American Government › Section I · Political parties › Topic I.4
Divided government and polarization
In 1950 leading political scientists complained that America's two parties were too alike to give voters a real choice. Today the complaint is the reverse: the parties are far apart, often share power uneasily, and their supporters increasingly distrust each other.
From too similar to too far apart
In 1950 a committee of the American Political Science Association published Toward a More Responsible Two-Party System. It argued that the parties were loose coalitions with overlapping views, so voters could not tell what each would do or whom to blame for results. It wanted distinct, disciplined parties that would offer clear programmes and carry them out. In the mid-twentieth century both parties did contain liberals and conservatives: many Southern Democrats were conservative, and many Northeastern Republicans were liberal or moderate. That overlap has since almost disappeared. This topic looks at two features of today's system, divided government and polarisation, and how they interact.
Divided and unified government
Unified government means one party holds the presidency and a majority in both chambers of Congress. Divided government means the president's opponents control at least one chamber. Since the late 1960s divided government has been common under presidents of both parties. Republican Ronald Reagan worked with a Democratic House throughout his presidency; Democrat Bill Clinton faced a Republican Congress from 1995; Barack Obama faced a Republican House from 2011; Donald Trump faced a Democratic House from 2019; and Joe Biden faced a Republican House from 2023. Republicans returned to unified control in 2025. Many voters split their tickets, and midterm elections often go against the president's party.
Costs and benefits of divided control
Divided government makes it harder for a president to keep campaign promises, because laws need agreement between branches the parties control separately. It can also blur accountability: when little gets done, each side blames the other. Supporters reply that divided control forces compromise and checks the excesses of either party, which suits the framers' design of separated powers. Evidence is mixed. In Divided We Govern, published in 1991, the political scientist David Mayhew found that major laws passed about as often under divided as under unified government between 1946 and 1990. Later scholars argue that rising polarisation has made divided control more likely to produce gridlock.
Shutdowns and standoffs
Each year Congress must pass appropriations bills, or a stopgap measure, to fund federal agencies. Since attorney general opinions of 1980 and 1981 interpreted the Antideficiency Act strictly, a lapse in funding forces agencies to halt non-essential work, a government shutdown. Shutdowns can happen under divided or unified control. A 35-day shutdown began in December 2018. The longest so far ran for 43 days, from 1 October to 12 November 2025, when Republicans controlled the White House and both chambers but needed some Democratic votes to overcome a Senate filibuster. Fights over raising the debt limit, as in 2011 and 2023, have also brought the country close to default.
What polarisation means
Party polarisation is the growing ideological distance between the parties. Scholars separate several kinds. Elite polarisation is the gap between officeholders: measures of congressional roll-call votes, such as the DW-NOMINATE scores developed by Keith Poole and Howard Rosenthal, show the two parties' members moving apart since the 1970s until almost no member of one party now votes to the ideological side of any member of the other. Partisan sorting means voters' ideology and party now line up more closely, so fewer conservatives are Democrats and fewer liberals are Republicans. Affective polarisation is the dislike and distrust partisans feel towards the other side.
Worked example: reading data on partisan dislike
Interpret Pew Research Center findings, from a survey taken from 27 June to 4 July 2022 and published that August. 1. The data: 62 percent of Republicans and 54 percent of Democrats had a very unfavourable view of the other party. 2. The comparison: in 1994, fewer than a quarter in either party felt that way. 3. The change: very negative views more than doubled in both parties over about 28 years. 4. Symmetry: the rise appears on both sides, so it is not one party's story. 5. Caution: unfavourable views of a party are not the same as hostility towards individual neighbours, and one survey is a snapshot. 6. Conclusion: affective polarisation grew sharply across the electorate.
Explaining polarisation: sorting and media
Scholars offer several explanations, and most think more than one is at work. The first is sorting. After the civil rights laws of the 1960s, conservative White Southerners gradually moved to the Republican Party, as the topic The two-party system described, while many liberal and moderate Republicans in the Northeast lost elections or became Democrats. Each party became more ideologically uniform. The second is media change. National television, then cable news, talk radio and social media, nationalised politics and let people choose sources that match their views; the section The media examines how strong those effects are. A third explanation points to primaries, where turnout is low and the most committed voters have the greatest say.
Explaining polarisation: district lines
A fourth explanation is gerrymandering, drawing district lines to favour a party or group. The name dates from 1812, when a Massachusetts district approved under Governor Elbridge Gerry was mocked for its salamander shape. Computer mapping now lets mapmakers draw lines with great precision. If a district is safe for one party, the real contest is the primary, so the member answers mainly to that party's most active voters. Both parties gerrymander where they control redistricting. Many scholars think its effect on polarisation is real but modest, for reasons the next card tests.
Worked example: testing the gerrymandering thesis
Ask whether district lines can explain most of the rise in polarisation. 1. Prediction: if gerrymandering is the main cause, chambers without drawn districts should polarise much less. 2. Test case: senators represent whole states, whose borders never change. 3. Evidence: roll-call measures show the Senate has polarised as well, though somewhat less than the House by some measures. 4. Second test: polarisation has also grown in the electorate itself, and many voters now live among like-minded neighbours, a process scholars call geographic sorting. 5. Conclusion: gerrymandering may add to polarisation in the House, but it cannot by itself explain the trend.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming divided government always means nothing passes: Mayhew found major laws passing at similar rates in both conditions before 1990. Second, thinking shutdowns happen only under divided government; the longest occurred under unified control. Third, blaming polarisation on one party alone; dislike of the other side has risen in both. Fourth, treating gerrymandering as the whole explanation when the Senate has polarised too. Fifth, confusing polarisation with competitive elections: distinct parties give voters clear choices, which the 1950 report wanted, even as they make compromise harder.
Key takeaways
In 1950 the APSA called for more distinct, disciplined parties; today the parties are highly distinct. Divided government, when the president's opponents control at least one chamber, has been common for decades and can bring gridlock or compromise, though Mayhew found it did not stop major laws before 1990. Shutdowns occur when funding lapses, and the longest, 43 days, ended in November 2025. Polarisation includes elite distance, partisan sorting and affective dislike; Pew found 62 percent of Republicans and 54 percent of Democrats very unfavourable to the other party in 2022. Likely causes include sorting, media change, primaries and, more modestly, gerrymandering.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Toward a More Responsible Two-Party System
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A Democratic president faces a Republican House and a Democratic Senate. How is this arrangement described?
Question 2 of 5
What did David Mayhew's Divided We Govern conclude about 1946 to 1990?
Question 3 of 5
A 2022 Pew survey found most Republicans and about half of Democrats had very unfavourable views of the other party. Which kind of polarisation does this measure?
Question 4 of 5
Why does the polarisation of the Senate weaken the claim that gerrymandering is the main cause of polarisation?
Question 5 of 5
Which statement about government shutdowns is accurate?
