American Government › Section N · State and local government › Topic N.2

State political culture

Why do some states make voting as easy as possible while others leave politics to a few? One influential answer is political culture: the beliefs a state's people share about what government is for and who should take part in it.

Why states differ

States differ in obvious material ways. Alaska's oil revenue lets it pay residents a yearly dividend from its Permanent Fund, and states without an income tax, such as Florida and Texas, rely more on sales and property taxes. But states with similar economies can still govern very differently: one may have high turnout and strict ethics rules, another a long tradition of party machines. Political scientists use the term political culture for the shared attitudes and beliefs in a place about the purpose of government, the duties of officials and the role of ordinary citizens. Culture is one explanation for such differences, alongside wealth, population and party.

Elazar's three cultures

The most cited account comes from the political scientist Daniel Elazar, in his book American Federalism: A View from the States, first published in 1966. Elazar argued that the country contains three political subcultures: moralistic, individualistic and traditionalistic. Each began with a different stream of settlers whose religious and political values shaped what they expected of government. As those groups moved west, they carried their cultures with them, so the map of cultures runs roughly in east-west bands. Elazar stressed that most states blend two cultures, with one usually dominant, and that a single state can contain pockets of all three.

The moralistic culture

In a moralistic culture, government is a commonwealth: a means of building a good society and advancing the public interest. Officials are expected to be honest and to serve the community rather than themselves, so tolerance for corruption is low. Taking part in politics is seen as every citizen's duty, so laws tend to make registering and voting easy, and elections are often genuinely contested. Government may act on a problem even before the public demands it. Elazar traced this culture to Puritan New England; Scandinavian and other northern European settlers later reinforced it across the upper Midwest and on to the Pacific Northwest, in states such as Minnesota, Wisconsin and Oregon.

The individualistic culture

In an individualistic culture, government works like a marketplace. It exists to provide services people want and to keep order, not to remake society, and it acts mainly when there is demand. Politics is treated as a profession, even a business, run by organised parties that reward loyal supporters with jobs and contracts, a practice called patronage. Voters tend to be loyal to their party, and some corruption is tolerated as a cost of getting things done. Elazar traced this culture to non-Puritan English and German settlers in the middle Atlantic states, such as New York, New Jersey and Pennsylvania, from where it spread west across the middle of the country through Ohio and Illinois.

The traditionalistic culture

In a traditionalistic culture, government's main role is to preserve the existing social order. Politics is led by established elites, often from leading families, and participation by ordinary citizens is not especially encouraged. Elazar linked this culture to the plantation economy of the South, where slavery and later legal segregation concentrated power in a small group. After Reconstruction, poll taxes, literacy tests and white primaries kept most Black citizens and many poor white citizens from voting. For much of the twentieth century the South was a one-party region, where real contests happened between factions inside the Democratic Party; after the civil rights era, the region moved towards the Republican Party.

Worked example: testing the theory on Minnesota

Elazar classified Minnesota as strongly moralistic. Test what the theory predicts. 1. Prediction: high participation. Evidence: Minnesota has allowed registration on election day since 1974, and its turnout in presidential elections is regularly among the highest of any state. 2. Prediction: low tolerance of corruption and interest in good government. Evidence: the state has a reputation for clean politics and strong civic groups, though such reputations are hard to measure. 3. Prediction: openness to candidates outside the two main parties. Evidence: a third-party candidate, Jesse Ventura of the Reform Party, won the governorship in 1998. 4. Conclusion: the evidence fits, but each point could also reflect education levels, income or specific laws.

Worked example: reading the cultures in a debate

Imagine three legislators arguing over a proposal to fund a new job-training programme. 1. Legislator A says the state has a duty to help struggling residents, whether or not anyone is lobbying for it. That fits a moralistic view of government as a tool for the common good. 2. Legislator B says the programme is worth it if local businesses want trained workers and voters reward it at the polls. That is the individualistic marketplace view. 3. Legislator C says the state should leave such matters to the community leaders who have always handled them. That echoes the traditionalistic view. 4. Lesson: the cultures describe beliefs about government's purpose, not positions of one party.

Putting numbers on culture

Elazar's map was built from historical and qualitative study, not surveys. In 1969 the political scientist Ira Sharkansky turned it into a numerical scale, scoring each state from most moralistic to most traditionalistic, so that researchers could test the theory against data. Studies using such scores have found that more moralistic states tend to have higher turnout and to spend more on some public services, while more traditionalistic states tend to have lower turnout. But the links are often modest, and once researchers control for income, education and race, culture sometimes explains less than the theory suggests.

Criticisms of Elazar's theory

Critics raise several problems. First, the theory rests on European settlement streams, but most immigrants today come from Latin America and Asia, and generations of movement between states, for jobs, housing or retirement, have mixed their populations. Second, divides within states, especially between big cities and rural areas, can be wider than divides between states, and a state-level label hides them. Third, culture is hard to define and measure precisely, which limits its power in research. Fourth, labels risk turning into stereotypes about a region's people. Defenders reply that early settlers built institutions and habits that can persist long after the original population has changed.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, "moralistic" does not mean that people in those states are more moral; it describes a belief that government should pursue the common good. Second, "individualistic" does not mean anti-government; it describes a marketplace view in which government supplies what people demand. Third, the cultures are not the same as the two parties, or as liberal and conservative: each party has held power in states of every culture. Fourth, Elazar did not claim that every state has exactly one culture; most are mixtures. Fifth, culture is a tendency, not a law, so a single election result neither proves nor disproves it.

Key takeaways

Political culture is a shared set of beliefs about what government is for and who should take part. Daniel Elazar (1966) described three cultures carried west by settlers: moralistic, which sees government as a commonwealth and values participation and clean politics; individualistic, which treats government as a marketplace run by organised parties; and traditionalistic, which uses government to preserve the existing order under established elites. Sharkansky (1969) turned the map into a scale, and studies find modest links to turnout and spending. Critics point to new migration patterns, urban-rural divides and problems of measurement.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Political culture

Shared beliefs about the purpose of government and the role of citizens

One explanation for differences between states.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A state's officials say government should tackle a problem even before anyone demands action, and the state makes voting as easy as possible. Which culture does this best fit?

Question 2 of 5

Where did Elazar trace the origins of the individualistic culture?

Question 3 of 5

In Elazar's account, how does party competition typically work in a traditionalistic culture?

Question 4 of 5

Which is a criticism of Elazar's theory discussed in the reading?

Question 5 of 5

A student says: "Moralistic states are the ones where people behave more morally." What is wrong with this?

← Previous topicNext topic →