American Government › Section P · Domestic policy › Topic P.5

Budgeting and tax policy

Every year the federal government decides how to raise and spend trillions of dollars, and those choices reveal what the country values. This topic follows how the budget is made, why most of it runs on autopilot, and how taxes and the Federal Reserve fit in.

A budget is a statement of priorities

The federal fiscal year runs from 1 October to 30 September. According to the Treasury, in fiscal year 2026 the government spent about $7.40 trillion and collected about $5.40 trillion, leaving a deficit of about $1.99 trillion. The macroeconomics topics Government spending, Taxation and Federal deficits and the national debt explain where that money goes, where it comes from and how borrowing builds up. This topic looks at the politics: the ideas behind budget choices, who writes the budget and why much of it is hard to change.

Three approaches to the economy

Before the 1930s most policymakers favoured laissez-faire, leaving markets to recover from downturns on their own. The Great Depression challenged that view. The economist John Maynard Keynes argued in 1936 that a slump could persist because people and firms were not spending enough, so government should support demand through spending and tax relief. When high inflation and slow growth struck in the 1970s, supply-side economists such as Arthur Laffer argued that high tax rates and heavy regulation discouraged work and investment. Under President Ronald Reagan, laws in 1981 and 1986 cut the top income tax rate from 70% to 28%. Economists still debate how far tax cuts pay for themselves.

Who writes the budget

Congress holds the power of the purse, but the process starts with the President: the Office of Management and Budget assembles the President's budget request, due by the first Monday in February. The Congressional Budget and Impoundment Control Act of 1974 created budget committees in each chamber and the Congressional Budget Office. Congress is meant to adopt a budget resolution setting overall totals; it is not signed by the President and is not law. The appropriations committees then write 12 regular appropriations bills that fund agencies for the next fiscal year. In practice, Congress rarely passes all 12 on time.

Continuing resolutions and shutdowns

When the appropriations bills are not finished by 1 October, Congress usually passes a continuing resolution, a temporary law that keeps agencies funded, often at the previous year's level. If neither appropriations nor a continuing resolution is enacted, funding lapses and the government partly shuts down. Affected workers are sent home or, if their jobs protect life or property, work unpaid until funding returns. Mandatory programmes such as Social Security continue, because they do not depend on annual appropriations. The shutdown from 1 October to 12 November 2025, 43 days, was the longest in US history.

Mandatory spending and reconciliation

Mandatory spending, including Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, flows automatically under existing law and makes up well over half of federal outlays. Discretionary spending, about half of which goes to defence, is set each year in appropriations bills. Net interest must be paid on debt already issued. To change mandatory programmes or taxes, Congress must change the underlying laws. Budget reconciliation, created by the 1974 act, makes this easier: a reconciliation bill cannot be filibustered in the Senate, so it can pass with a simple majority, but it may contain only provisions that change spending, revenue or the debt limit. Both the 2017 tax law and the 2025 One Big Beautiful Bill Act passed this way.

Worked example: closing the deficit

Use the fiscal year 2026 figures: outlays $7.40 trillion, receipts $5.40 trillion, deficit $1.99 trillion, net interest $1.05 trillion. 1. Check the deficit: \(7.40 - 5.40 = 2.00\), which matches $1.99 trillion once rounding is allowed for. 2. Spending cuts alone, applied evenly to all outlays: \(1.99 \div 7.40 \approx 0.27\), a 27% cut. 3. Interest cannot be cut by Congress, so the remaining programmes would need \(1.99 \div (7.40 - 1.05) = 1.99 \div 6.35 \approx 0.31\), a 31% cut. 4. Tax rises alone: \(1.99 \div 5.40 \approx 0.37\), so receipts would need to rise about 37%. Check: either path is very large, so most proposals combine measures.

Deficits, debt and the debt limit

Each deficit adds to the national debt. The government last ran surpluses from fiscal year 1998 to 2001. By 30 September 2026, debt held by the public was about $32.4 trillion, roughly 100% of GDP, and total debt was about $40.2 trillion. Congress also sets a debt limit, a legal cap on total federal borrowing. Raising it does not authorise new spending; it lets the Treasury pay for spending and tax laws Congress has already passed. Standoffs over the limit have led to near misses, and the 2025 law raised it by $5 trillion.

Tax policy choices

Taxes pay for government, but they also change behaviour: taxing something tends to discourage it, which is why cigarette taxes are sometimes raised deliberately to reduce smoking. The federal income tax is progressive, taking a larger share of income from people with higher incomes, while some other taxes are regressive. Keynesians tend to favour leaving more money with households likely to spend it, which often means lower- and middle-income families. Supply-siders tend to favour lower marginal rates, especially on top earners and investment, to strengthen incentives. In fiscal year 2026, individual income taxes supplied about 53% of federal receipts, payroll taxes about 34% and corporate income taxes about 7%.

Worked example: why a fuel tax is regressive

The federal gasoline tax has been 18.4 cents a gallon since 1993. Compare two households. 1. Household A earns $40,000 and buys 700 gallons a year: tax \(700 \times 0.184 = 128.80\) dollars. 2. Share of income: \(128.80 \div 40{,}000 \approx 0.32\%\). 3. Household B earns $200,000 and buys 1,400 gallons: tax \(1{,}400 \times 0.184 = 257.60\) dollars. 4. Share of income: \(257.60 \div 200{,}000 \approx 0.13\%\). 5. Conclusion: B pays twice as many dollars but less than half the share of income, because its fuel buying rises much more slowly than its income. Check: a tax whose share of income falls as income rises is regressive.

Monetary policy and the Federal Reserve

Fiscal policy, taxing and spending, is set by Congress and the President. Monetary policy, the management of interest rates and the money supply, belongs to the Federal Reserve, created by the Federal Reserve Act of 1913 after repeated banking panics. Its seven governors serve staggered 14-year terms after Senate confirmation, which insulates them from election pressure, though how independent the Fed should be is debated. By law it seeks maximum employment, stable prices and moderate long-term interest rates, and it treats 2% inflation as stable prices. The macroeconomics topic The Federal Reserve and central banks covers it in depth.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking a shutdown stops all spending: mandatory programmes such as Social Security keep paying. Second, treating the budget resolution as a law; the President does not sign it. Third, believing that raising the debt limit approves new spending; it pays for laws already passed. Fourth, assuming a regressive tax charges lower earners more dollars; it takes a smaller share of income from higher earners. Fifth, confusing fiscal policy, made by Congress and the President, with monetary policy, made by the Fed, which has no fixed numerical target for unemployment.

Key takeaways

In fiscal year 2026 the government spent about $7.40 trillion, collected about $5.40 trillion and ran a deficit of about $1.99 trillion. Laissez-faire, Keynesian and supply-side ideas shape budget debates. The President proposes; Congress passes 12 appropriations bills, or a continuing resolution to avoid a shutdown. Mandatory spending runs under existing law, and reconciliation lets the Senate change it, and taxes, by simple majority. The debt limit caps borrowing for spending already approved. The Federal Reserve sets monetary policy separately.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Federal fiscal year

1 October to 30 September

Fiscal year 2026 ended on 30 September 2026.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What happens if, by 1 October, Congress has enacted neither the regular appropriations bills nor a continuing resolution?

Question 2 of 5

In fiscal year 2026, receipts were about $5.40 trillion and the deficit about $1.99 trillion. With spending unchanged, by roughly what percentage would receipts have needed to rise to close the deficit?

Question 3 of 5

What makes budget reconciliation important in the Senate?

Question 4 of 5

A household earning $40,000 pays $128.80 a year in federal gasoline tax, and one earning $200,000 pays $257.60. Why is this tax called regressive?

Question 5 of 5

Which goals does federal law set for the Federal Reserve?

← Previous topicNext topic →