American Government › Section L · The presidency › Topic L.4
The public presidency
Modern presidents are on camera almost every day, speaking straight to the public through radio, television and social media. Reaching people is easier than ever, but turning public attention into votes in Congress is far harder than it looks.
Before mass media
For most of the nineteenth century, presidents had few ways to reach ordinary people. Inaugural addresses and annual messages to Congress were printed in newspapers, and some presidents toured the country, as George Washington did early in his presidency. Many relied on friendly editors; Ulysses S. Grant benefited from the cartoons of Thomas Nast. Abraham Lincoln wrote public letters meant for the press. Mostly, though, presidents worked through patronage, rewarding loyal supporters with government jobs, and private deals with party leaders in Congress. Civil service reform from the 1880s onwards, which required many jobs to be filled on merit, shrank that tool and pushed presidents to look for new sources of influence.
The bully pulpit
Theodore Roosevelt, president from 1901, called the office a "bully pulpit", using "bully" in its old sense of excellent: a platform from which to rally public opinion behind his agenda. He courted reporters and appeared in the newsreels that were becoming popular in cinemas. Woodrow Wilson revived the practice of delivering the annual message to Congress in person, and in 1919 he toured the country to build support for the League of Nations until he collapsed from exhaustion, days before a severe stroke. Their approach, appealing over the heads of Congress to the people, became a defining feature of the modern presidency.
Worked example: the first fireside chat
Trace how radio gave a president new influence. 1. When Franklin Roosevelt took office in March 1933, panicked depositors were pulling cash out of banks, and he ordered a national bank holiday. 2. On 12 March, a week after his inauguration, he spoke by radio directly to millions of listeners, explaining in plain language how banks worked and why reopened ones would be safe. 3. When banks reopened the next day, deposits began flowing back in rather than out. 4. Interpretation: historians credit the broadcast with helping restore confidence, alongside the emergency banking law Congress passed days earlier. 5. Roosevelt went on to give about thirty fireside chats by 1944. 6. Lesson: a direct, personal message can shape behaviour quickly in a crisis.
Television and the image presidency
Television made the president's face and manner part of the job. John F. Kennedy held the first live televised presidential news conferences in 1961, and his ease on camera helped his popularity. Ronald Reagan, a former actor, used carefully staged events and speeches so effectively that supporters called him the Great Communicator. Presidents gave prime-time addresses from the Oval Office, and Air Force One, in use since the 1950s, let them carry their message anywhere at short notice. Image also became a risk: a single gaffe or unflattering picture could now be replayed nationwide within hours.
Going public
The political scientist Samuel Kernell called the strategy of appealing directly to citizens, hoping they will pressure their representatives, going public. Presidents give national addresses, travel to swing districts and hold rallies. Does it work? George C. Edwards examined decades of polling and found that presidential speeches rarely change many minds; going public tends to energise supporters but can also harden opposition and make compromise harder. Political scientists now often contrast it with "staying private": quiet bargaining with members of Congress, which can leave both sides room to claim credit. Many presidents use both, depending on the issue.
Social media and the fragmented audience
The internet and social media let presidents skip journalists altogether. Barack Obama's campaigns pioneered online organising and fundraising, and in 2015 he opened the first @POTUS account on Twitter. Donald Trump went much further, often posting many times a day to promote policies and attack opponents, first on Twitter and later on his own platform, Truth Social. Yet the same technology works against presidents. Audiences are split across countless channels, many people never see a president's message, opponents can reply instantly, and news cycles move so fast that one announcement is quickly buried by the next. More ways to speak do not guarantee more people listening.
Approval ratings and the rally effect
Gallup has asked Americans whether they approve of the president's performance since the late 1930s, and members of Congress, journalists and donors watch these numbers closely. Approval usually starts high during the honeymoon and then drifts down as hard choices disappoint some supporters. Economic conditions, scandals and wars move it. International crises can produce a rally-round-the-flag effect: after the 11 September 2001 attacks, George W. Bush's approval reached 90%, the highest Gallup has recorded. Rallies rarely last. Popularity helps, but it does not translate automatically into legislative success, because members of Congress answer to their own voters.
The first lady's public role
The Constitution creates no role for the president's spouse, but first ladies have become public figures with their own staff and causes. Eleanor Roosevelt wrote a daily newspaper column, held press conferences and pushed for civil rights and anti-lynching laws. Lady Bird Johnson championed highway beautification, Betty Ford spoke openly about her breast cancer and backed the Equal Rights Amendment, and Nancy Reagan led the "Just Say No" anti-drug campaign. Most chose causes that drew broad support, such as Laura Bush's literacy work, Michelle Obama's campaign against childhood obesity and Melania Trump's "Be Best" initiative on children's well-being.
Worked example: a first lady in policy battles
Analyse why one first lady's policy role proved so controversial. 1. In 1993 President Bill Clinton put Hillary Clinton, a lawyer with long policy experience, in charge of his task force on health care reform. 2. This went beyond the usual role of championing a widely popular cause. 3. The plan faced opposition from many interest groups and from Republicans, and critics nicknamed it "Hillarycare", tying the policy to her personally. 4. The task force's meetings were held privately, which drew criticism and a lawsuit. 5. By 1994 the plan had died in Congress without a floor vote in either chamber. 6. Lesson: an unelected spouse who leads a divisive policy becomes a partisan target, which helps explain why later first ladies chose less contested causes.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, "bully pulpit" does not mean bullying; Roosevelt meant a splendid platform. Second, high approval does not guarantee that Congress will pass a president's programme, because members answer to their own constituents. Third, going public is not always effective; research suggests speeches seldom change many minds and can deepen divisions. Fourth, the first lady holds no constitutional or elected office, so her influence depends on her own standing and the president's choices. Fifth, social media gives presidents a direct channel, but it also gives opponents one.
Key takeaways
Nineteenth-century presidents relied on newspapers, tours, patronage and private bargaining. Theodore Roosevelt's bully pulpit, Franklin Roosevelt's fireside chats, televised news conferences from 1961 and, today, social media steadily widened the president's direct reach. Going public can mobilise supporters but may harden opposition, so presidents also stay private. Approval ratings, measured since the late 1930s, start high in the honeymoon, can spike in rallies such as late 2001, and usually decline. First ladies, from Eleanor Roosevelt onwards, have used their visibility for causes; Hillary Clinton's health care role showed the risks of taking on divisive policy.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Rewarding political supporters with government jobs
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did Theodore Roosevelt mean by calling the presidency a "bully pulpit"?
Question 2 of 5
According to George C. Edwards's research, what usually happens when presidents go public on an issue?
Question 3 of 5
What made Franklin Roosevelt's first fireside chat in March 1933 important?
Question 4 of 5
After the 11 September 2001 attacks, George W. Bush's approval reached 90%. What is this an example of?
Question 5 of 5
Why did Hillary Clinton's leadership of the 1993 health care task force prove so controversial?
