American Government › Section E · Civil rights › Topic E.3

The fight for women's rights

Women were citizens from the start yet could not vote, serve on many juries or keep their own wages. How they won rights through amendments, statutes and court rulings, and why the Equal Rights Amendment stalled, shows every route to change the system offers.

Citizens without equal rights

At the founding, women counted as citizens but held few political or legal rights. Under coverture, a married woman's legal identity merged with her husband's: he controlled her property and her wages. Only New Jersey let some women vote, and it ended that practice in 1807. The US History topic "Early women's rights" covers the reform movements of the 1830s and 1840s and the Seneca Falls Convention of 1848. This topic follows the institutional fight that followed: for the vote, for equal treatment in law and work, and for a constitutional amendment that has never been formally added.

Two routes to the vote

After the Fifteenth Amendment (1870) enfranchised Black men but not women, the movement split in 1869. Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony's National Woman Suffrage Association sought a federal amendment; Lucy Stone's American Woman Suffrage Association worked state by state. The courts offered no shortcut. In Minor v. Happersett (1875), the Supreme Court ruled unanimously that citizenship did not carry a right to vote, so states could exclude women. Western territories and states moved first: Wyoming Territory granted women the vote in 1869 and kept it at statehood in 1890. The two associations merged in 1890 as the National American Woman Suffrage Association.

The Nineteenth Amendment

In the 1910s two strategies ran side by side. NAWSA, led by Carrie Chapman Catt, lobbied politicians and built state victories. Alice Paul's National Woman's Party picketed the White House from 1917; many pickets were jailed, and some hunger strikers were force-fed. Women's wartime work strengthened their case. Congress sent the Nineteenth Amendment to the states in June 1919, and Tennessee became the thirty-sixth state to ratify it in August 1920, after a narrow vote in its House. The amendment bars denial of the vote "on account of sex". Like the Fifteenth, it opened the polls in law, but many Black women in the South remained shut out by the same tests and taxes used against Black men.

Worked example: why the federal route won

Analyse why the suffrage campaign finally succeeded through a constitutional amendment. 1. The state route was slow: by 1910 only a handful of states, all in the West, allowed women full voting rights. 2. The court route was closed: Minor (1875) held that the Constitution did not guarantee women the vote. 3. State gains still mattered: each new suffrage state added voters whom members of Congress from that state could not ignore. 4. Pressure built from two sides: NAWSA's lobbying made the amendment respectable, while the NWP's protests kept it in the news. 5. Conclusion: state victories created the votes in Congress and the legislatures that the federal amendment needed.

After the vote

The vote did not end legal inequality. Many states kept women off juries; in Hoyt v. Florida (1961) the Court upheld a law placing women on jury lists only if they volunteered, before reversing course in Taylor v. Louisiana (1975). Employers routinely paid women less or refused to hire them. Congress acted in the 1960s and 1970s. The Equal Pay Act of 1963 required equal pay for equal work. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 banned employment discrimination by sex. Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 barred sex discrimination in federally funded education, including sport. The Pregnancy Discrimination Act of 1978 made pregnancy discrimination a form of sex discrimination.

The courts change the standard

Until 1971 the Supreme Court upheld almost every law that treated the sexes differently. In Reed v. Reed (1971), it struck down an Idaho law preferring men over women as administrators of estates, the first time it used the equal protection clause to invalidate a sex classification; Ruth Bader Ginsburg co-wrote the winning brief. Craig v. Boren (1976) then set intermediate scrutiny, and United States v. Virginia (1996) required an "exceedingly persuasive justification", as "What are civil rights?" explains. Some differences still survive review: in Rostker v. Goldberg (1981) the Court upheld requiring only men to register for the draft. Abortion and contraception rulings are covered in "Interpreting the Bill of Rights, including privacy".

The Equal Rights Amendment

Alice Paul drafted an Equal Rights Amendment, first introduced in Congress in 1923. Its modern text says equality of rights "shall not be denied or abridged" on account of sex. Congress finally passed it in 1972 with a seven-year ratification deadline, later extended to 30 June 1982. Thirty-five states ratified, three short of the thirty-eight needed, and several later voted to rescind. Opponents, led by the conservative activist Phyllis Schlafly, argued it could subject women to the draft and remove legal protections such as alimony; supporters argued it would lock equality into the Constitution rather than leave it to judges and statutes.

Worked example: is the ERA in the Constitution?

Weigh the legal dispute. 1. Count: Nevada (2017), Illinois (2018) and Virginia (2020) ratified, giving supporters a claimed total of thirty-eight. 2. Timing: all three came decades after the 1982 deadline set by Congress. 3. Rescissions: several states had voted to withdraw ratification, and Article V does not say whether that is allowed. 4. Officials: in 2020 the Justice Department's lawyers advised that the deadline had expired, and the national archivist, who certifies amendments, has not certified it. 5. Politics: in January 2025 President Joe Biden declared the ERA the Twenty-eighth Amendment, but the statement brought no formal recognition. 6. Conclusion: under current official practice the ERA is not part of the Constitution.

Continuing debates

Women now earn most college degrees and serve at every level of government, but gaps remain. Federal labour statistics for 2024 put women's median weekly earnings for full-time work at about 83 percent of men's. Economists debate how much of that gap reflects occupation and hours and how much reflects discrimination. Supporters of comparable worth argue that jobs requiring similar skill and responsibility should be paid alike even when they differ; critics say markets, not officials, should set wages. Congress has also responded to the Court: after Ledbetter v. Goodyear (2007) limited the time for pay claims, the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act of 2009 extended it. The glass ceiling, an invisible barrier to top positions, remains a common term in these debates.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking the Constitution always let women vote, or that the Fourteenth Amendment did; Minor (1875) said it did not. Second, believing the Nineteenth Amendment gave every woman the vote in practice; many Black women were still excluded until the 1960s. Third, confusing the ERA with Title IX: Title IX is a 1972 statute, the ERA a proposed amendment. Fourth, saying sex classifications get strict scrutiny; they get intermediate scrutiny. Fifth, stating that the ERA is now in force; it has not been certified.

Key takeaways

Coverture denied married women a separate legal identity. After Minor v. Happersett (1875), suffragists pursued both state victories and a federal amendment, won in 1920 with the Nineteenth Amendment. Statutes then did much of the work: the Equal Pay Act (1963), Title VII (1964), Title IX (1972) and the Pregnancy Discrimination Act (1978). Reed v. Reed (1971) began heightened review of sex discrimination, leading to intermediate scrutiny. The ERA passed Congress in 1972 but fell three states short by 1982; later ratifications have not been certified. Pay and representation gaps are still debated.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Coverture

A married woman's legal identity merged into her husband's

He controlled her property and wages.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did the Supreme Court decide in Minor v. Happersett (1875)?

Question 2 of 5

Which of these is a federal statute rather than a constitutional amendment?

Question 3 of 5

Why is the Equal Rights Amendment not counted as part of the Constitution today?

Question 4 of 5

Reed v. Reed (1971) is significant because it was the first time the Supreme Court did what?

Question 5 of 5

Which argument did ERA opponents such as Phyllis Schlafly make?

← Previous topicNext topic →