American Government › Section D · Civil liberties › Topic D.4
Interpreting the Bill of Rights, including privacy
The Bill of Rights never uses the word "privacy", yet privacy has become one of its most fought-over ideas. How judges read the Ninth and Tenth Amendments, and how they find rights the text does not name, shapes debates from contraception and abortion to phone tracking.
Reading an old text in a new world
The Bill of Rights was written in 1789 for a country of farms, muskets and handwritten letters; judges now apply it to smartphones and drones. Two broad approaches compete. Originalists hold that the words should carry the meaning they had when adopted, so that changing that meaning is a job for the amendment process. Supporters of a living Constitution hold that broad principles such as "liberty" and "unreasonable" must be applied to new conditions. Originalists say their method stops judges imposing their own values; critics reply that original meaning is often unclear or ill-suited to modern problems. Many judges draw on both, and the balance between them often decides hard cases, especially about rights the text does not name.
The Ninth Amendment
The Ninth Amendment answers Hamilton's worry, described in the topic "What are civil liberties?", that listing rights might endanger unlisted ones. It says the listing of certain rights "shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people." Americans exercise many unnamed rights, such as travelling between states and raising children. Judges disagree about the amendment's force. Some read it as inviting courts to protect unlisted natural and common-law rights. Others see it only as a rule of interpretation, leaving new rights to be secured by legislatures or by amendment, as voting rights were through the Fifteenth and Nineteenth Amendments.
The Tenth Amendment and state constitutions
The Tenth Amendment concerns power rather than rights. Justice Harlan Fiske Stone called it a "truism" in United States v. Darby (1941): the states keep what they did not give up. Yet it still matters for liberty, because state constitutions may protect rights more generously than the federal one. Several state constitutions expressly protect privacy, and many guarantee public education. In PruneYard Shopping Center v. Robins (1980) the Supreme Court let California protect leafleting in privately owned shopping centres under its own constitution. The protection runs only one way: states may add rights, but they cannot override valid federal law or federal constitutional limits.
Where privacy comes from
In 1890 the lawyers Samuel Warren and Louis Brandeis published an influential article arguing for a legal "right to be let alone." Several amendments seem to guard pieces of that idea: the Third keeps soldiers out of homes, the Fourth bars unreasonable searches, the Fifth protects against forced self-incrimination, and the Ninth preserves unlisted rights. In Griswold v. Connecticut (1965) the Supreme Court struck down a ban on contraceptives for married couples, with Justice William O. Douglas finding a zone of privacy formed by these guarantees together. Eisenstadt v. Baird (1972) extended the contraception right to unmarried people. Later cases grounded such rights in the "liberty" protected by the due process clause.
Abortion: Roe and Casey
In Roe v. Wade (1973) the Court held that the right of privacy covers a decision to end a pregnancy, balancing it against the state's interests in maternal health and potential life. It set a trimester framework that barred most restrictions early in pregnancy and allowed bans after viability, the point at which a fetus could survive outside the womb, except to protect the woman's life or health. In Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992) the Court kept Roe's core holding but replaced the trimesters with the undue burden test: before viability, states could regulate abortion unless a law placed a substantial obstacle in the path of a woman seeking one. Casey upheld a waiting period and parental consent but struck down spousal notification.
Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022)
Mississippi banned most abortions after 15 weeks, before viability. In Dobbs (2022) the Court upheld the law by six votes to three, and five justices joined Justice Samuel Alito's opinion overruling Roe and Casey. The majority held that the Constitution does not confer a right to abortion, because such a right is not mentioned in the text and is not "deeply rooted in this Nation's history and tradition", and returned the issue to the people and their elected representatives. It said the ruling did not cast doubt on other precedents. The three dissenting justices argued that it stripped women of a long-recognised liberty and endangered related rights.
Worked example: two ways to read "liberty"
Compare how Roe and Dobbs reasoned about the same clause. 1. Text: the Fourteenth Amendment protects "liberty" against deprivation without due process of law. 2. Roe's approach: liberty includes a right of personal privacy, drawn from earlier cases such as Griswold, broad enough to cover the abortion decision. 3. Dobbs's approach: an unlisted right counts only if it is deeply rooted in history and tradition; the majority found that most states made abortion a crime when the amendment was adopted in 1868, so it fails; the dissent disputed that reading of history. 4. Consequence of Roe: one national rule limiting state laws. 5. Consequence of Dobbs: each state decides through ordinary politics. 6. Lesson: the method of interpretation chosen largely decides the outcome.
Privacy in intimate life
In Bowers v. Hardwick (1986) the Court upheld a Georgia law criminalising sodomy. In Lawrence v. Texas (2003) it overruled Bowers, holding that the due process clause protects consensual intimate conduct between adults in private. That reasoning fed into Obergefell v. Hodges (2015) on marriage. The liberty is not unlimited: states may still regulate obscenity, prostitution and polygamy. After Dobbs, one concurring justice urged the Court to reconsider rulings such as Griswold, Lawrence and Obergefell, while the majority opinion said nothing in it should be read that way.
Worked example: state responses after Dobbs
Trace how one ruling produced different state results. 1. Dobbs removed the federal constitutional floor, so state law now decides. 2. Some legislatures enacted bans or tight limits, some of which had been written earlier to take effect if Roe fell. 3. Other states passed laws protecting access. 4. Voters joined in: in August 2022 Kansas voters rejected, by about 59% to 41%, an amendment stating that the state constitution does not protect abortion. 5. Check: this is the Tenth Amendment pattern, with states free to protect more or less, within federal law.
Privacy from surveillance
Privacy has a second sense: freedom from being watched. Licence-plate cameras, facial recognition, phone location data and drones make tracking far easier than ever before. The USA PATRIOT Act, passed weeks after the 11 September 2001 attacks, widened federal surveillance powers; supporters said it helped prevent terrorism, while civil liberties groups argued it made warrants too easy to obtain. Courts have begun to respond, as the warrant rulings on GPS trackers and phone location records in the topic "The rights of suspects" show, but much of this area is governed by statutes, not settled constitutional law.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, the word "privacy" does not appear in the Constitution; the right was inferred, starting with Griswold (1965). Second, Casey did not overrule Roe; it replaced the trimester framework with the undue burden test, and Dobbs later overruled both. Third, Dobbs did not ban abortion nationwide; it left the question to elected officials, chiefly in the states. Fourth, the Ninth Amendment does not list the extra rights it protects; it only warns against treating the list as complete.
Key takeaways
Originalist and living-Constitution approaches compete when judges read old words in new settings. The Ninth Amendment says listed rights are not the only ones; the Tenth reserves power and lets states protect rights more fully. Privacy grew from Warren and Brandeis's 1890 article into Griswold (1965) and Eisenstadt (1972). Roe (1973) and Casey (1992) protected abortion until Dobbs (2022) held that the Constitution confers no such right and returned the issue to elected officials. Lawrence (2003) protected intimate conduct. Surveillance technology now poses privacy questions the courts and Congress are still answering.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Reading the Constitution by its meaning when adopted
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What does the Ninth Amendment say?
Question 2 of 5
In Griswold v. Connecticut (1965), what did the Court do?
Question 3 of 5
What did Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992) change?
Question 4 of 5
What standard did the Dobbs majority (2022) apply to a right not named in the Constitution?
Question 5 of 5
A state supreme court rules that its own constitution protects a right more broadly than the US Constitution does. Is this allowed?
