American Government › Section P · Domestic policy › Topic P.4

Policymakers

Behind every major policy are people who push for change and people who measure what change would cost. This topic meets both groups and follows a policy from the moment a problem gains attention to the day someone asks whether it worked.

Policy advocates

Most people hold opinions about policy but do little beyond voting. Policy advocates go further: they actively work to propose, change or defend a policy. Their position is normative, meaning it starts from a conviction about what ought to happen, and they then gather facts and arguments to win over officials and the public. Advocates include ordinary citizens, but the most effective are often professionals working for interest groups, lobbying firms and think tanks. Advocates can usually compromise more easily over how much money a programme receives than over issues they see as matters of principle, such as abortion or gun rights.

Worked example: an advocacy campaign

Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) was founded in 1980 by Candy Lightner after her daughter was killed by a drunk driver. 1. Goal: fewer alcohol-related crashes, including a minimum drinking age of 21. 2. Obstacle: drinking ages were set by the states, and many were lower. 3. Strategy: press Congress to use its spending power instead of lobbying 50 legislatures one by one. 4. Result: the National Minimum Drinking Age Act of 1984 withheld part of federal highway money from states with a lower age, and by 1988 every state had adopted 21. 5. Test: in South Dakota v. Dole (1987) the Supreme Court upheld the condition. Check: the advocates began with a goal and chose the venue most likely to deliver it.

Policy analysts

Policy analysts take a different approach. Instead of starting with the answer, they identify the realistic options open to decision makers and estimate each one's costs, benefits, winners and losers, including how people would respond. A new health programme's cost depends on its take-up, how many eligible people actually enrol, and on whether people drop coverage they already have in order to join. The analyst's job is to make sure decision makers understand the consequences of a choice, not to make the choice for them. In practice, analysts' assumptions often reflect the outlook of whoever employs them.

Analysts inside government

Both branches employ their own analysts. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO), set up under the Congressional Budget and Impoundment Control Act of 1974 and working from 1975, gives Congress non-partisan estimates, called scores, of what bills would cost. The Joint Committee on Taxation estimates the effects of tax bills. The Government Accountability Office audits how agencies spend money, and the Congressional Research Service briefs members on issues. In the executive branch, the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) prepares the President's budget and, through its regulatory office, reviews major rules, usually requiring an analysis of costs and benefits. Because OMB serves the President's priorities, it is less independent than CBO.

Think tanks

Outside government, think tanks produce research and proposals. Some, such as the RAND Corporation, founded in 1948, present themselves as non-partisan research organisations. Others openly start from a philosophy: the Heritage Foundation describes itself as conservative, the Cato Institute as libertarian and the Center for American Progress as progressive. Their reports can be careful and useful, but readers should ask who funded the work, what assumptions drive the results, and whether rival studies disagree. Businesses and trade associations also run their own policy units.

The policy process in stages

Political scientists often describe policymaking as a sequence of stages. Agenda setting comes first and has two parts: problem identification, deciding which issues deserve attention, and alternative specification, working out possible solutions. Next is enactment, when elected officials adopt a specific solution; many textbooks split this into formulation and adoption. Then comes implementation, when agencies carry the policy out, and finally evaluation, which asks whether it worked. Evaluation feeds back into the earlier stages, so the model is often drawn as a cycle. Real policymaking is messier, but the model organises analysis.

Getting on the agenda

Government can attend to only a limited number of issues, and many existing programmes already demand attention, so new problems compete fiercely for space. Framing matters: health reformers, for example, drew attention by stressing the number of people without insurance. The political scientist John Kingdon argued in 1984 that change happens when three streams come together: problems that people recognise, policy solutions that experts have prepared, and politics, meaning the public mood, elections and interest groups. When they align, a policy window opens, and policy entrepreneurs push their ideas through it. Focusing events, such as disasters, can open a window suddenly.

Implementation

Once a policy is enacted, agencies, states, localities and contractors carry it out. Implementation can be top-down, with Washington setting detailed rules that every state follows the same way, or bottom-up, with local areas given flexibility to meet their own needs. The political scientist Michael Lipsky pointed out in 1980 that street-level bureaucrats, such as teachers, police officers and benefit caseworkers, use discretion daily that shapes how a policy really works. Policies in one area are often shaped by iron triangles, stable alliances of a congressional committee, an agency and interest groups, or by looser issue networks of experts and advocates. The topic Controlling the bureaucracy examines these relationships.

Evaluation

Evaluation asks how well a policy did what it was designed to do, and at what cost. Simple before-and-after comparisons can mislead, because many other things change at the same time. Stronger designs compare people who received a programme with similar people who did not. In 2008 Oregon had money to add only some low-income adults to Medicaid and chose them by lottery, creating a natural experiment. Researchers found that coverage increased the use of health care and reduced financial strain and depression, but produced no statistically significant change in measured blood pressure, cholesterol or blood sugar in the first two years. Results like these feed back into the agenda.

Worked example: the stages after 11 September 2001

Follow airport security through the cycle. 1. Agenda setting: the attacks were a focusing event that made aviation security an urgent problem. 2. Alternatives: Congress debated tighter federal rules for private screening companies or a federal screening workforce. 3. Enactment: the Aviation and Transportation Security Act, signed on 19 November 2001, created the Transportation Security Administration (TSA). 4. Implementation: the TSA took over passenger screening at commercial airports, with federal screeners in place by the end of 2002. 5. Evaluation: covert tests by government inspectors have repeatedly found weaknesses, prompting new procedures and equipment. Check: evaluation fed back into the process, as the cycle model predicts.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming advocates ignore evidence: they use it, but to support a goal they have already chosen. Second, assuming analysts are always neutral; their assumptions can reflect their employers. Third, confusing CBO, which works for Congress, with OMB, which works for the President. Fourth, thinking enactment is the end of the story; implementation by agencies and street-level bureaucrats decides how a law works in practice. Fifth, judging a programme by a simple before-and-after comparison instead of comparing it with a similar group that did not receive it.

Key takeaways

Policy advocates start from a normative goal and work to achieve it; policy analysts set out options and estimate their effects. Congress relies on CBO, the Joint Committee on Taxation, GAO and the Congressional Research Service; the President relies on OMB. Think tanks range from self-described non-partisan to openly ideological. The policy process runs through agenda setting, enactment, implementation and evaluation, and evaluation feeds back into a cycle. Kingdon's three streams explain how policy windows open. Street-level bureaucrats shape implementation, and strong evaluations use a comparison group.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Policy advocate

A person who actively works to propose, change or defend a policy

Starts from what ought to happen.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What chiefly distinguishes a policy analyst from a policy advocate?

Question 2 of 5

Which body gives Congress non-partisan estimates of what proposed bills would cost?

Question 3 of 5

According to John Kingdon's model, when does major policy change become most likely?

Question 4 of 5

A caseworker decides how strictly to check the paperwork of families applying for food aid. Which idea does this illustrate?

Question 5 of 5

In the creation of the TSA, what role did the attacks of 11 September 2001 play in the policy process?

← Previous topicNext topic →