American Government › Section J · Interest groups and lobbying › Topic J.1

What interest groups are

Farmers, teachers, gun owners, hospitals, cities and soft-drink makers all have people in Washington and the state capitals speaking for them. Interest groups are one of the main ways Americans, and the organisations they work for, carry their demands to government.

Madison's factions, organised

The Constitution never mentions interest groups, but the framers expected them. In Federalist No. 10, Madison argued that banning factions would destroy liberty, so the cure was to let many of them form and compete, making it hard for any one to dominate. That is roughly what happened. Estimates of the number of American interest groups vary widely, because nobody keeps a complete list. Whether so many groups spread power widely or let a well-funded few dominate is the debate between pluralists and elite theorists met in the topic Who governs? Elitism, pluralism, and tradeoffs. This section asks the narrower questions: what groups are, how they form and what they do.

What an interest group is

An interest group is an organised association of people or institutions that tries to influence public policy. It is also called a pressure group, an organised interest or, usually by critics, a special interest. Like parties, groups link citizens to government, but they do not run candidates under their own label or try to take over the government; the topic What parties are and how they formed draws that line. Groups also tend to be narrower. A major party must hold together a coalition spanning many issues, while a group can focus on one: taxes on small businesses, wilderness protection, or the rights of gun owners.

Lobbyists

Much group activity runs through lobbyists, people who represent an organisation before government and try to influence decisions. Under the federal Lobbying Disclosure Act of 1995, an organisation or lobbying firm generally must register and file regular reports, listing as lobbyists the paid staff who make more than one lobbying contact for a client and spend at least 20 percent of their time for that client on lobbying over three months. Each state sets its own definitions. An in-house lobbyist works for one organisation, such as a company's government affairs office. A contract lobbyist works for a lobbying firm that represents many clients. Volunteers sometimes lobby unpaid for causes they care about.

Membership groups and associations

Political scientists sort groups by who belongs. Membership groups are made up of individuals who join voluntarily, usually paying dues, such as the National Rifle Association, which promotes gun rights, and Brady: United Against Gun Violence, which campaigns for tighter gun laws. Labour unions represent workers in bargaining and politics. Professional associations, such as the American Medical Association, represent members of one occupation. Trade associations bring together firms in the same industry, such as the American Beverage Association, whose members compete for customers but share interests in taxes and regulation. Peak associations, such as the US Chamber of Commerce, speak for business across many industries.

Companies and governments as lobbies

Not every interest has individual members. Large corporations register to lobby on their own behalf, often while also belonging to a trade association. Governments lobby too. Cities, counties and states press Congress and federal agencies over grants and regulations, often through associations such as the National Governors Association and the National League of Cities. A public university usually employs a government relations officer, sometimes called a legislative liaison, to argue for its share of the state budget and for research funding. Foreign governments also hire American lobbyists, who must register separately under the Foreign Agents Registration Act of 1938.

Private and public interests

Groups can be sorted by what they seek. Private interest groups seek benefits that go mainly to their own members or industry, such as a tax break, a subsidy, a contract or a looser regulation. Public interest groups say they pursue collective goods that benefit most or all of society whether or not people join, such as clean air, safer cars or open government. In the language of the Microeconomics course, such goods are largely non-excludable and non-rival. The label is contested: an environmental group and a manufacturers' group may each claim that its preferred policy serves the public, and many groups mix private and public aims.

What groups do

Influencing policy is the main goal, but groups do more. They monitor government, tracking bills, regulations and court cases that could affect members and raising the alarm early. They inform, briefing lawmakers on technical details and explaining issues to members and the public. They offer a channel for participation, organising letter campaigns, rallies and volunteer work, as the topic Interest groups as political participation explores. And they pursue influence through two broad styles. Inside lobbying takes the message directly to officials, through meetings, testimony and help drafting bills. Outside lobbying works through the public, using media campaigns and members' calls to stir pressure from back home.

Worked example: classifying groups

Sort four organisations by type and aim. 1. A national association of independent pharmacies lobbies on drug pricing rules. Its members are businesses in one industry, so it is a trade association pursuing mainly private benefits. 2. A state's association of county governments asks the legislature for more road money. Its members are governments, so it is a government interest. 3. A group of 200,000 dues-paying hikers campaigns to protect trails on federal land. It is a membership group that describes its aim as a collective good. 4. A software company's own Washington office argues against a data-privacy rule. It is a corporation using in-house lobbyists for a private interest. 5. Check: type depends on who belongs; aim depends on who benefits.

Worked example: one bill, many roles

A state legislature considers a bill changing the rules for mail-in ballots. Trace what a voting-rights group and a group favouring stricter ballot rules each might do. 1. Monitor: both spot the bill when it is filed and analyse its effects. 2. Inform members: each emails supporters a plain-language summary, so members need not read the legal text. 3. Inside lobbying: each sends staff to meet committee members and offers testimony at the hearing. 4. Outside lobbying: each asks members to call their own legislators. 5. Conclusion: groups on opposite sides use the same functions, and lawmakers hear both, which is the competition Madison expected.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, confusing interest groups with parties: groups may endorse candidates but do not run them under their own label. Second, assuming every lobbyist is a hired gun for a corporation; unions, cities, universities, charities and volunteers lobby too. Third, treating public interest as a neutral fact rather than a group's claim about its goals. Fourth, thinking a citizen who phones a representative must register as a lobbyist; federal registration applies to people paid to lobby who meet the law's thresholds. Fifth, forgetting that groups monitor and inform, not only pressure.

Key takeaways

Interest groups are organised associations that try to influence policy without running candidates under their own label. Lobbyists, in-house or contract, represent them, and federal lobbyists who meet the thresholds of the Lobbying Disclosure Act of 1995 must register and report. Groups include membership organisations, unions, professional and trade associations, corporations and governments. Private interest groups seek benefits mainly for members; public interest groups claim to seek collective goods, a label that is often contested. Groups influence policy, monitor government, inform lawmakers and the public, and give members a way to participate, using inside and outside lobbying.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Interest group

An organised association that tries to influence public policy

Also called a pressure group or organised interest.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What most clearly makes an organisation an interest group rather than a political party?

Question 2 of 5

A lobbying firm in Washington represents a hospital chain, a car maker and a city government at the same time. Its lobbyists are best described as what?

Question 3 of 5

Several competing beverage companies join one organisation to lobby on taxes and labelling rules. What kind of group is this?

Question 4 of 5

Why is the label public interest group often contested?

Question 5 of 5

A group's staff testify at a committee hearing and meet the committee chair to suggest changes to a bill. Which approach is this?

← Previous topicNext topic →