American Government › Section B · The Constitution › Topic B.1

Roots of the American political tradition

The revolutionaries of 1776 did not invent their ideas from nothing. They drew on centuries of English law, on Enlightenment theories of natural rights and consent, and on more than 150 years of governing themselves in colonial assemblies.

Old ideas behind a new nation

When colonists protested British policy in the 1760s, they did not claim new rights. They claimed the traditional rights of English subjects, which they believed Parliament was violating. Three strands of thought fed their case: English legal traditions of limited government, the political philosophy of John Locke and other Enlightenment writers, and long experience of electing their own assemblies. This topic traces those roots and how they shaped American government. The events of the imperial crisis and the war are told in detail in the US History course; here the focus is on the ideas.

Magna Carta and English law

In 1215 King John of England, facing rebellious barons, agreed to Magna Carta, the Great Charter. It established that the king, too, was bound by law. One clause promised that no free man would be imprisoned or stripped of his property except by the lawful judgement of his peers or the law of the land, an early root of due process. Another required the common counsel of the realm before certain levies were raised. At first the charter protected mainly the barons, but by the 1600s English lawyers read it as a guarantee of liberty for all free subjects.

The Glorious Revolution and the Bill of Rights

In 1688 leading English politicians invited the Dutch prince William of Orange to act against James II, a Catholic king accused of ruling without regard to law. James fled, and his Protestant daughter Mary and her husband William took the throne. In 1689 Parliament passed the English Bill of Rights, a list of rights the Crown could not override. It required Parliament's consent for taxes and for a standing army in peacetime, protected the right to petition the monarch, called for free elections, allowed Protestants to keep arms, and banned excessive bail, excessive fines and cruel and unusual punishments. Americans later borrowed several of these protections almost word for word.

John Locke: natural rights and consent

John Locke's Two Treatises of Government, published late in 1689, gave these claims a philosophical basis and is often read as a defence of the Glorious Revolution, though much of it was written years earlier. Locke argued that people possess natural rights to life, liberty and property, given by God and not by any ruler. To protect those rights, people agree to form a government and accept its laws, an agreement later called the social contract. A government's authority therefore rests on the consent of the governed. If rulers abuse that trust and systematically violate rights, the people may resist and establish a new government.

Montesquieu and the republican tradition

Other writers added further ideas. The French philosopher Montesquieu, in The Spirit of the Laws of 1748, argued that liberty was safest when legislative, executive and judicial powers were held by separate bodies, a principle the framers would build into the Constitution. Colonists also read English opposition writers who warned that power constantly threatened liberty, and they admired the Roman Republic. Those republican ideas, including civic virtue and suspicion of hereditary rule, are covered in the US History topic From monarchy to republic. Together, these sources taught that government must be limited, divided and accountable.

Colonial self-government

Ideas were reinforced by practice. Virginia's House of Burgesses, first meeting in 1619, was the earliest elected assembly in the English colonies. In 1620 the Plymouth settlers signed the Mayflower Compact, agreeing to form a civil body politic and obey laws made for the general good. By the mid-1750s every colony had an elected assembly that passed laws and voted taxes, and many New England towns governed local matters in town meetings. Voting was limited mostly to property-owning White men, yet historians estimate that a far larger share of men could vote than in England, because land was easier to acquire.

Representation and the imperial crisis

After the Seven Years' War ended in 1763, Parliament began taxing the colonies to help pay its war debts and the cost of troops in America. The Stamp Act of 1765 and the Townshend Acts of 1767 provoked fierce protest. British officials argued that colonists enjoyed virtual representation: Parliament represented every subject, whether or not they voted for a member. Colonists insisted on actual representation: only representatives they had elected, in their own assemblies, could tax them. The dispute escalated through the Coercive Acts of 1774 and the First Continental Congress to war in April 1775.

Worked example: the representation argument

Trace the logic of no taxation without representation. 1. The principle: English tradition, from Magna Carta to the Bill of Rights, held that subjects could be taxed only with their consent, given through representatives. 2. The fact: colonists elected no members of the House of Commons. 3. British reply: virtual representation, since most people in Britain could not vote either but were considered represented. 4. Colonial rebuttal: their own elected assemblies were their true representatives. 5. Consequence: if Parliament could tax them without consent, colonists argued, their property and liberty were no longer secure. 6. Check: the argument used English principles against an English Parliament.

The Declaration as political theory

The Declaration of Independence, drafted mainly by Thomas Jefferson and adopted on 4 July 1776, turned these ideas into a public justification for breaking away. It states "that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness." Governments are instituted to secure these rights, "deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed", and when a government becomes destructive of those ends, the people may alter or abolish it. The long list of grievances that follows was meant to prove that George III had broken that contract.

Worked example: Locke and the Declaration side by side

Compare the Declaration with Locke. 1. Rights: Locke named life, liberty and property; the Declaration names life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. 2. Source of rights: both say they come from God, not rulers. 3. Purpose of government: both say it exists to protect those rights and rests on consent. 4. Right of revolution: Locke allowed resistance after a long train of abuses; the Declaration uses almost the same phrase. 5. Limit: in practice, neither extended these rights to enslaved people, women or Native nations, a gap the US History course explores. 6. Conclusion: the Declaration adapts Locke's theory rather than copying it.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking Magna Carta created democracy: it limited the king and protected mainly the barons at first. Second, assuming the Declaration created a government; it justified independence and left the design of government to later debates. Third, assuming colonists objected to all taxes: they objected to taxes imposed by a Parliament in which they had no representatives. Fourth, confusing Locke's social contract with a written document; it is a theory of how legitimate government arises. Fifth, imagining colonial assemblies were elected by everyone; most voters were property-owning White men.

Key takeaways

American political ideas grew from English law, Enlightenment philosophy and colonial practice. Magna Carta (1215) bound the king by law, and the English Bill of Rights (1689) required Parliament's consent for taxes and banned cruel and unusual punishments. Locke argued for natural rights, government by consent and a right of revolution; Montesquieu argued for separating powers. Colonists governed themselves through elected assemblies from 1619. When Parliament taxed them after 1763, they rejected virtual representation, and the Declaration of 1776 justified independence in Lockean terms.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Magna Carta, 1215

Charter binding the English king by law

Lawful judgement of peers: a root of due process.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

According to John Locke, where does a government's legitimate authority come from?

Question 2 of 5

British officials argued that colonists were represented in Parliament even though they elected no members. What was this idea called?

Question 3 of 5

Which right is named in the Declaration of Independence but replaced the word property in Locke's list?

Question 4 of 5

Montesquieu's main contribution to the framers' thinking was the argument that liberty is safest when

Question 5 of 5

Why is Virginia's House of Burgesses important in the history of American government?

← Previous topicNext topic →