American Government › Section E · Civil rights › Topic E.4

Civil rights for Native Americans, Alaskans, and Hawaiians

For most groups, civil rights means equal treatment as individuals. For Native nations it also means something no other group claims: the right to govern themselves as nations with their own lands, laws and courts.

Two kinds of claim

Native Americans, Alaska Natives and Native Hawaiians have sought the same equal rights as other citizens: to vote, to attend school and to be free of discrimination. But most of the 575 federally recognised tribes (as of 2026) also make a second claim, to sovereignty, the right of a nation to govern itself. The Constitution recognises this status: the commerce clause lets Congress regulate commerce "with the Indian Tribes" alongside foreign nations and the states. So many Native civil rights questions are about who governs, not only about equal treatment.

Nations within a nation

In the 1820s and 1830s the Supreme Court defined tribes' legal position. In Cherokee Nation v. Georgia (1831), Chief Justice John Marshall called tribes "domestic dependent nations", not foreign states, so the Court could not hear the Cherokee suit. In Worcester v. Georgia (1832), he held that Georgia's laws had no force inside Cherokee territory, because relations with tribes belonged to the federal government. The US History topic "Indian Removal" explains why that victory went unenforced. These cases still underpin federal Indian law: tribes keep inherent powers of self-government, states generally lack authority inside reservations, and Congress holds broad, though not unlimited, power over tribal affairs.

Citizenship and the vote

Because tribes were treated as separate nations, Native people were long excluded from US citizenship. In Elk v. Wilkins (1884), the Court held that the Fourteenth Amendment did not make John Elk, born into a tribe, a citizen. The Dawes Act (1887) granted citizenship to those who accepted individual allotments, and the Indian Citizenship Act of 1924 made all Native people born in the United States citizens. States still kept many from voting, claiming that reservation residents were not state residents or were under federal guardianship. Arizona and New Mexico courts struck down such bars in 1948, and Utah, the last state, ended its exclusion in 1957.

Policy swings: assimilation to self-determination

Federal policy has lurched between destroying tribes and restoring them. Allotment and boarding schools, covered in "The assault on American Indian life and culture", aimed at assimilation. The Indian Reorganization Act of 1934 ended allotment and encouraged tribes to adopt constitutions and elected governments. In the 1950s Congress turned to termination, ending federal recognition of more than 100 tribes, and to relocation, which paid Native families to move to cities. In 1970 President Richard Nixon asked Congress to reject termination in favour of self-determination, and the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act of 1975 let tribes run federally funded programmes, such as schools and health clinics, themselves.

Worked example: the effects of termination

Trace the consequences of terminating the Menominee of Wisconsin, a policy enacted in 1954 and carried out in 1961. 1. Goal: Congress said termination would free Native people from federal supervision and make them equal citizens. 2. Change: federal recognition, services and the reservation's protected status ended; the reservation became a county. 3. Effect: the new county had a small tax base, the tribal hospital closed, and some land was sold to pay taxes. 4. Response: Menominee activists, led by Ada Deer, campaigned for restoration. 5. Outcome: Congress restored federal recognition in 1973. 6. Conclusion: treating tribes simply as individuals to be assimilated weakened both their self-government and their members' welfare.

Red Power and the Indian Civil Rights Act

A pan-Indian Red Power movement grew in the 1960s. Its protests, from the occupation of Alcatraz (1969 to 1971) to the 71-day siege at Wounded Knee in 1973, are covered in the US History topic "Rights movements and a divided society". A less visible change mattered too. The Bill of Rights restrains federal and state governments but not tribal governments, which predate the Constitution. The Indian Civil Rights Act of 1968 applied most of its protections, such as free speech and due process, to tribes by statute, while respecting tribal courts as the main place to enforce them.

Laws of the self-determination era

Congress passed a series of protective laws. The Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 responded to the removal of many Native children into non-Native homes; it prefers placement with extended family or the child's tribe and gives tribal courts a strong role. The American Indian Religious Freedom Act of 1978 declared a policy of protecting traditional religions, and a 1994 amendment protected the religious use of peyote. After California v. Cabazon Band (1987) limited state power over reservation gaming, the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act of 1988 set rules under which tribes negotiate compacts with states to run casinos.

Recent Supreme Court rulings

In McGirt v. Oklahoma (9 July 2020), the Court ruled 5 to 4, in an opinion by Justice Neil Gorsuch, that Congress had never disestablished the Muscogee (Creek) reservation, so much of eastern Oklahoma remains Indian country for federal criminal law. In Oklahoma v. Castro-Huerta (29 June 2022), it held that states share jurisdiction with the federal government over crimes committed by non-Native people against Native victims there. In Haaland v. Brackeen (15 June 2023), the Court voted 7 to 2, in an opinion by Justice Amy Coney Barrett, to uphold the Indian Child Welfare Act against claims that it exceeded Congress's power.

Worked example: who prosecutes the crime?

A crime occurs in Tulsa, inside the Muscogee (Creek) reservation recognised in McGirt. Work out which government can prosecute. 1. Location: the reservation counts as Indian country, so state power is limited. 2. A Native defendant commits a major crime such as murder: under the Major Crimes Act the federal government prosecutes, and the tribe may also act; the state may not, which was McGirt's holding. 3. A non-Native defendant harms a Native victim: after Castro-Huerta, both the federal government and the state may prosecute. 4. A non-Native defendant harms a non-Native victim: the state prosecutes. 5. Check: the answer depends on place, defendant and victim together.

Alaska Natives and Native Hawaiians

Alaska Natives settled their land claims in the Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act of 1971, passed as oil development began. They received about 44 million acres and nearly $1 billion, managed through Native-owned regional and village corporations rather than reservations. Native Hawaiians lost their kingdom when American businessmen, backed by US Marines, overthrew Queen Liliuokalani in 1893; the United States annexed Hawaii in 1898. In 1993 Congress formally apologised for the overthrow. Native Hawaiians have no recognised tribal government, and in Rice v. Cayetano (2000) the Court struck down a Hawaiian-only election for a state agency under the Fifteenth Amendment. Native Hawaiians remain divided over whether to seek federal recognition.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating Native rights only as equal-treatment claims; sovereignty and self-government are central. Second, saying Cherokee Nation v. Georgia called tribes foreign nations; Marshall called them domestic dependent nations. Third, dating Native citizenship to 1940 or later; the Indian Citizenship Act of 1924 covered all Native people born in the United States, though some states blocked voting until 1957. Fourth, assuming the Bill of Rights binds tribal governments directly; the Indian Civil Rights Act of 1968 applied most protections by statute. Fifth, overstating McGirt: it concerned criminal jurisdiction, and Oklahoma kept power over many cases.

Key takeaways

Native nations seek equal rights and sovereignty. The Marshall cases made tribes domestic dependent nations under federal, not state, authority. Elk v. Wilkins (1884) denied birthright citizenship; the Indian Citizenship Act (1924) granted it, and the last state voting bar fell in 1957. Policy swung from allotment to the Indian Reorganization Act (1934), termination in the 1950s and self-determination from 1975. Key laws include the Indian Civil Rights Act (1968), ICWA (1978) and IGRA (1988). McGirt (2020), Castro-Huerta (2022) and Brackeen (2023) are recent landmarks. Alaska Natives took a corporate settlement in 1971; Native Hawaiians lack a recognised government.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Tribal sovereignty

A tribe's inherent right to govern itself

A claim no other American group makes.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

In Cherokee Nation v. Georgia (1831), how did Chief Justice Marshall describe Native tribes?

Question 2 of 5

Which law made all Native people born in the United States citizens?

Question 3 of 5

Why did Congress pass the Indian Civil Rights Act of 1968?

Question 4 of 5

After McGirt (2020) and Castro-Huerta (2022), who may prosecute a non-Native person for a crime against a Native victim on the Muscogee (Creek) reservation?

Question 5 of 5

What did the termination policy of the 1950s do?

← Previous topicNext topic →