American Government › Section B · The Constitution › Topic B.2

The Articles of Confederation

The first national government of the United States was designed above all to avoid tyranny. It succeeded in that, but it left Congress unable to tax, regulate trade or enforce its decisions, and its failures shaped every choice made in 1787.

A government for wartime

Declaring independence in 1776 created thirteen states, each with its own new constitution, but no agreed national government. Fighting Britain required one: someone had to direct the army, borrow money and make treaties with foreign powers such as France. The Second Continental Congress appointed a committee, and a draft largely written by John Dickinson became the Articles of Confederation. Congress adopted them in November 1777 and sent them to the states, but they needed approval from all thirteen. They took effect only in March 1781, after Maryland, as the US History course explains, held out until states such as Virginia gave up their western land claims.

Confederal, federal and unitary systems

Governments divide power between the centre and the parts in three broad ways. In a unitary system, such as Britain's, the central government holds ultimate power and local bodies have only what it grants. In a confederation, sovereign states form a union for limited shared purposes, and the central body depends on them. In a federal system, which the Constitution later created, power is divided between a national government and the states, each acting directly on citizens. The Articles were plainly confederal. They called the union "a firm league of friendship", and Article II declared: "Each state retains its sovereignty, freedom, and independence".

How the Confederation Congress worked

The national government was a single body, the Confederation Congress. State legislatures appointed its delegates, between two and seven per state, and could recall them at any time. No one could serve more than three years in any six, a rule meant to prevent a class of permanent politicians. Each state cast one vote, regardless of population. Most important decisions, such as making war, signing treaties or borrowing money, needed the votes of nine of the thirteen states. There was no separate executive: the President of Congress only presided over debates. There was no national court system for ordinary cases.

Powers given and powers withheld

Congress could declare war and make peace, conduct diplomacy, make treaties, coin and borrow money, run a postal service, manage relations with Native nations outside state borders, and settle disputes between states. What it lacked mattered more. It could not tax: under Article VIII it could only ask each state for a share of expenses, calculated by the value of its land. It could not regulate trade between the states or with other countries. It could not raise troops directly, only request quotas from the states. Above all, its decisions applied to state governments, not to individual citizens, so it had no means of enforcing them.

Why so weak? A deliberate design

The weakness was intentional. Americans had just rebelled against a distant government that, in their view, taxed them without consent and used soldiers against them. Many believed that liberty was safest in small republics close to the people, and that a powerful central government would inevitably drift towards tyranny. Keeping taxation in state hands meant no repeat of taxation without representation. Leaving armies to the states guarded against a standing army controlled by the centre. Requiring unanimity for amendments protected each state from being outvoted on the terms of the union itself.

Worked example: the requisition problem

Trace why asking the states for money failed. 1. The request: Congress set each state's share of national expenses and asked it to pay. 2. Competing pressures: every state also had war debts of its own and citizens resisting high taxes. 3. The incentive: each state reasoned that if others paid, the union survived anyway, and if others did not, its own payment would be wasted. 4. The result: historians agree that the states paid only a small fraction of what Congress requested. 5. The consequence: Congress could not pay soldiers or creditors, and the union's credit collapsed. 6. Check: this is a collective action problem, a theme a later topic examines.

Trying to fix it: the impost

Leaders saw the problem and tried to repair it within the rules. In 1781 Congress proposed an amendment allowing it to collect a 5 percent duty on imports, called an impost, to pay the national debt. Most states agreed, but Rhode Island refused in November 1782, Virginia then withdrew its approval, and because amendments needed every state, the plan died. A revised revenue plan in 1783 met the same fate when New York attached conditions in 1786 that Congress could not accept. The unanimity rule meant that a single state could block reform supported by all the rest, which persuaded many nationalists that patching the Articles would never work.

Trade, diplomacy and defence

Without power over commerce, Congress could not answer when Britain restricted American trade with its Caribbean colonies, and some states taxed goods from their neighbours, though historians debate how serious these barriers were. Foreign governments saw a weak partner. Britain kept forts on American soil around the Great Lakes, citing unpaid debts owed to British creditors and unfair treatment of Loyalists. Spain closed the lower Mississippi to American shipping in 1784. With the Continental Navy disbanded, Congress could not protect merchant ships from capture off North Africa. Yet the Confederation won the war, secured the 1783 Treaty of Paris and passed lasting land ordinances.

Worked example: Shays's Rebellion as a stress test

Use the uprising, told in detail in the US History course, to test the Articles. 1. The crisis: in 1786 and early 1787, indebted Massachusetts farmers, many of them veterans, closed courts to stop foreclosures. 2. The national response: Congress voted to enlarge its small army, officially for frontier defence, but could not pay for the troops. 3. The state response: Massachusetts suppressed the rebels with militia funded by Boston merchants. 4. The reaction: George Washington and other nationalists were alarmed, while Thomas Jefferson, in Paris, wrote in 1787, "I hold it that a little rebellion now and then is a good thing". 5. Conclusion: the national government had proved unable to act.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling the Articles a federal system: they created a confederation of sovereign states. Second, saying Congress had no powers; it could make war, treaties and money, but could not tax, regulate commerce or enforce its decisions on individuals. Third, thinking the weaknesses were accidents; they reflected deliberate fears of central power. Fourth, assuming the President of Congress was a chief executive; the office only presided. Fifth, claiming every state had to approve ordinary laws; most major measures needed nine states, while amendments needed all thirteen.

Key takeaways

The Articles of Confederation, adopted by Congress in 1777 and in force from March 1781, created a confederation: a league of sovereign states. A one-house Congress, with one vote per state, had no executive or national courts, needed nine states for major measures and unanimity for amendments. It could not tax, regulate commerce, raise troops directly or act on individuals. Requisitions went largely unpaid, and impost amendments failed when single states refused. Despite real achievements, such as the peace treaty and land ordinances, Shays's Rebellion convinced many leaders that a stronger government was needed.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Articles of Confederation

First national plan of government, in force from March 1781

Adopted by Congress in November 1777.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why were the Articles of Confederation a confederal rather than a federal system?

Question 2 of 5

In 1782 one state's refusal killed a proposed 5 percent import duty for Congress. Which feature of the Articles made that possible?

Question 3 of 5

Which power did the Confederation Congress have?

Question 4 of 5

Why did Congress's system of requisitions raise so little money?

Question 5 of 5

What best explains why the authors of the Articles made the national government so weak?

← Previous topicNext topic →