American Government › Section L · The presidency › Topic L.3
Organizing to govern
Winning the election is only the start. In about eleven weeks a president-elect must take over a vast government, choose thousands of officials and decide which promises to tackle first, and the choices made in those early months often shape the whole term.
The transition
Between election day and inauguration on 20 January, the outgoing and incoming teams prepare a peaceful handover. Under the Presidential Transition Act of 1963 and later amendments, the General Services Administration provides the president-elect's team with offices, money and equipment, and outgoing agencies brief the newcomers. Serious candidates now name transition teams months before the election, so that they can move quickly if they win. The aim is continuity: on inauguration day, one set of senior officials leaves and another arrives, while the career civil servants who run most programmes stay in place.
Building a cabinet
Washington's cabinet had four members: the secretaries of State, War and the Treasury, and the attorney general. Today the cabinet includes the heads of 15 executive departments, the newest being Homeland Security, created in 2002, plus other officials each president chooses to give cabinet rank, such as the White House chief of staff. The heads of State, Treasury, Defense and Justice, echoing Washington's original four, are often called the inner cabinet because they get the most attention. Presidents weigh expertise, loyalty, political influence and reputation, and many also seek a cabinet that reflects the country's diversity of background and region.
Senate confirmation
Article II requires the Senate's "Advice and Consent" for cabinet secretaries, ambassadors, federal judges and other senior officers; about 1,200 to 1,300 civilian posts now need it. Most nominees are confirmed, but not all. In 1989 the Senate rejected John Tower as defense secretary, and in 1993 Zoe Baird withdrew as attorney general nominee after it emerged that she had employed undocumented workers. Many failed nominations now end quietly, through delay or withdrawal, rather than in a recorded defeat.
The changing rules of confirmation
Until 2013, a determined minority could filibuster a nominee, blocking a final vote unless 60 senators agreed to end debate. In 2013 the Democratic majority changed the rules so that a simple majority could end debate on executive nominees and lower-court judges. In 2017 the Republican majority extended this to Supreme Court nominees, a move nicknamed the nuclear option, to confirm Neil Gorsuch. As a result, a president whose party holds the Senate can usually confirm nominees without votes from the other side, while a president facing an opposition Senate may see nominees stalled. Federal judges serve during good behaviour, so judicial vacancies arise only gradually.
Worked example: two Supreme Court vacancies
Compare the Senate's handling of two election-year vacancies, a frequent topic of partisan argument. 1. In February 2016 Justice Antonin Scalia died. President Obama nominated Judge Merrick Garland in March. 2. The Republican Senate majority held no hearing, arguing that voters in the coming election should decide. 3. After the 2016 election, the Senate confirmed President Trump's nominee, Gorsuch, in April 2017. 4. In September 2020 Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg died. The same majority confirmed Amy Coney Barrett about a week before the election. 5. Republican leaders said the cases differed because in 2020 the president and Senate majority were of the same party; Democrats called the positions inconsistent. 6. Lesson: the Constitution sets no timetable, so Senate control decides.
Recess appointments
Article II lets the president fill vacancies "that may happen during the Recess of the Senate" with temporary commissions lasting to the end of the Senate's next session. Intended for long breaks when the Senate could not meet, it became a way around a Senate that refused to act: Presidents Clinton and George W. Bush each made well over a hundred recess appointments. The Senate answered with pro forma sessions, brief meetings every few days that keep it formally in session. The two sides' tactics collided in a 2014 case about appointments made during such a break.
Worked example: NLRB v. Noel Canning (2014)
Analyse the case step by step. 1. In January 2012, President Obama made recess appointments to the National Labor Relations Board while the Senate was holding pro forma sessions. 2. A company that lost a case before the board argued that the appointments were invalid, so the board's ruling was too. 3. The Supreme Court agreed unanimously. 4. The majority held that the Senate is in session when it says it is, as long as it can conduct business under its own rules. 5. It added that a break of fewer than ten days is presumptively too short to count as a recess. 6. Result: pro forma sessions can block recess appointments, so presidents now depend more heavily on Senate confirmation.
The Executive Office and the White House staff
In 1937 an advisory committee told Franklin Roosevelt that "the President needs help," and in 1939 Congress allowed him to create the Executive Office of the President (EOP). It now includes the White House Office, led by the chief of staff; the Office of Management and Budget, which prepares the budget and reviews agency regulations; the National Security Council, created in 1947; and the Council of Economic Advisers. White House staff, such as the chief of staff and the national security adviser, need no Senate approval and serve at the president's pleasure. Lincoln had a handful of secretaries; the White House Office now employs several hundred people.
The vice president's growing role
For most of the nineteenth century the vice presidency was a political backwater; in 1900 New York party bosses backed Theodore Roosevelt for it partly to sideline him, only for McKinley's assassination in 1901 to make him president. Starting with Walter Mondale under Jimmy Carter, vice presidents gained a West Wing office, regular private meetings with the president and major assignments. Dick Cheney under George W. Bush was widely seen as unusually influential; Joe Biden advised Barack Obama on foreign policy; Mike Pence led the COVID-19 task force. Vice President JD Vance, in office since January 2025, also takes part in many senior meetings. Influence still depends on the president's choice.
Forging an agenda
New presidents enjoy a honeymoon period, when public approval and goodwill from the press and Congress are usually at their highest. Since Franklin Roosevelt's burst of legislation in 1933, the first hundred days have been treated as an early test. Most presidents try to pass their biggest priorities in the first two years, before midterm elections often cost their party seats. They inherit the outgoing president's budget, so new spending plans take time. The inaugural address sets the tone, and the political scientist Stephen Skowronek argues that "political time", whether a president arrives as the old order collapses or while it holds, shapes how bold they can be.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, the cabinet is not named in the Constitution; it grew from Washington's practice. Second, White House staff such as the chief of staff need no Senate confirmation, while department heads do. Third, the nuclear option did not abolish the legislative filibuster; it removed the 60-vote hurdle for nominations only. Fourth, a recess appointment is temporary, ending with the Senate's next session. Fifth, unified party control does not guarantee success: Jimmy Carter often clashed with a Congress his own party controlled.
Key takeaways
Transitions run to 20 January, supported by the GSA. The cabinet has grown from four members to 15 department heads plus others of cabinet rank. The Senate confirms about 1,200 to 1,300 posts, and since 2013 and 2017 a simple majority can end debate on any nomination. Noel Canning (2014) let pro forma sessions block recess appointments. The EOP (1939) houses the president's closest staff, and the vice presidency has grown since Mondale. Honeymoons, the first hundred days and political time shape early agendas.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The handover period from election day to 20 January
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which of these officials can a president appoint without Senate confirmation?
Question 2 of 5
What did the Senate's 2017 "nuclear option" change?
Question 3 of 5
What did the Supreme Court decide in NLRB v. Noel Canning (2014)?
Question 4 of 5
Why do most presidents try to pass their main priorities in their first two years?
Question 5 of 5
Which change in the vice presidency began under Jimmy Carter?
