seizure, and Congress had earlier declined to grant such a power. 2. Truman relied on the vesting clause and his role as commander in chief. 3. The Court ruled against him, six votes to three. 4. Justice Robert Jackson's concurrence sorted presidential actions into three zones: strongest with Congress's authorisation, uncertain when Congress is silent, weakest against its will. 5. The seizure fell in the third zone. 6. Courts still use this framework.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, impeachment is not removal: the House impeaches, and only a two-thirds Senate vote removes, which has never happened to a president. Second, Nixon was never impeached; he resigned first. Third, the original Constitution set no term limit; the two-term rule came from custom and then the Twenty-Second Amendment. Fourth, the veto is in Article I, not Article II. Fifth, the vesting clause does not list inherent powers; whether it grants any is exactly what Roosevelt, Taft and the Youngstown justices argued about.
Key takeaways
The framers chose a single executive for energy and accountability, picked by electors for renewable four-year terms; the Twelfth Amendment (1804) separated the two electoral votes. A president must be a natural-born citizen, at least 35 and a 14-year resident; the Twenty-Second Amendment (1951) limits terms and the Twenty-Fifth (1967) governs succession. Article II lists military, pardon, treaty, appointment and law-enforcement powers. Johnson, Clinton and Trump were impeached and acquitted; Nixon resigned. Washington to Lincoln widened the office, the 1921 budget act and national crises enlarged it, and Youngstown (1952) marks its limits.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Hamilton's defence of a single, energetic executive
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why was the Twelfth Amendment adopted?
Question 2 of 5
What happens after the House of Representatives impeaches a president?
Question 3 of 5
How did Gerald Ford become president without winning a national election?
Question 4 of 5
In Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer (1952), why was Truman's seizure of the steel mills weakest under Justice Jackson's framework?
Question 5 of 5
Which statement best describes Theodore Roosevelt's stewardship theory?
