American Government › Section E · Civil rights › Topic E.1

What are civil rights?

Every law sorts people into groups, by age, income, licence or residence. Civil rights law asks which of those lines are fair, and courts have built a three-level test to answer that question.

Equal treatment under law

Civil rights are guarantees that government will treat people equally, especially members of groups that have historically been denied the rights and opportunities others enjoyed. The topic "What are civil liberties?" drew the contrast: a liberty limits what government may do to anyone, while a right to equal treatment asks whether some people are handled differently from others. Not every difference is unjust. A ten-year-old may not vote or drive, and nobody calls that discrimination in the legal sense. The hard questions are which differences need a strong justification, who must supply it, and what happens when the justification fails.

Where the guarantees come from

The Fourteenth Amendment, ratified in 1868, says no state shall "deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws." That clause binds the states. The original Bill of Rights contains no equality clause, so in Bolling v. Sharpe (1954), decided the same day as Brown v. Board of Education, the Supreme Court held that the Fifth Amendment's due process clause forbids the federal government to segregate the public schools of Washington, DC. Today the same equal protection standards apply to both levels of government. The Thirteenth Amendment (1865) ended slavery, and the Fifteenth (1870) barred racial discrimination in voting.

Government action and private conduct

The equal protection clause restrains governments, not private individuals. In the Civil Rights Cases (1883) the Court struck down the Civil Rights Act of 1875, which had banned racial discrimination in inns, theatres and public transport, holding that the Fourteenth Amendment reached only state action. Congress found another route. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 rests its ban on discrimination in hotels and restaurants mainly on the power to regulate interstate commerce, and the Court upheld it on that basis in Heart of Atlanta Motel v. United States (1964). So civil rights today come from two sources: the Constitution, which limits governments, and statutes, which can also bind employers, landlords and businesses.

Rational basis review

Most classifications get the mildest test. Under rational basis review a law is upheld if it is rationally related to a legitimate government interest, and the burden falls on the person challenging it to show that no sensible reason exists. A minimum driving age, a vision test for a licence or a grade requirement at a public university all pass easily: each treats some people differently, but for a plausible reason connected to safety or academic readiness. Classifications by age, income, disability and most economic categories are judged this way. Laws rarely fail this test, though the Court has occasionally struck down measures it found to rest only on hostility towards a group.

Intermediate scrutiny for sex

Laws that treat men and women differently get a tougher test, first set out in Craig v. Boren (1976). Oklahoma allowed women to buy low-alcohol beer at 18 but made men wait until 21; the Court struck the law down. Under intermediate scrutiny the government must show that the classification serves an important governmental objective and is substantially related to it. In United States v. Virginia (1996), the Court applied this test to the all-male Virginia Military Institute, requiring an "exceedingly persuasive justification" for excluding women, which the state could not supply. The burden of proof now rests on the government, not on the person claiming discrimination.

Strict scrutiny for race

Classifications by race or national origin are treated as "suspect" and get strict scrutiny, the hardest test. The government must prove that the law serves a compelling interest and is narrowly tailored to achieve it, meaning no less discriminatory means would work. The phrase traces to Korematsu v. United States (1944), where the Court said racial restrictions deserve "the most rigid scrutiny" yet still upheld the wartime removal of Japanese Americans, a decision later repudiated, as "What are civil liberties?" explains. Since the 1960s very few racial classifications have survived. In Loving v. Virginia (1967), for example, a ban on interracial marriage failed completely.

Purpose, not just effect

A law can be neutral on its face yet affect groups unequally. In Washington v. Davis (1976), applicants challenged a police verbal-skills test that Black candidates failed at higher rates. The Court held that the equal protection clause is violated only by discriminatory purpose; unequal impact alone is not enough, though it can be evidence of intent. Statutes can go further. In Griggs v. Duke Power Co. (1971), the Court read Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 to bar employment tests that screen out a group disproportionately unless they are related to the job. Whether a claim is constitutional or statutory therefore changes what must be proved.

Worked example: choosing the level of scrutiny

Decide which test a court would apply. 1. A state requires drivers over 80 to renew their licences every two years instead of every eight. The line is age, so rational basis applies; road safety is a legitimate interest and the law is very likely upheld. 2. A city fire department hires only men as firefighters. The line is sex, so intermediate scrutiny applies; the city must show an important objective substantially served by excluding all women, and a physical fitness test open to everyone would serve safety better. 3. A county assigns jurors by race. The line is race, so strict scrutiny applies, and no compelling interest is served. 4. Check: identify the line drawn first, then the test follows.

Worked example: spotting a civil rights issue

New claims emerge over time, so a simple method helps. Take voters who use wheelchairs and find their polling place up a flight of stairs. 1. Which group? People with mobility impairments. 2. Which right is threatened? The right to vote on equal terms with others. 3. What can government do? Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (1990) requires state and local governments to make their services accessible, so election officials can move the polling place or provide ramps. 4. Is the remedy realistic? Yes: it is cheap and targeted. Compare a proposal to let 16-year-olds vote. Age is reviewed only for a rational basis, so the case for change must be won politically, not in court.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming every unequal treatment is unconstitutional; most classifications pass rational basis review. Second, thinking the equal protection clause reaches private businesses; it limits governments, and statutes such as the Civil Rights Act of 1964 cover private conduct. Third, mixing up the tests: strict scrutiny for race and national origin, intermediate for sex, rational basis for most others. Fourth, forgetting who carries the burden: the challenger under rational basis, the government under the two higher tiers. Fifth, treating unequal effects as proof of unconstitutional discrimination; under Washington v. Davis the Constitution requires discriminatory purpose.

Key takeaways

Civil rights guarantee equal treatment, especially for groups historically excluded. The Fourteenth Amendment binds the states, and Bolling v. Sharpe (1954) applied equal protection to the federal government through the Fifth Amendment. The Constitution limits government action; statutes resting on the commerce power reach private businesses. Courts use three tiers: rational basis for most lines, intermediate scrutiny for sex since Craig v. Boren (1976), and strict scrutiny for race and national origin. Constitutional claims require discriminatory purpose, while some statutes reach disparate impact. To spot a civil rights issue, ask which group, which right and what remedy.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Civil rights

Guarantees that government will treat people equally

Especially groups historically denied equal treatment.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A state law sets a higher minimum age for men than for women to buy alcohol. Which test does a court apply?

Question 2 of 5

Why could the Civil Rights Act of 1964 ban discrimination by private restaurants and hotels?

Question 3 of 5

Under rational basis review, who must show that a classification is unjustified?

Question 4 of 5

What did Washington v. Davis (1976) hold about equal protection claims?

Question 5 of 5

How did the Supreme Court apply equal protection to the federal government in Bolling v. Sharpe (1954)?

← Previous topicNext topic →