American Government › Section K · Congress › Topic K.5
The legislative process
Thousands of bills are introduced in each Congress, and only a few percent become law. The route from idea to statute has many points where a bill can stall, and in recent decades Congress has increasingly found ways around the textbook path.
Introduction and referral
Anyone can draft a bill: the president, an agency, an interest group or a think tank. But only a member of Congress can introduce one, so even a president's agenda needs sponsors in each chamber. Under Article I, Section 7, bills for raising revenue must start in the House, though the Senate may amend them. Once introduced, a bill is referred to the committee with jurisdiction over its subject. The Speaker in the House and the presiding officer in the Senate make referrals, normally following the advice of the parliamentarian, an expert on the chamber's rules. Large bills are often referred to several committees at once, a practice called multiple referral.
The committee stage
Committees are where most bills die, usually because the chair never takes them up. When a committee does act, it typically holds hearings, where officials, experts and interest groups testify, and then a markup, in which members debate, amend and vote on the text. A bill approved in markup is reported to the full chamber with a written report explaining it and estimating its cost. In the House, a majority of members, 218 when every seat is filled, can sign a discharge petition to force a bill out of a committee that refuses to act. Such petitions rarely succeed, but the threat of one can push leaders to act.
The House floor
Most major House bills reach the floor under a special rule written by the Rules Committee and approved by a floor vote. The rule sets how long debate lasts and which amendments may be offered: an open rule allows any relevant amendment, a structured rule allows only listed ones and a closed rule allows none. Because the Speaker controls the Rules Committee, the majority shapes outcomes before debate begins. Many less controversial bills instead pass under suspension of the rules, which limits debate to 40 minutes and bars amendments but needs a two-thirds vote. Otherwise, a bill passes the House with a simple majority of members voting.
The Senate floor and the filibuster
The Senate runs on looser rules and much of its business moves by unanimous consent, so one senator can slow things by objecting or by placing a hold. Debate is unlimited unless the Senate votes to end it, which allows a filibuster: prolonged debate or delay meant to block a vote. Since 1917, Rule XXII has allowed cloture to end debate, at first by two-thirds of those voting and, since 1975, by three-fifths of all senators, normally 60. Today a senator rarely needs to hold the floor; the threat alone means most legislation needs 60 votes. By majority votes in 2013 and 2017, the Senate cut cloture on all nominations to a simple majority.
Worked example: counting to cloture
A Senate has 52 members of the majority party and 48 of the minority, and the majority wants to pass an ordinary bill. 1. Passage itself needs a simple majority: 51 votes, or 50 plus the vice president's tie-breaking vote. 2. But the minority threatens to filibuster, so the bill first needs cloture. 3. Cloture needs three-fifths of 100, which is 60. 4. Shortfall: even with all 52 majority votes, 8 minority senators must join. 5. Alternative routes: negotiate changes to win those 8, or, if the bill concerns taxes and spending, use budget reconciliation, which cannot be filibustered. 6. Check: 52 + 8 = 60.
Making the two versions match
The Constitution requires both chambers to pass exactly the same text before it can go to the president. If the versions differ, one chamber may simply accept the other's version, or the chambers may send amendments back and forth, a practice nicknamed ping-pong. For difficult differences they can appoint a conference committee of members from both chambers, whose compromise report must then pass both houses without amendment. Conference committees were once the standard route for major bills, but in recent Congresses leaders have more often negotiated informally and then had one chamber pass the agreed text.
The president's choice
The president may sign a bill, making it law, or veto it by returning it to the chamber where it began, with objections. Congress can override a veto by a two-thirds vote of the members present in each chamber, which happens for fewer than one in ten regular vetoes. If the president does nothing for ten days, Sundays excepted, while Congress is in session, the bill becomes law without a signature. If Congress adjourns during those ten days and so prevents the bill's return, it dies: a pocket veto, which Congress cannot override.
Budgets, reconciliation and shutdowns
The Congressional Budget and Impoundment Control Act of 1974 created a yearly budget resolution and a fast-track process called reconciliation for bills that change taxes, spending or the debt limit. Reconciliation bills face limited debate and cannot be filibustered, but the Byrd rule bars provisions that do not mainly affect the budget. Parties have used it for major laws: the 2010 health-care follow-up bill, the 2017 tax law, the 2021 pandemic relief law, the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act and the 2025 tax and spending law. Separately, regular appropriations bills must pass by 1 October, the start of the fiscal year, or Congress needs a continuing resolution. Lapses cause shutdowns; the longest, 43 days, ran from 1 October to 12 November 2025.
Unorthodox lawmaking
The political scientist Barbara Sinclair used the term unorthodox lawmaking for the ways modern Congress departs from the textbook route. Leaders now often write major bills themselves, bypassing or overriding committees. Large omnibus bills package many measures, often several appropriations bills, into a single up-or-down vote. House special rules restrict amendments more tightly than in past decades, and Senate cloture votes have become routine. Supporters say these tools let a polarised Congress act at all; critics say they concentrate power in a few leaders.
Worked example: tracing one bill
Follow an imaginary bill to fund rural broadband. 1. A House member introduces it, and it is referred to the Energy and Commerce Committee. 2. A subcommittee holds hearings; the full committee marks it up and reports it. 3. The Rules Committee grants a structured rule allowing six amendments, and the House passes it 241 to 190. 4. In the Senate, the minority threatens a filibuster; after changes, cloture succeeds 64 to 36 and the bill passes 66 to 34. 5. The House accepts the Senate version, so no conference is needed. 6. The president signs it. Check: at each stage one actor could have stopped it.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking the Constitution requires 60 Senate votes; it requires a majority, and the 60-vote hurdle comes from the cloture rule. Second, believing the president can introduce bills; only members can. Third, confusing a pocket veto, which needs adjournment and cannot be overridden, with a bill becoming law unsigned while Congress sits. Fourth, assuming every bill goes to a conference committee; most differences are settled by one chamber accepting the other's text. Fifth, assuming reconciliation can carry any policy; the Byrd rule limits it to budgetary provisions.
Key takeaways
Only members introduce bills, and most die in committee. The Rules Committee sets terms of House debate. In the Senate, cloture needs 60 votes for most legislation, while nominations need only a majority since 2013 and 2017. Both chambers must pass identical text. The president signs or vetoes; overrides need two-thirds of each chamber, and pocket vetoes cannot be overridden. Reconciliation avoids the filibuster for budget bills, appropriations are due by 1 October, and modern lawmaking is often unorthodox.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Only a member of Congress can introduce a bill
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A Senate majority of 54 wants to pass an ordinary bill that the 46-member minority opposes and will filibuster. How many minority senators must join to invoke cloture?
Question 2 of 5
Congress passes a bill and then adjourns. The president neither signs nor returns it, and ten days pass. What happens?
Question 3 of 5
What does the House Rules Committee do for most major bills?
Question 4 of 5
Why can a budget reconciliation bill pass the Senate with only a simple majority?
Question 5 of 5
The House and Senate pass different versions of a bill. Which is now the most common way to settle the differences?
